• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
More interesting than the giant list is where each Doctor's best story falls. This isn't too bad a list:

1st Doctor: The Myth Makers #21
2nd Doctor: The Enemy of the World #2
3rd Doctor: The Three Doctors #24
4th Doctor: City of Death #15
5th Doctor: The Caves of Androzani #10
6th Doctor: Vengeance on Varos #96
7th Doctor: Ghost Light #16
8th Doctor: Doctor Who: The Movie #294
9th Doctor: The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances #12
10th Doctor: Blink #4
11th Doctor: The Day of the Doctor #5
12th Doctor: Hell Bent #1
13th Doctor: Rosa #109
14th Doctor: Wild Blue Yonder #64
15th Doctor: 73 Yards #6

I like 73 Yards a lot, but I can't imagine it'd be in my top ten if I made this list manually. And yeah, Rosa is probably my favorite 13th Doctor episode, although it'd be between it and Demons of the Punjab which I'd have thought would be higher. Who knows, it's a weird way to make a list.
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
I adore The Three Doctors, but yeah, it's not great as a representative 3rd Doctor story, even though Pertwee is great in it. It does have most of his era's supporting cast, though, so it definitely feels of his era.

Eight is a laugh, especially since I didn't click the minisode option, given Night of the Doctor is the only one of those I care about. Well, that's not entirely true, Time Crash is fun, but Night is the crown jewel of DW mini episodes... The TV Movie is actually decently placed. I do like it more than everything below it, at the very least...
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
It's a shame RTD isn't writing 73 Yards, but oh well. I'll certainly post here whether Scott Handcock lives up to the transmitted episode when I receive the book.
 

Phantoon

I cuss you bad
I took a Doctor Who ranking thing, linked here. What's nice about it is you can do it by Doctor, season, or individual stories, so you can exclude stuff you haven't seen, both from the classic series and new series. Here are my results:

