• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

The Top 50 Cartoon Characters Nomination Thread - A Terrible Strain on Talking Time's Wrists

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)

8958.jpg



Probably something like trans rights or sphere grids but in the meantime, we like to entertain ourselves with cartoons as we weight to be flung through time off of our mortal coils. And who makes up these time killers? Characters! Unless the cartoon is rather abstract or is about a tree growing or some shit.

But let’s face it, the outsized characters are often what keeps us coming back for more. After all, even the biggest scenery chewing ham can’t beat what a cartoon can do: bring to life an special kind of logic. Cartoons have a special power all of their own and though to an extent a lot can be replicated in non-moving art, the combination of motion and being beyond the real can bring a different sort of power and a special kind of character. Even cartoon characters who don’t follow splat and squish animation logic have something that can’t be replicated in real life, even if it is more subtle. Technically, you could have a live action Hank Hill or Bob Belcher or god forbid Fred Flinstone (again) but animation feels better for them, in that the simplicity of design can convey things more directly to the viewer. And maybe more personally. Its in human nature.

understanding-comics-faces.jpg
image-2-p-36-400-pixel-width-of-page.jpg


Pictured:
dedooxc-07484196-162d-408b-9190-acb677c0cf15.jpg

Yourself!

Of course, McCloud was talking about the non-moving kind of cartoons but it certainly still applies, doesn’t it? So I feel confident in saying we love cartoon characters. I know I do. Let’s see which characters speak to us the most. Together. In front of the warming glow of our televisi— er, computers.

How to Draw up a Cartoon Character list!

1. Choose your top 25 cartoon characters in order from favourite downwards.
2. PM them to me
3. Each placement on your list will be represented by points. #1 is 35, #2 is 34 and so on until the end.
4. I will tabulate the scores and then draw up a list based on everyone’s collective points.
So, what counts as a cartoon character?

Sure this might sound inherently obvious but there’s definitely a lot that is open to interpretation so allow me to clear things up.
  • The character must be animated. I know cartoon is a term that can be used for illustration rather than simply animation and even that this what it initially referred to but I want this to be clear that I am looking specifically at animated ones. This time. I hope I didn’t mislead anyone with the title.
  • The way the character is animated can be in any number of varieties. Pen and paper, stop motion, CG. However, this must be a character who intended to exist in an animated world. I’ll definitely make exceptions (say, where they represent animation) but mostly what I am trying to say is I won’t include, say, King Kong, who was often depicted in stop motion and CG forms.
  • If you are like “Hey, technically aren’t ALL video game characters animated?” And I’ll be like “Don’t do this to me.” But I will allow video game characters who exist within traditional animation (like a Don Bluth game).
  • I won’t completely exclude characters that didn’t originate in animation but I’ll mostly discourage them. Like, animated versions of Tintin are basically different Tintins. But Popeye definitely evolved in his animated forms and Roger Rabbit of the novel doesn’t really represent the character on screen. Use your best judgement.
  • This is for individuals. But what about duos and trios and etc.? It depends. Though Pinky and the Brain are a duo, both are different characters with their own unique personalities and sometimes do their own things. So, if the characters are kind of super inseparable, then I’m fine with it.
Does that pretty much cover it? Well, don’t let the rules get you to overthink things too much, these are just basic guidelines so we are on the same page. So please get cracking and try to have your list sent in by the 24th of September. Of 2021. To be clear. See you there!

 

Torzelbaum

????? LV 13 HP 292/ 292
(he, him, his)
So does the limit really have to be 25 and we don't have any other restrictions? Because as it currently is I think I'm going to have a very hard time narrowing down the rough list of candidates I had preemptively started making once this topic had won the vote.
 

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)
They are animated characters so... bring em in.

That said, I can't speak for the Studio Killers but each member of the Gorillaz would be its own entry, as they all have their own backstories and characterizations.
 
