Closing thoughts
Here's the master spreadsheet. I've collected some interesting data points below, but all of this and more can be found on the spreadsheet.
In case it wasn't obvious, Kanto was far and away the most-represented region, comprising 23 of the 52 mons featured here. We're a bunch of old farts. We didn't get any Paldean Pokémon, which I suspect would change if we re-ran the poll today, but Sprigatito, Fuecoco, and Lechonk all missed the list by less than 10 points.
The only #1 pick that did not make the list was Torzelbaum's Ninjask. In total, 140 Pokémon received a single vote, and there were an additional 35 Pokémon with two votes (or three in Wooloo's case!) that did not make the cut.
Our biggest ties were for 37th (Dunsparce, Hydreigon, Mew, Torterra, Tyranitar) and 56th (Emolga, Mankey, Primarina, Snorunt, Venusaur). Well, for Pokémon that received more than one vote, anyway -- if you include the one-offs, the largest tie is for 197th, indicating that voters were most likely to get creative for their 19th-place vote.
The highest-placing Pokémon to receive a 1st-place vote was Bulbasaur, sitting in 5th place on our list. The biggest disparity between list rank and voter ranks is Gyarados, who bagged 12th on the big list despite no one giving it better than 8th on any individual list.
Our most popular evolutionary lines -- those with multiple entries on our list -- are Rowlet/Decidueye, Scyther/Scizor, Farfetch'd/Sirfetch'd, and of course Eevee/Sylveon/Umbreon. Jolteon took 64th, Espeon 99th, Vaporeon 206th, and Glaceon 244th.
Our top two, Psyduck and Rowlet, received 8 votes apiece, meaning half of the 17 voters picked each of them.
Speaking of which, 17 voters was an amazing and humbling turnout. I want to thank everyone who voted as well as those who just read along. Running one of these can be exhausting, but you've made it worthwhile. I especially want to thank Kirin, who not only provided the GO Corner for each entry and covered for me on many occasions but also provided the inspiration for the metanarrative, including the Psyduck ending. (And thanks again to our Psyduck voters for giving us a satisfying way to follow up our gag #1, MissingNo.)