  1. Hell Bent
  2. The Enemy of the World
  3. The Power of the Daleks
  4. Blink
  5. The Day of the Doctor
  6. 73 Yards
  7. The Zygon Invasion / The Zygon Inversion
  8. Midnight
  9. The War Games
  10. The Caves of Androzani
  11. The Eleventh Hour
  12. The Empty Child / The Doctor Dances
  13. Snakedance
  14. Human Nature / The Family of Blood
  15. City of Death
  16. Ghost Light
  17. The Brain of Morbius
  18. The Robots of Death
  19. Silence in the Library / Forest of the Dead
  20. Flatline
  21. The Myth Makers
  22. Kinda
  23. The Girl in the Fireplace
  24. The Three Doctors
  25. The Macra Terror
  26. Paradise Towers
  27. The Mind Robber
  28. Heaven Sent
  29. Genesis of the Daleks
  30. The Ambassadors of Death
  31. Love & Monsters
  32. Remembrance of the Daleks
  33. Vincent and the Doctor
  34. Gridlock
  35. The Evil of the Daleks
  36. The Happiness Patrol
  37. The Pandorica Opens / The Big Bang
  38. The Sun Makers
  39. The Ribos Operation
  40. The Ark in Space
  41. Kill the Moon
  42. World Enough and Time / The Doctor Falls
  43. The Curse of Fenric
  44. The Impossible Planet / The Satan Pit
  45. Mummy on the Orient Express
  46. Listen
  47. Carnival of Monsters
  48. The Doctor's Wife
  49. The Magician's Apprentice / The Witch's Familiar
  50. The Massacre
  51. Face the Raven
  52. The Stolen Earth / Journey's End
  53. Logopolis
  54. The Waters of Mars
  55. The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords
  56. Boom
  57. A Christmas Carol
  58. The Snowmen
  59. The Five Doctors
  60. An Unearthly Child
  61. Planet of the Ood
  62. Thin Ice
  63. Army of Ghosts / Doomsday
  64. Wild Blue Yonder
  65. The Curse of Peladon
  66. Terror of the Zygons
  67. Oxygen
  68. Marco Polo
  69. Let's Kill Hitler
  70. School Reunion
  71. Rose
  72. The Pirate Planet
  73. The Giggle
  74. Dalek
  75. Enlightenment
  76. The Deadly Assassin
  77. Mawdryn Undead
  78. Black Orchid
  79. The Talons of Weng-Chiang
  80. The Invasion
  81. The Impossible Astronaut / Day of the Moon
  82. The Girl Who Waited
  83. The Rescue
  84. The Green Death
  85. Dark Water / Death in Heaven
  86. The Krotons
  87. Frontios
  88. The Dalek Invasion of Earth
  89. The Daleks' Master Plan
  90. Survival
  91. Utopia
  92. Father's Day
  93. The Husbands of River Song
  94. The Aztecs
  95. Bad Wolf / The Parting of the Ways
  96. Vengeance on Varos
  97. Warriors' Gate
  98. Revelation of the Daleks
  99. The Abominable Snowmen
  100. The Wheel in Space
  101. The Tenth Planet
  102. The Claws of Axos
  103. The Dæmons
  104. The Pilot
  105. Robot of Sherwood
  106. Rogue
  107. The Gunfighters
  108. The Daleks
  109. Rosa
  110. The Time of Angels / Flesh and Stone
  111. Mission to the Unknown
  112. The Web of Fear
  113. The Romans
  114. A Good Man Goes to War
  115. The Two Doctors
  116. Spearhead from Space
  117. Smith and Jones
  118. Amy's Choice
  119. Turn Left
  120. The Crusade
  121. The Moonbase
  122. The Devil's Chord
  123. Twice Upon a Time
  124. Pyramids of Mars
  125. The End of Time
  126. The Star Beast
  127. The Face of Evil
  128. Deep Breath
  129. The Caretaker
  130. Asylum of the Daleks
  131. Robot
  132. Earthshock
  133. Full Circle
  134. Last Christmas
  135. The Keeper of Traken
  136. The Underwater Menace
  137. State of Decay
  138. Day of the Daleks
  139. The Fires of Pompeii
  140. The Church on Ruby Road
  141. The Time Meddler
  142. The Greatest Show in the Galaxy
  143. Horror of Fang Rock
  144. The Time of the Doctor
  145. The Wedding of River Song
  146. The Time Warrior
  147. Fury from the Deep
  148. The Witchfinders
  149. The Stones of Blood
  150. The God Complex
  151. The Tomb of the Cybermen
  152. The Faceless Ones
  153. Colony in Space
  154. The Androids of Tara
  155. The Girl Who Died
  156. The Awakening
  157. Fugitive of the Judoon
  158. The Space Pirates
  159. War of the Sontarans
  160. The Eaters of Light
  161. The Return of Doctor Mysterio
  162. Delta and the Bannermen
  163. Frontier in Space
  164. The Visitation
  165. Boom Town
  166. The Beast Below
  167. Once, Upon Time