Last edited:

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)
Oh, that's a good one. Hmm... I think I'm fine with this. I mean, I don't know much about the culture but I get the impression that the point is they are being "characters". If it's just them as themselves with a virtual mask, I'd still allow it but it feels less in line with the intent of the list. Of course, the question of "what is a mask?" is an even bigger philosophical debate that's a bit too heady for me right now.
 

Purple

(She/Her)
OK. There is an incredibly obscure one-off character from a show that's had 2 remakes since that somehow made it into my top 10, but sometimes you've gotta just go with what's in your heart. Even if it's a rambling manifesto.
 

Octopus Prime

Mysterious Contraption
(He/Him)
What about characters who are definitely intended for another medium but you’re specifically voting for an animated version of them.

Like The Real Ghostbusters or just specifically the Kevin Conroy Batman?
 

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)
I'd say if you feel there's something that separates them from their other medium counter-part. I mean, Goku from the anime is basically identical to Goku from the manga so there's not much of a point. Wait, till we do Top 50 Comic Characters.
 

Kirin

Summon for hire
(he/him)
Uhhhhh, that would cut out a *lot* of anime, since like 75% of it is adapted from manga. But I'd argue that many of the characters are best known from their animated adaptations, often moreso in the US.
 

Torzelbaum

????? LV 13 HP 292/ 292
(he, him, his)
I have some "comic" characters on my list (which Johnny hasn't pushed back on so far). But I really am far more familiar with those characters from cartoons than from the "source" material.
 

JBear

Internet's foremost Bertolli cosplayer
(He/Him)
I mean, I'm voting for a bunch of anime characters that come from source manga. If Johnny wants to fire my list into the sun or whatever, he's welcome to, but I'm not not listing one of my favourite cartoon characters because it's also in a comic I probably haven't read.
 

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)
But I'd argue that many of the characters are best known from their animated adaptations, often moreso in the US.
I'm not not listing one of my favourite cartoon characters because it's also in a comic I probably haven't read.
Fair enough.

(which Johnny hasn't pushed back on so far)
Yeah, I tend not to do heavy pushback. I'm pretty loosey goosey in terms of what I accept compared to my suggestions.

EDIT: Up to 5 lists. Some unexpected placements in the best sense. I am so psyched for this list.
 
Last edited:

Dracula

Plastic Vampire
(He/His)
I'm being hard on myself and excluding anime characters, as well as cape comics characters who I've primarily experienced in cartoons, and I've still already got at least 30 characters in my list. This should be a fun one.
 

Dracula

Plastic Vampire
(He/His)
Don't feel you need to. And I do apologize for any gatekeeperism.
No need to apologize to me! All of my stipulations are self-imposed. I just know if I allow anime or cape cartoons I'll have a list of 35 mech pilots and 35 Batman and Justice League villains. And then there'll be no room for Eek Stravaganza!
 

JBear

Internet's foremost Bertolli cosplayer
(He/Him)
No need to apologize to me! All of my stipulations are self-imposed. I just know if I allow anime or cape cartoons I'll have a list of 35 mech pilots and 35 Batman and Justice League villains. And then there'll be no room for Eek Stravaganza!
Eagerly awaits list of 70 transforming robots
 

Kirin

Summon for hire
(he/him)
Well, finally had time to start throwing together an initial list and looks like I'm now up to... hmm, about 64 characters. I guess I should probably stop adding and start paring it back down, even though I know I"ll be forgetting some that I'll smack myself for later.
 

ThornGhost

lofi posts to relax/study to
(he/him)
I knew this list would be impossible and just barfed out a list without worrying too much about it. There are definitely very biased and questionable choices on it but we're all just going to have to live with that.
 

Johnny Unusual

(He/Him)
Don't feel bad about it. Frankly, I tend to get self-conscious about how meat-and-potatoes and basic bitch most of my choices are but you like what you like and usually there are good reasons, even if you can't articulate them.
 
Top