• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

What'cha Reading?

I think Ann Leckie just keeps getting better with time. Her latest, Radiant Star (which is in the same continuity as the Ancillary trilogy), is in large part a book about the way religion functions in a society, and it treats that topic with a breadth and depth that are really unusual in science fiction.
 
Here's what I read to finish up the month:
Coffin Moon by Keith Rosson - A most excellent vampire story
Come Closer by Sara Gran - A very excellent possession story
The Woman in Black by Susan Hill - An extremely underwhelming gothic story, although the ending was good
A Short Stay in Hell by Steven L. Beck - A unique version of Hell where people try to find their life story to escape it, but it's pretty futile
The Thief of Always by Clive Barker - Reminded me of the Pleasure Island section in Pinocchio
 
This weekend, I finished Rosemary's Baby by Ira Levin and Maggie's Grave by David Sodergren. Both good reads, although the latter was great
 
I think Ann Leckie just keeps getting better with time. Her latest, Radiant Star (which is in the same continuity as the Ancillary trilogy), is in large part a book about the way religion functions in a society, and it treats that topic with a breadth and depth that are really unusual in science fiction.
I wish I completely agreed with you, but I find her books to be really hit-and-miss. Ancillary Justice is one of my favorite science-fiction novels, but the rest of the series I found to be pretty underwhelming. I keep trying her books and I feel like the split of ones I enjoy versus ones I don't is around 60/40. I did recently pick up the ebook of Radiant Star (it's heavily discounted on the Kobo store right now), so it's nice to hear that you liked it.

If I was going to recommend one of her books aside from Ancillary Justice, it would be The Raven Tower. I really like her take on gods and belief, and it's refreshing that the book stands pretty mucn on its own. She has written a handful of short stories that share the same world, which I also recommend.
 
Been buring through a lot of Scalzi's stuff thanks to that Humble Bundle.
I do wish someone would number his series. I read The Last Emperox before I realized I'd skipped The Consuming Fire.
 
After seeing that she won the Nobel Prize in Literature this morning I confirmed my library has two books by Anne Carson so have put a hold on those. I have heard of her and I think I've read an essay or short story in a compilation or a class but excited to sit down and focus on her work.
 
I finished A Natural History of Empty Lots, a very interesting and both hopeful and depressing book about the intersection of nature and urban within cities. I'd had it on hold for a while, I finally got it only to discover the author is from Austin Texas and a lot of the essays focus on examples from there, and I'm going to Austin for the first time next week! Glad I got to read it before that.

I am starting Night Owl by Aimee Nezhukumatathil. I really liked her book Bite by Bite and have heard nothing but good things about this poetry collection.

After seeing that she won the Nobel Prize in Literature this morning I confirmed my library has two books by Anne Carson so have put a hold on those. I have heard of her and I think I've read an essay or short story in a compilation or a class but excited to sit down and focus on her work.
I learned that one of her more famous long-form poems, The Glass Essay, is available for free online. Haven't started it yet but wanted to share.
 
Update time:
Kiss Slay Replay by Rachel Harrison: A fun, twisted version of a time loop story. Mt first Harrison, will not be my last
A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess. I was reluctant to read this because I feared I'd get lost amid all the slang. Not so. A dystopian classic.
Witchcraft for Wayward Girls[/b[ by Grady Hendrix. A bit disappointed in this one. The MC annoyed the hell out of me and it was a bit long.
Angel Down by Daniel Kraus. Well worth the Pulitzer, in my opinion. I would say this probably holds the record for longest run on sentence, but it technically shouldn't count either.
 
Angel Down by Daniel Kraus. Well worth the Pulitzer, in my opinion. I would say this probably holds the record for longest run on sentence, but it technically shouldn't count either.
Angel Down is so good it'll make you wonder how he turned around from Whalefall and then did this.
 
Clockwork Orange is interesting, in that the slang makes it really confusing at the start, but you get accustomed to reading it, and as the novel continues, it becomes normal.
I'm glad it works that way, because the start is pretty harsh, in what Alex is doing. Would be too much for me, maybe, if I could read it straight.
 
Read a few I really liked, read a few that were total nothings:

The Spear Cuts Through Water by Simon Jimenez was a book I was a bit on the fence about a first but really bowled me over by the end. I loved it.