  168. Planet of the Daleks
  169. The Seeds of Doom
  170. Arc of Infinity
  171. Dragonfire
  172. The Power of Three
  173. The Mysterious Planet
  174. The Mark of the Rani
  175. The Unquiet Dead
  176. The Space Museum
  177. The Rings of Akhaten
  178. Demons of the Punjab
  179. Sleep No More
  180. Inferno
  181. Castrovalva
  182. The Name of the Doctor
  183. Terminus
  184. The Lodger
  185. The End of the World
  186. Voyage of the Damned
  187. Nikola Tesla's Night of Terror
  188. The Armageddon Factor
  189. The Creature from the Pit
  190. The Vampires of Venice
  191. The Masque of Mandragora
  192. The Angels Take Manhattan
  193. The Hungry Earth / Cold Blood
  194. Cold War
  195. The Woman Who Lived
  196. The Halloween Apocalypse
  197. Under the Lake / Before the Flood
  198. 42
  199. The Android Invasion
  200. Smile
  201. The Mind of Evil
  202. Doctor Who and the Silurians
  203. The Woman Who Fell to Earth
  204. The Seeds of Death
  205. The Ark
  206. Resurrection of the Daleks
  207. Daleks in Manhattan / Evolution of the Daleks
  208. The Legend of Ruby Sunday / Empire of Death
  209. Terror of the Autons
  210. The Mutants
  211. Into the Dalek
  212. New Earth
  213. Partners in Crime
  214. Empress of Mars
  215. The Time Monster
  216. The Sensorites
  217. The Haunting of Villa Diodati
  218. The War Machines
  219. The Sea Devils
  220. Extremis
  221. Nightmare in Silver
  222. Rise of the Cybermen / The Age of Steel
  223. Time Heist
  224. Attack of the Cybermen
  225. The Monster of Peladon
  226. The Tsuranga Conundrum
  227. Resolution
  228. The Long Game
  229. Planet of Evil
  230. The Sontaran Stratagem / The Poison Sky
  231. Terror of the Vervoids
  232. Revenge of the Cybermen
  233. The Edge of Destruction
  234. Tooth and Claw
  235. Planet of Giants
  236. Image of the Fendahl
  237. The Hand of Fear
  238. It Takes You Away
  239. The Bells of Saint John
  240. The Invasion of Time
  241. Dot and Bubble
  242. Eve of the Daleks
  243. Knock Knock
  244. The Christmas Invasion
  245. Can You Hear Me?
  246. Closing Time
  247. The Power of Kroll
  248. Victory of the Daleks
  249. Destiny of the Daleks
  250. Aliens of London / World War Three
  251. Meglos
  252. Four to Doomsday
  253. A Town Called Mercy
  254. The Ice Warriors
  255. The Runaway Bride
  256. The Shakespeare Code
  257. Galaxy 4
  258. The Idiot's Lantern
  259. Night Terrors
  260. Revolution of the Daleks
  261. Time-Flight
  262. The Unicorn and the Wasp
  263. The Crimson Horror
  264. Hide
  265. Village of the Angels
  266. The Savages
  267. Invasion of the Dinosaurs
  268. Battlefield
  269. The Power of the Doctor
  270. Orphan 55
  271. The Sontaran Experiment
  272. The Pyramid at the End of the World
  273. Planet of Fire
  274. Kerblam!
  275. The Rebel Flesh / The Almost People
  276. Warriors of the Deep
  277. Arachnids in the UK
  278. Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS
  279. The Ghost Monument
  280. Spyfall
  281. Praxeus
  282. The Reign of Terror
  283. The Web Planet
  284. Time and the Rani
  285. Mindwarp
  286. The Horns of Nimon
  287. The Invisible Enemy
  288. The Leisure Hive
  289. Timelash
  290. Dinosaurs on a Spaceship
  291. Silver Nemesis
  292. The Keys of Marinus
  293. The Lie of the Land
  294. Doctor Who: The Movie
  295. The Smugglers
  296. Space Babies
  297. In the Forest of the Night
  298. The Vanquishers
  299. Fear Her
  300. Underworld
  301. Shada
  302. Nightmare of Eden
  303. The Lazarus Experiment
  304. The Curse of the Black Spot
  305. Death to the Daleks
  306. The Highlanders
  307. Planet of the Spiders
  308. The Celestial Toymaker
  309. Survivors of the Flux
  310. The King's Demons
  311. Legend of the Sea Devils
  312. The Ultimate Foe
  313. The Doctor's Daughter
  314. The Next Doctor
  315. The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe
  316. Planet of the Dead
  317. The Chase
  318. The Dominators
  319. The Twin Dilemma
  320. The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos
  321. Ascension of the Cybermen / The Timeless Children

