View Single Post
  #703  
Old 10-12-2017, 12:03 PM
Positronic Brain's Avatar
Positronic Brain Positronic Brain is offline
Out Of Warranty
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Barcelona, Spain
Posts: 8,871
Default

That said... Here's the final list we based the thread on. Please don't give much importance to ranking numbers beyond 75 or so... Lots of ties, lost of games with low mentions. This was a very horizontal list due to the high participation (38 Tyrants, 422 nominations). You guys even broke my spreadsheet - twice!


Place Game Pts Mentions
1 Chrono Trigger 687 23
2 Final Fantasy Vi 528 18
3 Katamari Damacy 475 18
4 Undertale 391 15
5 Chrono Cross 391 14
6 Castlevania: Symphony Of The Night 388 14
7 Shadow Of The Colossus 353 13
8 Secret Of Mana 340 13
9 Mega Man 2 271 11
10 Final Fantasy Iv 268 9
11 Final Fantasy Tactics 259 11
12 Nier 242 8
13 Super Castlevania Iv 234 9
14 Earthbound 210 9
15 Xenogears 208 8
16 Shovel Knight 206 9
17 Mega Man 3 195 9
18 The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time 190 8
19 Mega Man X 187 8
20 Persona 4 184 7
21 The Legend Of Zelda: A Link To The Past 167 7
22 Persona 5 166 6
23 Nier: Automata 164 6
24 Final Fantasy Vii 161 8
25 Streets Of Rage 2 159 7
26 Suikoden 133 5
27 Skies Of Arcadia 132 5
28 Okami 124 5
29 Ys Iii 122 5
30 Suikoden Ii 121 4
31 Super Metroid 114 5
32 Ys I & Ii 114 4
33 Final Fantasy Viii 112 4
34 Ducktales 111 5
35 Final Fantasy Xii 109 4
36 Super Mario Bros. 105 5
37 Actraiser 99 5
38 Castlevania 3 98 4
39 Metroid 96 5
40 Castlevania: Lament Of Innocence 96 4
41 Ico 96 3
42 Gitaroo Man 92 4
43 Super Mario Galaxy 91 4
44 Xenoblade Chronicles 85 4
45 Saga Frontier 85 3
46 Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze 84 3
47 Bastion 80 4
48 Cave Story 79 3
49 Legend Of Mana 78 3
49 Vagrant Story 78 3
51 Breath Of Fire Iii 77 4
51 Final Fantasy Ix 77 4
53 Hotline Miami 76 3
53 Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne 76 3
55 Castlevania Chronicles 75 3
56 The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker 74 4
57 Dragon Quest Viii 74 3
58 The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild 72 3
59 Castlevania 68 3
60 Fez 68 2
61 Castlevania: Rondo Of Blood 67 3
61 Phantasy Star Ii 67 3
61 Valkyria Chronicles 67 3
64 G-Darius 66 2
65 Mother 3 64 3
65 Super Mario Bros. 2 64 3
67 Bravely Default 63 3
67 Castlevania Ii 63 3
67 Life Is Strange 63 3
70 Jet Set Radio Future 63 2
71 Banjo-Kazooie 62 2
71 Tales Of Legendia 62 2
71 We Know The Devil 62 2
74 Suikoden Iii 61 3
74 Tetris 61 3
76 Thunder Force Iv 61 2
77 Valkyrie Profile 60 3
77 Bubble Bobble 60 2
77 Warcraft Ii 60 2
80 Final Fantasy V 59 3
80 Final Fantasy X 59 3
82 Persona 3 59 2
83 Etrian Odyssey Iii 58 3
84 Silver Surfer 58 2
84 The World Ends With You 58 2
86 Terranigma 55 3
87 Saga Frontier 2 55 2
87 Splatoon 55 2
89 Super Mario Bros. 3 54 3
90 Gunstar Heroes 54 2
91 Grand Theft Auto: Vice City 53 2
92 Gradius Iii 51 2
92 Star Tropics 51 2
94 Kirby'S Dream Land 50 3
95 Castlevania Ii: Belmont'S Revenge 50 2