This was a real impressive read. You're given enough latitude with the modern-day wrapper story of the stage play to explain away whatever you feel like, which frees up the narrative to drift through the minds of everyone on stage as the action unfolds. I loved the honesty of this book, never hiding any ugly thought or moment, always letting it wash over the reader. Jimenez is a really excellent writer.

I loved how the main pairing was handled, this book fully earns Keema and Jun's relationship, putting the time in to have them develop a complex and charming relationship as friends and rivals, not delving into romance until the last 10% of the story. And when it arrives, man, it's so good, I adored their scenes together (especially when they begin to share thoughts) and wish we got more of them.

The plot is generally good, I enjoyed listening to it. The baseline events aren't really about anything in particular, but there's a larger story about storytelling that's delightful to see take different aspects throughout the book. Sometimes this would be a thing as little as them traversing the water in a boat, and everyone on board swapping stories they've heard about a legendary figure. It is such a human experience, such a common thing in our lives, it's really cool to see it happening in a story. This book frequently surprised me with such real moments.

I have one or two gripes, nothing that affected my enjoyment of the book. I don't like frame stories, ever, and though this one was well-done, I don't think it was needed. I really did not care about the unnamed grandchild or Grandma Lola in the present-day, I didn't think the Inverted Theater or its memory magic was necessary, and I don't really think it added much to the theme of storytelling. I suppose it was a form of somehow perfectly-accurate storytelling? There was a little playing with the idea that some truths were left to interpretation, which I liked, but it wasn't as much as I might've hoped.

But yeah, overall, what an excellent book. I was floored by Jimenez's talent in description, his willingness to play with format and constantly break the rules of narrative to reveal the truth of the matter every step of the way.



Blindsight by Peter Watts is just an absolutely killer sci-fi-ass sci-fi story, I was completely enthralled all the way through.

Not much I could compare it to, maybe Arrival - a hand-picked crew of neurodivergent experts attempt to make first contact with an alien entity, and it is nothing like they imagined.

This is of the genre of science fiction where you are watching capable professionals work a baffling, interesting mystery. They experiment, they make mistakes, they learn, they make the next stumbling step. They are so unbelievably in over their heads, the best they can do is measure risk as best they can, take every available precaution, and stick to a plan until it falls apart and they regroup. Watts' ability to avoid the big dramatic thing in favor of the simple drama of exploration does this book a whole lot of favors.

I found the big reveal of the book effectively unsettling and fascinating, and it feels like everyone grapples with it realistically. It's been a while since a scifi book has got me with that pervading existential dread, so that was an element that really really impressed me.

I also just found myself really liking the core cast. I loved Siri as the POV character, his rationale flows as a man without emotions, analyzing everything without dread or fear or excitement, even his personal relationships. I found it immensely satisfying to see him struggle with the question of how to be authentic and present when he cannot feel his emotions and thus, always feels a step removed from his own self. Jukka is probably most people's favorite, as a transhuman "vampire" it's so much fun seeing him a few levels deep on the situation. His "predator" angle added a lot of fun and intrigue to his interactions with the crew, as does his distance from them. Another character I felt a lot for.

I honestly am surprised how moved I was by this story, considering most of the cast do not have strong emotions and avoid drama at all costs. Their struggles are so natural and deep and difficult, I loved being down there with them. Watts' writing style is excellent, very descriptive and evocative. I do think the book can get mired in essayland from time to time, but it was never going on about something I wasn't interested in, so I didn't mind.

Definitely, definitely going to check out the sidequel.



Dogs of War by Adrian Tchaikovsky held my interest, I largely enjoyed it.

I enjoyed this. Strong cast, interesting exploration of created intelligence as it flirts with the singularity. Generally the humor landed (Bees' dead bird picture killed me every time), the nature of the tech was explored pretty well, and I was very impressed by the Honey storyline in particular. This was my first Tchaikovsky, and I've come away from it thinking that he's a great scifi writer, but not like, an amazing one, like I'd hoped. I think the concepts are there, but it lacks a bit of the craft that could make the way this is delivered more interesting. I think I will check out the sequel.

I will say that I enjoyed the first third of this book the most. I didn't really care much about the second third, and I got back on board for the final third. I think I would've preferred this story to have kept Rex and his team in the operational theatre for the whole book, rather than resolve it and move back to peacetime society. There's plenty to explore with the scifi idea the bioforms represent, but that's not really what I came to this book to read, I came here for the core characters, and I feel like the political direction it too took us away from the characters more than I would've liked.