Furious at some of these (not really, it's just a dumb online test, but, you know lol). The top two should be reversed at the very least - I'm pretty certain they never went up against each other. Bottom five are solid.
I stuck to things I'd seen recently (glad I did, it took ages even with that), and here's the top twenty:

  1. Heaven Sent
  2. A Christmas Carol
  3. The Day of the Doctor
  4. The Doctor's Wife
  5. The Eleventh Hour
  6. The Zygon Invasion / The Zygon Inversion
  7. Dark Water / Death in Heaven
  8. The Pandorica Opens / The Big Bang
  9. Genesis of the Daleks
  10. Ghost Light
  11. Remembrance of the Daleks
  12. World Enough and Time / The Doctor Falls
  13. The Magician's Apprentice / The Witch's Familiar
  14. The Curse of Fenric
  15. The Impossible Astronaut / Day of the Moon
  16. Amy's Choice
  17. Listen
  18. The Lodger
  19. The Name of the Doctor
  20. The Deadly Assassin
Don't think I can argue with that

Also, Ghost Light is very high on yours, I see you are a man of taste
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
I stuck to things I'd seen recently (glad I did, it took ages even with that), and here's the top twenty:

  1. Heaven Sent
  2. A Christmas Carol
  3. The Day of the Doctor
  4. The Doctor's Wife
  5. The Eleventh Hour
  6. The Zygon Invasion / The Zygon Inversion
  7. Dark Water / Death in Heaven
  8. The Pandorica Opens / The Big Bang
  9. Genesis of the Daleks
  10. Ghost Light
  11. Remembrance of the Daleks
  12. World Enough and Time / The Doctor Falls
  13. The Magician's Apprentice / The Witch's Familiar
  14. The Curse of Fenric
  15. The Impossible Astronaut / Day of the Moon
  16. Amy's Choice
  17. Listen
  18. The Lodger
  19. The Name of the Doctor
  20. The Deadly Assassin
Don't think I can argue with that

Also, Ghost Light is very high on yours, I see you are a man of taste
A Christmas Carol above Day of the Doctor, The Doctor's Wife, and The Eleventh Hour? I mean, I like it a lot, but dang haha.

And yeah, Ghost Light absolutely rules. Maybe I should rewatch the 7th Doctor era again, since I am not feeling like Pertwee at the moment lol
 

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)
Oh, hey, Mrs. Flood is married to Bryan May

b4ea5ae7e5da57bc3df7400fd13606e82bb90a66.jpeg


And also was in an episode of Red Dwarf.

92eeb611113fc0d06ff405ea4d01b990f57f8703.gif
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
So I watched the new Celestial Toymaker animation (with the first episode in black and white, still, sadly. Stupid bluray). I will say this - the animation does wonders for the episode, and not just because we can see what's going on. They took major liberties with the visuals, and I'm glad they did. What's going on is far more interesting than what would have been possible in the 1960s. Even my wife watched a few minutes of it, being creeped out by the playing cards moving like they're the only things stop motion in an otherwise animated production. It's really good! Unfortunately it's still the friggin Celestial Toymaker, among the dullest stories Doctor Who has ever produced. I can't fault the animators - they did a wonderful job with a terrible script - but I can't see myself watching this by choice very often.

I'm going to go watch The Giggle as a palette cleanser now.
 

Vaeran

(GRUNTING)
(he/him)
Staff member
Moderator
They took major liberties with the visuals, and I'm glad they did.

Without having seen it, I feel like this sort of thing would annoy me, hahaha. To me, the animations should serve as the next closest thing to watching the lost episodes, not reinvent them or portray things that never happened in broadcast. I don't remember which it was now, but I watched a Second Doctor animation many many years ago that added a "BAD WOLF" graffiti somewhere in the background of one scene, and that really irked me at the time. (After doing a bit of googling I think I'm thinking of The Invasion.)

Of course I'm not trying to say my tastes are any better or more correct than yours, and I'm glad you enjoyed it!
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
@Vaeran Normally I feel similarly, but The Celestial Toymaker as written is so bad I will take anything to spice it up, including visuals that weren't possible in the 60s. I don't think it'd work for really any other story - they take what is essentially the TARDIS crew playing musical chairs (without the music) and make it trippy and weird, instead of just the dullest thing you've ever seen, for example. Because of the nature of the world they're in, they can do stuff like that and have it still make sense. But yeah, if you're looking for as close to a 1:1 replacement for the original production as you can get, it will bug you regardless.

I cannot stress this enough - this is the first time I've come even close to enjoying The Celestial Toymaker. It's still not great, but the animation actually makes the story better, weirdly enough.
 