95 Castlevania: Order Of Ecclesia 50 2
95 Donkey Kong Country 50 2
95 Final Fantasy Mystic Quest 50 2
95 Grim Fandango 50 2
95 Journey 50 2
95 Tactics Ogre 50 2
102 Dark Souls 49 2
102 Donkey Kong Country 2 49 2
102 Phantasy Star 49 2
102 Rocket Knight Adventures 49 2
106 Contra 48 2
106 Diablo Ii 48 2
106 Gradius V 48 2
106 Mass Effect 48 2
106 Sonic 2 48 2
111 Silent Hill 2 47 2
112 Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete 46 2
112 Metroid Prime 46 2
112 Muramasa: The Demon Blade 46 2
112 River City Ransom 46 2
116 Street Fighter Ii 45 3
117 Metal Black 45 2
117 Ninja Gaiden 45 2
117 Portal 45 2
120 Animal Crossing 43 2
120 Baten Kaitos 43 2
122 World Of Goo 42 3
123 Blaster Master 42 2
123 Castlevania: Harmony Of Dissonance 42 2
123 Final Fantasy Iii 42 2
123 Soul Blazer 42 2
123 The Neverhood 42 2
128 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney 41 2
128 Star Fox 41 2
128 The Legend Of Zelda 41 2
131 Hyper Light Drifter 40 2
132 Contra: Hard Corps 39 2
132 Ristar 39 2
132 Vvvvvv 39 2
135 Ecco The Dolphin 38 2
135 Journey To Silius 38 2
135 Rez 38 2
138 Hotel Dusk 37 2
139 Full Throttle 36 2
139 Lost Odyssey 36 2
139 Ninja Gaiden Ii 36 2
141 Castlevania: Aria Of Sorrow 35 2
141 Lufia 2 35 2
141 Metal Gear Solid 35 2
141 Star Control Ii 35 2
146 Alien Soldier 35 1
146 Drakengard 35 1
146 Final Fantasy Legend Iii 35 1
146 Gone Home 35 1
146 Heroes Of Might & Magic 2 35 1
146 Quest For Glory 4: Shadows Of Darkness 35 1
146 Shin Megami Tensei Strange Journey 35 1
146 The Legend Of Heroes: Trails In The Sky The 3Rd 35 1
146 Transistor 35 1
154 Mega Man 9 34 2
154 Super Smash Bros For Wii U 34 2
154 Xenoblade Chronicles X 34 2
158 Beyond Good And Evil 34 1
158 Morrowind 34 1
158 Opoona 34 1
158 The Binding Of Isaac 34 1
158 Unlimited Saga 34 1
163 Sonic Mania 33 2
164 Etrian Odyssey 33 1
164 Her Story 33 1
164 Just Dance 2014 33 1
164 Perfect Cherry Blossom 33 1
164 Red Dead Redemption 33 1
164 Touhou 10: Mountain Of Faith 33 1
170 Super Mario Land 32 2
170 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Iv: Turtles In Time 32 2
172 Brutal Legend 32 1
172 Crusader: No Remorse 32 1
172 Donkey Kong Country 3 32 1
172 Flashback 32 1
172 Gradius Gaiden 32 1
172 Mega Man 1 32 1
178 Crypt Of The Necrodancer 31 2
178 Rayman Origins 31 2
178 Sonic The Hedgehog 31 2
181 Batman (Nes) 31 1
181 Brigador 31 1
181 F-Zero Gx 31 1
181 Final Fantasy Xiv 31 1
181 Guilty Gear Xrd 31 1
181 Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon 31 1
181 Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan 31 1
181 Pyre 31 1
181 The Legend Of Zelda: Majora'S Mask 31 1
181 Zeliard 31 1
191 Bioshock 30 2
192 Digital Devil Saga 30 1
192 Plok 30 1
192 Rogue Legacy 30 1
192 Street Fighter Ex Plus 30 1
192 The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 30 1
192 Yoshi'S Island 30 1
198 Vandal Hearts 29 2
199 Anticipation 29 1
199 Banjo-Tooie 29 1
199 Dodonpachi: Daifukkatsu 29 1
199 Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn 29 1
199 Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance 29 1