But, I will take it as it is, and I do like how interested it was in its own world. That's not always a guarantee.



Tenderheart by Hetty Lui KcKinnon was a heartfelt cookbook of Vietnamese/Chinese vegetarian dishes. I ended up picking up a physical copy to try out some of them.

Not a ton to say about this one. The story of her dad dying when she was a young teen is gutting. She talks about it a lot throughout.



Some recent reads I was pretty blah on:
  • Bite Me by Christopher Moore was fineeeeee, you really just have to find it funny to enjoy the book and it wasn't hitting for me. Fun enough idea to have a gossipy high school girl be the POV protag but it got old quick for me.

  • The Enchanted Greenhouse by Sarah Beth Durst was, well, exactly as it seemed, to a fault. Written to be a "cozy cabin romance" and nothing more, no conflict or struggle or anything. I got my hopes up a little at the start because the protag became petrified as punishment for a crime and was awake as a statue for like a decade, and escapes only because the building collapses, which I thought was a cool and fucked-up situation for her to start in. But! She doesn't really feel anything about this ordeal but a tiny bit annoyed, so, ┐('~`; )┌ w/e

  • Pictures Don't Lie by Katherine MacLean is of that genre of scifi from the 50's and 60's that's like a lot of Twilight Zone eps, where the entire thing is people trying to figure out why things don't make sense, then you get the twist at the end that explains it, and the story ends there. The story should START there, but these writers were cowards. Cute idea though, would've liked to see more.
 
Last edited:
Read Taylor Tomlinson's book Actually, Nevermind on my trip and really enjoyed it. Definitely has her dark humor in her standup but so, so good.

I've also made good progress on The Three Musketeers for my classics book club. I've read a lot of passages from it and am pretty sure I've read an abridged version before too. It's nice to read the full thing. I had definitely forgotten how goofy all the characters were.
 
This is an important book for me, because it's the novel that got me back into reading after a break of many years (largely due to parenting). I found it extremely interesting and honestly pretty chilling. The ending is...a bit of a twist? I didn't realize there was another book in the series, does it explore aspects of the vampire-led revolution on Earth that happens in the absence of the protagonist?

Dogs of War by Adrian Tchaikovsky held my interest, I largely enjoyed it.

[...]

This was my first Tchaikovsky, and I've come away from it thinking that he's a great scifi writer, but not like, an amazing one, like I'd hoped.
I always feel compelled to speak up whenever someone talks about Tchaikovsky, but I can't really say I disagree with you here. It's true that prose is probably not his strength, but he does occasionally come up with some pretty incredible ideas. As always, I'll recommend the first two books in the Children of Time series, which are far and away my favorites of his. Wish I could say he bats 1.000, but with the sheer number of books he publishes each year, there are as many misses as hits.

As for me, I recently read A House with Good Bones by T Kingfisher. TK is another author who is a little up-and-down for me, and this book was more down than up. The story starts off as a slow-burn, unsettling story about an adult woman returning to a house where she spent a few years as a child, living with her overbearing (and now deceased) grandmother. It builds like this for a while, but the pacing takes a wild turn from one page to the next and it really threw me for a loop. My favorites of hers are the Sworn Soldier books, which I find to be delightfully written and a bit more consistently paced (although they're all quite short).

I'm currently reading Music and the Staged Veillée in Quebec, by my friend Laura Risk, which is a semi-academic history of performative tradition that is...probably not going to be of great interest to any of you. But I think it's neat! It does occasionally get into some more academic definitions of ontological concepts, and I absolutely do not feel smart enough to be reading it when that happens. But the more history-oriented sections are really interesting, and I love the way it examines the question of what is truly authentic and traditional vs. what are images that people project onto their own pasts in order to tell a story about themselves in the present.
 
Read Gideon Falls: The Black Barn by Jeff Lemire. I might read the next volume, but it's not a priority for now. Also, literally just finished The Blacktongue Thief by Christopher Buehlman. I really enjoyed it. I think BTF was slightly better. I might try to read The Daughter's War in November, and maybe the sequel in December
 
Finished a few more:

When We Were Real by Daryl Gregory is one of my favorite reads of the year, I was completely sucked into this book for a good long while. I don't really think it ends up going anywhere remarkable with its very cool premise, but the characterwork is so good that I didn't ultimately mind much.