Teaspoon

(They)
one day they'll have the tech for realistic CGI animation and we'll wish for the days when things were allowed to be unfaithful
 

Kirin

Summon for hire
(he/him)
I missed the news that they're novelizing four stories from this season - including my favorite, 73 Yards, which you better believe I've already ordered lmao. The others are The Church on Ruby Road, Space Babies, and Rogue.

... Why on earth would we need a novelization of Space Babies?

I mean, I don't hate the episode for existing or anything, I had an okay time watching it, snot-monster and all, but it just doesn't seem like the kind of story begging to be fleshed out further (whereas the other three I can all see easily).
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Beats me, yeah. Not the top of my list either. I'd have expected The Legend of Ruby Sunday/Empire of Death, though maybe RTD is saving that one for himself whenever Millie Gibson leaves.
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
I have received and read the 73 Yards novelization. Spoilers for a lot of what stood out to me as different from the transmitted episode follow.

I liked it, but then I was always going to, unless Scott Handcock fucked it up and overexplained things. He didn't - the central premise is just as mysterious and unexplained as in the transmitted episode - but some other things were filled in. The first notable expansion comes during the scene in the pub Y Pren Marw - we get a lot more info about the patrons. So Joshua (the first guy to leave the pub and get terrified by The Woman), and the pub owner, Lowri, have been basically in love with each other their whole lives, but they waited too long to acknowledge it and by the time they had, Joshua was married and he felt it was too late. He still visited the pub every day, though, to see Lowri, at least until The Woman scared him away. He never returned to the pub again after that, we're told - even after Ruby and The Woman left, he still never went back. He and Lowry still occasionally saw each other, but drifted apart. Years later, when Ruby visits as an old woman (not yet The Woman herself, this is when she's being cared for in hospice or whatever it is in the UK), Ruby sees a message out of the corner of her eye that says "Love you, Josh..." in faded writing. I find this odd - Ruby read another message at the fairy circle right at the end of her life! Doesn't this mean she has transgressed against the fae again? Or is this somehow closing the circle somehow?

We also learn about the two young patrons of the pub. The young girl, Lucy, is in love with Ifor, the guy who was dressed kind of goth-y on TV. Lucy eventually confesses her love to Ifor, and he turns her down, but she still pines for him. Later, when Ruby reads Lowri's message at the fairy circle, she wishes that at least Ifor was happy, which I take to mean she wishes he comes out of the closet and lives as a proud gay man. It's never explicitly stated, but some of what we see on screen is expanded upon here. He says Mad Jack will get him first, and everyone there knows it - just like on TV. It seems everyone there, or at least most of them, know his secret.

Ruby being abandoned by her mom happens pretty much exactly as it does in the transmitted episode, even down to Mrs. Flood coming out, seeing what's going on, saying "...Nothing to do with me," and heading back inside. The book gives absolutely no hint whatsoever as to who she really is, and it's her only appearance.

We are told in the book how Ruby contacted UNIT - she went to UNIT tower and asked for help, and wasn't getting too far until she mentioned the Doctor and his TARDIS, at which point she is told to sit and wait, until eventually, a woman comes downstairs and asks if Ruby knows something about "the Professor." Ruby Sunday meets Ace, and has a brief chat with her! It's fairly insubstantial - and Ace is not present for the scene where UNIT tries to apprehend The Woman, and is not in the rest of the book, but it was lovely to make that connection. Ace works for UNIT sometimes, when she's not running her charity (this may have been canonized in The Power of the Doctor, but I can't remember, and don't feel like rewatching that mess).

We, frustratingly, don't learn all that much more about Roger ap Gwilliam. It really does seem his whole thing is he actually does want to launch nukes. Marti is still implied to be abused by him, and Ruby seems to know about it and seems to be friends with her to a degree, but doesn't stop Gwilliam until the stadium. There's a bit more detail about the world he gets elected in, though - it's ravaged by climate change, as one would expect for 2046. The stadium they hire out where the pivotal scene with The Woman scaring him off the Prime Minister job occurs has to be accessed by fording up overflowing rivers and such, not a hint of which was in the episode, but is a nice touch. We do get a bit of postscript for Gwilliam - he writes a book about his life, but lies about why he left politics. He said he was under threats and didn't want to give details so as to not risk his life again. The 73 Yards novelization says his life ended the way his political life began - with a lie, and that's it for Gwilliam.