199 Phantasy Star Iv 29 1
199 Quake 29 1
199 Sonic 3 29 1
199 Sonic Adventure 2 29 1
199 Super Mario 3D World 29 1
209 Axelay 28 1
209 Curse Of Monkey Island 28 1
209 Doom (2016) 28 1
209 Eschatos 28 1
209 Etrian Odyssey Ii 28 1
209 The Guardian Legend 28 1
209 The Legend Of Zelda: Link'S Awakening 28 1
209 Valdis Story: Abyssal City 28 1
217 God Hand 27 2
217 Shining Force Ii 27 2
219 Breath Of Fire V 27 1
219 Digital Devil Saga 2 27 1
219 Mega Man 6 27 1
219 Ragnarok Online 27 1
219 Seiken Densetsu 3 27 1
219 Tail Of The Sun 27 1
219 The Last Remnant 27 1
219 Trauma Team 27 1
219 We Love Katamari 27 1
219 Zen: Intergalactic Ninja 27 1
229 Breath Of Fire Iv 26 1
229 Final Fantasy Legend Ii 26 1
229 Ftl: Faster Than Light 26 1
229 Killer 7 26 1
229 Kirby'S Epic Yarn 26 1
229 Shadow Hearts 26 1
229 Tales Of Phantasia 26 1
229 Tekken 2 26 1
229 Wonder Boy In Monster Land 26 1
238 Battle Garegga 25 1
238 Bit.Trip Beat 25 1
238 Castlevania Bloodlines 25 1
238 Command & Conquer: Red Alert 25 1
238 Dragon'S Dogma 25 1
238 Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: The Crystal Bearers 25 1
238 Galactic Storm 25 1
238 Shining Force Iii 25 1
238 Sonic 3 & Knuckles 25 1
238 Street Fighter Ex3 25 1
238 Street Fighter Ii Turbo 25 1
238 Tetrisphere 25 1
238 The Legend Of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds 25 1
238 The Legend Of Zelda: Twilight Princess 25 1
238 Ys Vi: Ark Of Napisthim 25 1
253 Cho Ren Sha 68K 24 1
253 Double Dragon Neon 24 1
253 Dragon Quest Iv 24 1
253 Elemental Gearbolt 24 1
253 Flower, Sun, Rain 24 1
253 Parappa The Rapper 24 1
253 Professor Layton & The Curious Village 24 1
253 Space Manbow 24 1
253 Tree Of Savior 24 1
262 7Th Saga 23 1
262 Guilty Gear Xx 23 1
262 Marvel Super Heroes 23 1
262 Shin Megami Tensei Iv: Apocalypse 23 1
262 Silpheed 23 1
262 The Adventures Of Batman & Robin (Genesis) 23 1
262 Tokyo Mirage Sessions #Fe 23 1
262 Umjammer Lammy 23 1
262 Wonder Boy Iii: The Dragon'S Trap 23 1
271 Dragon Quest Ii 22 1
271 Dynamite Headdy 22 1
271 Elemental Master 22 1
271 Fantavision (Eu) 22 1
271 Guilty Gear X 22 1
271 Kingdom Hearts 22 1
271 Panzer Dragoon Saga 22 1
271 Portal 2 22 1
271 Saints Row: The Third 22 1
271 Shadow Hearts Covenant 22 1
271 Shatterhand 22 1
271 The Elder Scrolls Iv: Oblivion 22 1
271 Treasure Of The Rudras 22 1
271 Trip World 22 1
271 Wild Arms 3 22 1
271 Zelda Ii: The Adventure Of Link 22 1
287 Biohazard Battle 21 1
287 Botanicula 21 1
287 Contra: Shattered Soldier 21 1
287 Devil'S Crush 21 1
287 Einhander 21 1
287 Fire Emblem Echoes 21 1
287 Guitar Hero 21 1
287 Mega Man X2 21 1
287 New Super Mario Bros. 21 1
287 Prey (2017) 21 1
287 Prince Of Persia: The Sands Of Time 21 1
287 Romancing Saga Minstrel Song 21 1
287 Shadowgate 21 1
287 Super Mario World 21 1
301 Axiom Verge 20 1
301 Bloodborne 20 1
301 Brave Fencer Musashi 20 1
301 Castlevania Adventure 20 1
301 Fire Emblem: Geneology Of The Holy War 20 1
301 Jet Set Radio 20 1
301 Legend Of The Mystical Ninja 20 1
301 Mega Man Soccer 20 1
301 Psychic World 20 1
301 Shin Megami Tensei Iv 20 1