Gregory is excellent at writing different voices, each one feeling distinct and real, having fun in the space and in the heads of each person. My favorites were probably the Rabbi, the Influencer, and the comic book writer, though I liked all of them.

This book has a killer premise, a world within a simulation, where seven years prior the simulators had revealed to them they were code. Every morning, people see words floating around reminding them they're in a simulation, and the manifestation across the world of the Impossibles - landmarks to which everyone in the book is traveling as a tour group - removes any doubt that they are not in the real world. This, in my mind, is enough to carry the entire book. I loved reading the Rabbi's musings on what this means for his religion, and the Influencer's plan to keep the simulators from switching them off by staying entertaining. I liked the various factions that had developed in reaction to this news, like the Protagonists, 4channer types that believe themselves to be the only real people in the sim. It's great stuff, and I was completely enthralled for the first half of the book. It's also quite genuinely funny, pretty frequently.

I was less enamored by the second half of the book, because Gillian shows up and starts taking the role of the "main character," and she's just not what I was interested in here. She feels like a character a TV adaptation would have written in to give the audience a more traditional narrative - a rogue scientist who knows Truths about the simulation - and her story ultimately isn't very rewarding. I think once the idea that they could be a simulation within a simulation becomes established, it makes Gillian not particularly connected to the world, and if our protagonists don't care, it's hard for us as readers to care. It's a bit like introducing the idea of a multiverse into a story, suddenly it's not really possible to get your arms around what does and doesn't matter to the story here. It's far better to keep the focus in this one simulation.

I also had some gripes about where the Influencer's story ends up. I loved loved loved the premise that she - a teen who grew up knowing she was in a simulation - got pregnant by accident, and this motivated her to protect her baby by becoming such a popular influencer that the simulators wouldn't want to turn off the TV. What a great idea. I also very much liked her relationship with the other teen boy, another example of Gregory nailing the POV voice. But, after the mid-point, she starts to believe Gillian is a robot outsider and ugh, everything she plans from there is just wackiness, it's impossible to get behind, it becomes mostly about farce and comedy from there. I just found that disappointing, especially considering how much time the book spends with her.

Some of the Matrix gags with The Protagonists didn't really land for me, but all of it seems believable for how corny these 4channer types are, so, I don't really mark that as a negative necessarily. I just really dislike reference humor whenever it pops up, and this bit wasn't particularly funny.

So, the story didn't really get over the finish line and live up to the potential that excited me at the start, but I really liked it all the same. The first half is excellent, and the second half is perfectly good, so yeah, a great read overall. I'll definitely be checking out more of Daryl Gregory's work.



Field Guide for the Formerly Villainous by Autumn K. England had me grinding my teeth through most of the book, it is as if Claude was directed to combine Stardew Valley with additional parameters [heckin_good_puppers], [baked_goods], [found_family], [nonbinary_protagonist], [managing_panic_attack], and [spice_level_none], and boy howdy, none of this stuff matters in the story. It's the literary equivalent of one of those places that has a teetering pile of random colorful sweets on top of a flavorless waffle.

I think this marks the last of these romantasy books I'm going to try, they're so so soulless, they're the Tom Clancy books of the romance genre. Essentially, this is a dating sim, the main character is a personality void that tries to avoid interacting with people, but a host of hot, intensely empathetic, dateable prospects chase them down and do not relent until they have paired off and lived happily ever after. They are gifted a cottage and a farm that is in perfect shape. They are told what to do by a ghost of a grandmother who gives them all the right answers for their farm to be completely successful. Everyone immediately loves them and they never experience a moment of struggle.

As with a lot of other romance books I've read, the main character does not make any real choices, they remain as they are at the start of the story and are "discovered" by a perfect mate, who affirms that they don't need to change anything or even state something they want. I think this is also why I bounce off of most dating sims and shows, they're just surface-level wish fulfillment and seem so supremely lazy. I'm sure you, reader, know this to be true and wonder why I do not, but I like to experience this with my own two peepers.

