I would like to say that I feel that in this list, and most of the more recent lists, that people have been doing a pretty good job of acknowledging the positive points of entries they don't particularly care for. I do understand why someone would feel uncomfortable with people expressing the fact that something is not their cup of tea, given that, for a while, things could get quite nasty. The JRPG list, while being the biggest Top 50 we've ever done, was rife with negative energy, including from the people running it, so I can understand where that might have soured anyone on any less than 100% positive discussion in these lists.
I do think, myself, that saying "entry x is great for these reasons, but it's not for me because of those reasons" doesn't detract from the overall positive tone those of us running the lists have been trying to set. YMMV of course, and I'm not going to tell you how to feel about it, but them's my two cents.