The scene where Ruby dies and seemingly becomes The Woman is just as vague as in the transmitted episode. I'm fine with that - I don't want to be told that it really is the fae or some alien trap or whatever it might have been.


Overall, I enjoyed it. It won't replace the episode, not that I ever expected it to (nor, I'm sure, was it intended to) - the TV episode is far creepier and makes me uneasier than the book did. Still, it was a breezy read, and you may enjoy it if you liked the episode.
 

Vaeran

(GRUNTING)
(he/him)
Staff member
Moderator
Thanks for the review Kazin! I was curious how this one would turn out and I'm glad Handcock didn't overexplain anything. (I still see a thread on reddit about every week asking WHAT DO YOU THINK THE WOMAN SAID TO PEOPLE THAT SCARED THEM OFF? and it just feels as useless to me as speculating as to the Doctor's real name. There's no answer that would be as satisfying or effective as the void of not knowing. Just another case of fans missing the point entirely.)

As for Ace, I don't believe there was any indication given in The Power of the Doctor that she would continue working for UNIT in the future, or else I'd have been in here going WHERE THE FUCK IS ACE after every episode. Cool that she shows up, though!
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Thinking about Ace, it seems a bit of a missed opportunity to not have her interact with The Woman and have her recoil from Ruby, but that's probably a step too far given she wasn't in the actual transmitted episode. These are nitpicks, though. I think Handcock did a pretty good job.
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
I ordered the other three new Target novelizations, including Space Babies, because I am a big dumb Doctor Who baby.
 
I ordered the other three new Target novelizations, including Space Babies, because I am a big dumb Doctor Who baby.
Here's a question, Kazin:

Do you have a favorite Doctor Who novel outside of the ones based on actual transmitted episodes? I tried to collect a few during the Tenth Doctor era, but ultimately sold them during a time of hardship. But these days I'd be curious to check one out just for fun.

EDIT: Also, just to add: I enjoyed your review on the 73 Yards novelization and will try to check it out! That was one of my favorite episodes from this latest season.
 
Last edited:

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Here's a question, Kazin:

Do you have a favorite Doctor Who novel outside of the ones based on actual transmitted episodes?

Hoooooo boy, this is a fun one haha

So if you're talking strictly new series books not based on transmitted episodes, my experience is limited - I remember thinking The Stone Rose by Jacqueline Raynor was good, but looking over the list of titles on Wikipedia, I've either not read or do not remember reading the rest (I've read others. None of them besides that one stand out).

If you're willing to dip your toes into the classic Doctors, though, I've a lot more experience there. Cold Fusion by Lance Parkin featuring the Fifth and Seventh Doctors and Damaged Goods featuring the Seventh Doctor by Russell T Davies are both excellent, though honestly I think I prefer both of those as audio plays done by Big Finish (which I don't say lightly - lots of Big Finish is Doctor Who flavored slop and not worth recommending unless you're in the mood for that, as I sometimes am lol. These two audio plays are superlative, though). Otherwise, Timewyrm: Revelation, Love And War, and Human Nature all by Paul Cornell are excellent New Adventures (which continued the 7th Doctors story after the classic series ended). Lungbarrow is a fun, if completely non-canon origin story for the entire series (especially after Chibnall's run as showrunner, but even before that, too). The Dark Path is kind of an origin story for the Master, and stars the Second Doctor and the Roger Delgado Master, which is fun. There are others, but all those should get you started.

Shoutout to the Day of the Doctor novelization, though - Moffat adds so much to that episode that it feels like a completely different thing, and is probably my favorite novelization of Doctor Who, ever, and one of the best Doctor Who books in general anyway. I know that doesn't really fit your criteria, but if you haven't read it, cannot recommend it enough.
 
Thank y'all, those sound like some great suggestions! I definitely want to dig in to some classic Doctor stories, so I might start with Cold Fusion! Also, the way you describe it, Day of the Doctor sounds fun!