I stuck with this one to the end because there was a nugget of a possibility of some juicy drama (much like I experienced with The Enchanted Greehouse earlier), where the protagonist had joined a cult that was only recently disbanded by adventurers, and was keeping that secret from everyone in this new town. This premise is pretty solid I think! They did some fucked-up stuff in the cult that they escaped and regret and will have to reckon with.

But, it's revealed that the cult initially presented itself as a school for learning magic for free, so the protagonist is blameless for escaping is religious fundamentalist family to join them, and further, the leader of the cult mind controlled everyone and that's why they rampaged around the land, meaning they are also completely blameless for that. So they feel guilty for no good reason, and every character in the story reminds them of that over and over until they accept it and move on. You couldn't have the protagonist fuck up a LITTLE? Have them do something bad or reckless and have to admit that and apologize for it and struggle with it? You had to make them completely morally pure all the way through, a victim entirely in an impossible situation, whose guilt only exists to prove how nice they are? Ugh. Ugh ugh.
 
Read Beyond the Curve, a collection of Kobo Abe's short fiction ranging from 1949 - 1966. While some of the writing felt a little dated now (a few of the stories have the sort of heavy-handed didactic feel of early sci-fi), the ideas still felt fresh and worthwhile. Honestly, some of them could've just as easily been written today.
 
Just got but haven't yet cracked open Horde of the Counterwind. A French friend told me about it nearly a decade ago, but it was never translated until now, when its English version released two-ish weeks ago. It's cited as an inspiration for Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 and I'm 100% sure that's why someone finally felt it might sell well enough to be worth translating, since all of the SEO mentions COE33 pretty noticeably. Hey, if that's what it takes!
 
Finished Hellboy: The Wild Hunt and Hellboy in Hell, the series that was designed to end the series. I have mixed feelings. Overall, the art and story are good. The problem for me is while there's no lack of action in the Wild Hunt, it's also lots of revelations and before he can really do anything about it, it's more revelations. Then Hellboy moping about it. It's a bit too much of moping. But overall, it's good. Hellboy in Hell is better but much quieter. It's more an epilogue, albeit an epic one but it also clearly feels Mignola's writing these great little one-off stories set in Hell, sidelining the main narrative, then the main narrative coming to an abrupt end. It's also moping but this feels right for the story; Hellboy is in Hell, no hope of returning and somehow basically the destruction of Hell is... kinda sad. It's a bit disjointed and Mignola calls the end of it a parade of little stories but the quality never dips. I can see why some where disappointed with the ending but I like it, even though I wanted something... else I think. But there's also another series Hellboy in Love and I'm curious if it is a continuation of the narrative that seems to have a definitive end or if it's a flashback story.
 
I enjoyed The Curse of Chalion by Lois McMaster Bujold, certainly one of the best fantasy books I've read for a long while. It hews pretty realistic and features Mothra's Favorite™, a war trauma-mired broken man who Carries It With Him and is thus a good survivor for this world.

Cazaril is one of a host of well-rounded, lively characters who feel as though they are of their world, behaving reasonably based on their knowledge of history and their class. For a character to grow beyond their station, they must be exposed to the world beyond in some way, coloring their worldview and their relationship to the gods. Characters aren't just good or just because it would be nice if this was so, their empathy flows from their experiences. That really goes a long way throughout the twists and turns of this book.

Bujold presents an alternate Castile and León during the time of the Reconquista, where the dominant religion revolves around five gods who embody various aspects of life. Different nations have different variants, similar to Abrahamic religions in our world, and these add to the usual othering and national conflict. Being one step removed from the Reconquista and mixing in the gods allows Bujold to use the aesthetic, technology and political color of the real world while making it fresh and interesting.

It reminded me a good deal of Game of Thrones in how it tried to hew as realistic as possible, a single person or a small group unable to change the tides of nations, but making incremental, strategic actions to move things according to their values. A risk is never taken here without a plan, without a vision that instills the confidence to propel action, and I greatly appreciated seeing each major moments earned like this.

I really liked Cazaril as the protagonist, his suffering as a slave proving to reshape his entire worldview. He is a traumatized survivor who tasted death and was broken, and rose all the stronger, all the more contemplative for it. I love a "hero" figure like this, who is humble without performance, realistic without cynicism, and embodying truly of the values he still holds close to his chest. Best part of the book for me was his recollection of him being stripped and hung on the back of the slave ship to taunt the enemy, unraveling to his core, and the "fear is my friend" revelations that came of it... that's the juice.