301 The Path 20 1
312 Age Of Mythology 19 1
312 Dragon Quest Iii 19 1
312 El Shaddai 19 1
312 Final Fantasy 19 1
312 Final Fantasy Xiii-2 19 1
312 Secret Of Evermore 19 1
312 Snatcher 19 1
312 Xcom: Ufo Defense 19 1
320 Alundra 18 1
320 Bayonetta 18 1
320 Braid 18 1
320 Etrian Odyssey Iv 18 1
320 Final Fantasy Xiii 18 1
320 Furi 18 1
320 Heroes Of Might & Magic Iv 18 1
320 Icewind Dale 18 1
320 Lunar 2: Eternal Blue 18 1
320 Silent Hill: Shattered Memories 18 1
320 The Last Of Us 18 1
320 The Last Story 18 1
332 Castlevania: Curse Of Darkness 17 1
332 Dustforce 17 1
332 Illusion Of Gaia 17 1
332 Ken Griffey'S Winnin' Run 17 1
332 Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards 17 1
332 Mega Man Zero 3 17 1
332 Mike Tyson'S Punch Out 17 1
332 Minecraft 17 1
332 Romance Of The Three Kingdoms Viii 17 1
332 Shining Force 17 1
332 Sim City 17 1
332 Super Mario 64 17 1
332 Super Mario Galaxy 2 17 1
332 Super Mario Rpg 17 1
332 Warcraft Iii 17 1
332 Wing Commander 17 1
348 Animal Crossing: New Leaf 16 1
348 Danganronpa 2 16 1
348 Demon'S Crest 16 1
348 Fire Emblem: Path Of Radiance 16 1
348 Golden Eye 007 16 1
348 Starcraft Ii Wings Of Liberty 16 1
348 Super Robot Wars Alpha 16 1
348 Zone Of The Enders: The 2Nd Runner 16 1
356 Arcana 15 1
356 Drakengard 3 15 1
356 Gimmick! 15 1
356 Kid Icarus Uprising 15 1
356 Kirby Air Ride 15 1
356 Paladin'S Quest 15 1
356 Parasite Eve 15 1
356 Read Only Memories 15 1
356 Revenge Of Shinobi 15 1
356 Soldier Blade 15 1
356 Star Ocean 15 1
356 To The Moon 15 1
356 Trine 15 1
356 Uncharted 4 15 1
370 Castle Crashers 14 1
370 Civilization Iv 14 1
370 Fire Emblem: Awakening 14 1
370 Gaiapolis 14 1
370 Gauntlet Iv 14 1
370 Kirby: Canvas Curse 14 1
370 R-Type 3 14 1
370 Shantae 1/2 Genie Hero 14 1
370 Shin Megami Tense: Digital Devil Saga 14 1
370 Skullmonkeys 14 1
370 Tales Of Destiny 14 1
370 Wild Arms 14 1
370 Zombies Ate My Neighbours 14 1
383 Castlevania: Portrait Of Ruin 13 1
383 Civilization 13 1
383 F-Zero 13 1
383 Magician 13 1
383 Mega Man X Command Mission 13 1
383 No More Heroes 13 1
383 Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World 13 1
383 Star Ocean The Second Story 13 1
383 World Of Warcraft 13 1
383 Yoshi'S Story 13 1
393 Ar Tonelico 3 12 1
393 Bomberman 64 12 1
393 Freedom Planet 12 1
393 Guacamelee 12 1
393 Half-Minute Hero 12 1
393 Katamari Damacy: Forever 12 1
393 Kirby Super Star 12 1
393 Mcdonald'S Treasure Land Adventure 12 1
393 Mega Man 5 12 1
393 Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door 12 1
393 Power Strike Ii 12 1
393 Probability 0 12 1
393 Sigma Harmonics 12 1
393 Soukaigi 12 1
393 Space Channel 5 12 1
393 Steamworld Heist 12 1
393 Super Smash Bros Brawl 12 1
410 Deathsmiles 11 1
410 Dolucky Sandlot Baseball 11 1
410 Dragon Quest 11 1
410 Dragon'S Crown 11 1
410 King Arthur 11 1
410 Pikmin 2 11 1
410 Sonic Cd 11 1
410 Sonic Colours 11 1
410 Suikoden V 11 1
410 The Witcher Iii 11 1
410 Total Annihilation 11 1
410 Viewtiful Joe 11 1


It's also available as a Google sheet, with a detailed point breakdown.
Reply With Quote