Okay, so Kermit's definitely winning this thing, right? The other two have a bit more mystery to them. I'd guess Cookie Monster is the runner up and Audrey II takes bronze. I don't know if I would have guessed Cookie Monster would be the favorite Sesame Street Muppet (I know, Kermit's a Sesame Street Muppet too, at least formerly), but thinking about it, I can see it. I could be wrong, but I'd be way more shocked that he was outside the top 50 than to see him make the top 3.
I would be a bit (very pleasantly) surprised to see Audrey II this high, but again, not as surprised as seeing it completely miss the list. I suppose it's a cross-section of things that I'm quite confident are well-liked on Talking Time: movie monsters, awesome special effects, good songs, Frank Oz, and Rick Moranis.