I have some gripes. The constant refrain that Cazaril is "old" at 35 had me grinding my teeth a bit but life expectancy in the 15th century was 30-40 so honestly, that tracks I suppose. I again see Bujold pairing a man of nearly 40 with a young woman of 19 - something I also saw in Falling Free - sooooo I just want to note that it's a weird, unequal dynamic that she keeps writing into stories (I suppose here you could just chalk it up to the times again, though). Lastly, I never like prophecy whenever it rears its head in a story, and this is no exception. Why were the requirements to break the curse just so - not working at all if not exact - and who received the prophecy, and why weren't further questions asked about it? Seems like such a long period of suffering, closing on being forgotten and thus never broken, it makes the gods seem dumb, which is not what I think Bujold was going for.

But, those aside, I immensely enjoyed the ride. There are no big dumb action sequences, there are substantial planned moments of action and reaction, like in life.

"As we were being chased off, I failed at my ore, fainting in the heat. To make some use of me, despite all, the oremaster hauled me out of my chains, stripped me, and hung me over the stern rail with my hands tied to my ankles, to mock our pursuers. I couldn't tell if the crossbow bolts that thumped into the rail, or the stern around me, were good or bad aim on the Brajarian archers' parts. Nor by what god's mercy I didn't end my life with a few in my ass. Maybe they thought I was Roknari. Maybe they were trying to end my misery.

You know, we lived with fear for months on end, till we were used to it. A sort of nagging ache in the gut that we learned to ignore, but that never quite went away?"

Palli nodded.

"But I found out that... this is odd, I don't quite know how to say it." He never had a chance to try put it into words, out where he could see it, until now. "I found there is a place beyond fear, where the body and the mind just can't sustain it anymore. The world, time, reorder themselves. My heartbeat slowed down. I stopped sweating, and salavating, it was almost like some holy trance. When the Roknari hung me up, I had been weeping in fear and shame, in agony for the disgust of it all. When the Brajarians finally veered off, and the oremaster took me down, all blistered from the sun. I was laughing. The Roknari thought I'd gone mad, and so with all did my poor benchmates, but I didn't think so. The whole world was all... new.

Of course, the whole world was only a few dozen paces long and made of wood and rocked on the water. All time was the turning of a glass. I planned my life by the hour as closely as one plans a year. And no further than an hour. All men were kind and beautiful each in his way, Roknari and slave alike, lordly nor vile blood, and I was a friend to all, and smiled. I wasn't afraid anymore. I did take care never to faint at my ore again. So whenever fear comes back into my heart, I am more pleased than anything for I take it as a sign that I am not mad after all. Or maybe, at least, getting better. Fear... is my friend."

“We lords, at our oars, then? We sweating, pissing, swearing, grunting gentlemen? I think not, Palli. On the galleys we were not lords or men. We were men or animals, and which proved which had no relation I ever saw to birth or blood. The greatest soul I ever met there had been a tanner, and I would kiss his feet right now with joy to learn he yet lived. We slaves, we lords, we fools, we men and women, we mortals, we toys of the gods—all the same thing, Palli. They are all the same to me now.”

“I don’t duel, boy. I kill as a soldier kills, which is as a butcher kills, as quickly, efficiently, and with as least risk to myself as I can arrange.”



Had some mixed thoughts about The City & The City by China Miéville. I loved the setting a lot, but was really lukewarm on the story and the characters. It also seems to argue that the insane system they live under is fine as-is and is worth preserving?

I remember there being controversy around this guy from back in 2018ish, but information's hard to find on the specifics. This could be China's publisher scrubbing it from the web really well, it could be the girlfriend choosing to take the posts down for another reason... it's unfortunately not stated.

We do know that in 2018, his girlfriend of the time accused him of being abusive:

(I'm going to put the girlfriend's name as "B" and him as "M")

B accused M of severe emotional distress, exploitation, and psychological harm, describing a pattern of manipulative behavior and playing with her feelings under the guise of affection.

It looks like they were in an open relationship and then it came apart. I tracked down B's original post on the wayback machine. It seems like he pretended to be in love with her and cheated on her. People point to them being in an open relationship but I would imagine that she did not think this was one at the time and he later characterized it as such, but again, no way to really tell.

