Man NG+ is WIIILD. I've cleared every starting area in a single run and defeated every mini-boss and GYOBU on the first try, some of them stylishly. I've had to ressurect a few times but my first Capital D Death was against Lady Butterfly who I took on shortly after LOUD HORSE MAN. I was disappointed but also had to remind myself what an accomplishment that was compared to my last playthrough and especially the partial playthrough before that.
I still like that little "Forgive me..." that Wolf says before killing him, which he also says to Lady Butterfly, implying that neither of these bosses are people he would want to kill under normal circumstances. I thought that would end up being true for all of the bosses in the game but Genichiro broke the streak.
Also, ok, the story. I'm most compelled by Isshin, who I had spoiled well before I ever touched the game and assumed from the hype that he was one of those optional super bosses, not THE final boss for 75% of the game's endings, and can be locked in as such no less. So I knew some guy named Isshin was a mega super boss. And then I play the game and a "Lord Isshin" gets mentioned by the kid a few times implying that the two are on friendly terms and I'm like "Ok, some old badass dude is secretly the evil manipulator behind the scenes."
But I'm not so sure? Like when you get to meet him in-game (officially) he's just a weary old man who has accepted his mortality but will share some spicy stories with you if you get him liquored up. He seems to condone letting Kuro be the chooser of his own fate. But then like boom, he shows up and is your biggest roadblock to whichever of the three non-Shura endings you're going for. But is that Isshin as we know him? Or is it more of a spiritual idealization of him as Genichiro saw him, an unstoppable war god who would never let his nation fail. Or is it a younger version of Isshin at his most fiery and arrogant, who only knows he was ressurected to KICK YOUR ASS and can?
Aww whatever, soulsborne game.
Oh yeah, speaking of things I had spoilers about, I knew the Guardian Ape was a boss fight which as a kaiju fan made me quite enthusiastic, and I had unfortunately had it spoiled that he just gets right back up after a full blown UI confirming kill. What I did not have spoiled is the creepy, floaty serpentine way in which his headless self moves so it was still quite a fight. Watching compilations of people who don't know it's coming and reacting to it is a favorite passtime of mine.