Jack Black's got the right energy for the more comedic version of Bowser, and I know next to nothing about Anya Taylor-Joy (not that it matters, since Peach's characterization through the years is not great), but the rest of that cast? Did they consult a Reddit subforum? For all its faults, at least the 1993 garbage pile cast Mario and Luigi correctly.
Please discuss. Should we even have expected anything different from Illumination?