I do remember owning a copy of "The Stone Rose" but I can't recall if I ever read it. I might have just started it?

Other than that, I do remember reading "Beautiful Chaos" and I believe "The Resurrection Casket" featuring the Tenth Doctor. The funny thing is, the only thing I remember about the latter is thinking "What makes this a Doctor Who story and not just a bland sci-fi novel?" That sounds harsh, I don't think I disliked the novel at all, but I can see it being a challenge to write that specific Doctor and companion's personality into the dialogue and narrative without them going "Allons-y!" every few paragraphs. But maybe that might be true for a lot of Doctor Who's extended media...?
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
There are some running plotlines going into Cold Fusion, but I think it reads pretty well as a standalone (I certainly haven't read everything leading up to it, far from it). Assuming you've seen the classic 5th and 7th Doctor eras on TV, I think you'll quite enjoy it.
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Oh and I also really enjoyed The Witch Hunters and especially The Time Travelers, both of which are 1st Doctor books. The Time Travelers in particular is a standout - it is a much better ending (sorta - it takes place beforehand, but is just more fleshed out) for Ian and Barbara than the friggin Chase.
 

Vaeran

(GRUNTING)
(he/him)
Staff member
Moderator
I am ashamed to admit I bought The Time Travelers months ago but it still sits unread on my shelf.
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Eh, it'll be there when you get around to it (he says, with like half the New Adventures from the 90s sitting on his shelves through two moves, many unread for like a decade of owning them lol). It really is a good book, though!
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Decided to read some Doctor Who novelizations as I wait for the new books to arrive.

First, I read The Space Pirates by Terrance Dicks. It does a good job of conveying what the actual televised story was about, and doesn't deviate far from it at all. It was fine, but it would be completely superfluous if the televised story were ever found.

Not so for The Myth Makers, by Donald Cotton. Completely unlike the televised serial, it is told entirely in first person by Homer - yes, that Homer - even though he wasn't in the televised story at all. And it rules. Cotton did a fantastic job adapting the tv story to book form - he captures the comedy extremely well, but in many different ways than his original script. Homer is sarcastic, self-serving, witty, and has all kinds of jokes about everything going on. Homer takes the piss out of everything, including the story he's in - sneaking in and out of Troy easier than the TARDIS crew could ever hope to, and not knowing what the Doctor's talking about when he says he has no idea where Homer got the idea for the Trojan horse (the Doctor claims Homer must have made it up, which Homer found strange as he'd never heard of the idea before). I also like how British as fuck everyone in the novel is. It was like this in the televised episode, too, but played up here - everyone is extremely dryly funny, and in many ways, the book reads like an honest to god Douglas Adams novel. No, probably nowhere near as good as his stuff (I haven't read Hitchhikers' Guide since highschool), but a delightful read nonetheless. As much as I love and want the televised serial back, the novel does a fantastic job approximating what I think it was supposed to be like - it's very funny, and a much easier experience than sitting through a reconstruction. Thoroughly recommended.

My wife and I drove about an hour to a pretty big used bookstore where, years ago, I'd picked up like a dozen Doctor Who novelizations, and they hadn't had a single Doctor Who book in stock, from any era. According to the owner, they're hard to keep in stock, which was wild to me. Ah well. To eBay it is for anything else I may want to read...
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
Rewatched Dot and Bubble today. Knowing the gut punch at the end improves it significantly, but I still think it's a tedious, annoying watch overall for most of its runtime. Yes, I get that we're supposed to end up disliking the main pov character, but they do such a good job at that right away. Gatwa sells the end of it, but it's still not one I'll come back to very often, I don't think.

Started reading The Church on Ruby Road, since those books came in the mail today. It's fine so far, pretty straightforwardly an adaptation of the tv script, but I'm only like a quarter of the way through it so who knows if that'll remain the case. Apparently the author of Space Babies, Alison Rumfitt, is a relatively new author who has written two horror books prior to Space Babies, at least one of which features transphobia as a literal parasite, with a title called "Brainwyrms", so I am vastly more interested in that novelization now given her pedigree.
 
Top