From B:

And I realised, when you said, “I never told you I loved you. I was very careful about that. I said I adored you - but that’s not love,” that I had been set up.

In the years of the aftermath I have confided in too many women who then paled and told me that you had done the same to them, or to a close friend, or colleague. I have learned, with a sickness I cannot put into words, that your mistreatment is not just serial but simultaneous: there is a mass, a morass, a mess of abuse.

Sounds like really shitty behavior, for sure. Two friends of mine also pointed out that China has collaborated with fucking Zak S on a children's book called *The Worst Breakfast*, so that does point to who he associates with. I'm a little hesitant to full-on sexual-predator cancel this guy for cheating but those are definitely some ill signs, and the extent of the abuse is something I'd love to know more about. I do also think it's worth noting that he is annoying and occasionally corny, neither of which are a crime but further makes one not want to bother defending him.

I'm happy to continue the conversation elsewhere if desired, didn't want to derail the book thread with that.

If ever a setting could carry a story, it's here. The complicated and surreal reality of Besźel and Ul Qoma as two cities within one city is quite fascinating, and it's a great fit for a detective book, where one must first understand what "normal" looks like and thus, what is abnormal. That's really the meat of the book - this place. I think Miéville does a great job conveying the way language and religion and aesthetic and even history differs between these two nations that exist in the same place. I genuinely found that really cool.

The mystery itself and how it is pursued and resolved is honestly surprisingly straightforward, ever concerned with ensuring things are done Properly, in alignment with The Rules. Even moments of what seems like rebellion are in fact a prostration to a "higher" authority of Breach, who they, by design, know nothing about. I know they are not allowed to think about it, but does this not make them uneasy, knowing they are under the thumb of an alien authority whose justice is never explained or understood?

That's all to say, I think the characters feel very real and I love the dialogue and the world is fascinating, but the actual story of this book isn't anything particularly special. I was a bit disappointed to find how unremarkable the cause of and resolution to the main conflict of the book was (money). I can't bring myself to dip this below 4 stars, though, because it really is quite interesting as a place.

You are thankfully shown, rather than told, how these two cities work, how they exist as one but separate thing(s). People's lives are shaped by it, their opinions are like two different nations who have never visited each other, and yet, they are trained from birth to unsee and forget, always, and so they can't really ever think about the other in a substantial way. I pondered if there would be anything to be gained from explaining more about how things became this way, or why Breach exists at all, or why everyone is so happy to carry on without questioning this grand overriding authority. I can certainly think of a more interesting story in that space than what we got. There are tantalizing little details, such as how far back in the past this situation came to be, but it is not explored. I suspect some rule of Weird Fiction is that you can't explain anything or it "loses its power", which was a inclination that reminded me of the 50s/60s sci-fi fad of writing an entire story where the only interesting thing that happens is in the final sentence, for that Twilight Zone twist. I tend to feel like the story should start there, and dive in, rather than run its hands over it like a plasma ball.

What sticks with me is that, when The City & The City is not exploring the day-to-tday of their surreal situation, It's really mainly concerned with stating what the Rules are and what one would have to do to do things Properly, so that the actions that are squabbled over and decided are Correct and presumably, in their eyes, Just. I don't think our heroes are as devoted to what is Just as I might hope, but rather, more interested in what is Proper. It's impressive to see them tie themselves in knots to ensure no major rule of Besźel, Ul Qoma, or Breach are violated, but when you're several pages into characters still debating how to "legally" do something they know they should do, it's just a little disappointing they don't feel compelled to simply act. I would've enjoyed a little more rumination on how this maze they are made to navigate is insane, and how things are real and are there in front of them, despite what anyone says. The conclusion that things must remain a maze because Those Are The Rules is pretty unsatisfying, and the ending showing Borlú joining Breach to enforce it felt like a real "oh I got power now, I'm okay with all of this actually" moment.

Worth a read for a the setting, but don't expect the story or the character development to blow you away. I think Miéville's prose is great and I think I'll check out Perdido Street Station, but he does kind of ick me out so I don't think I'll go much deeper than that. I think I'm more of a M. John Harrison guy in that "new weird" genre.



I was a bit underwhelmed by The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison, which made a lot of sense when I looked into it and saw that this was written 17 years before Beloved. It is an unrelentingly tragic trudge of racism and self-hatred whittling every character down to their bones in a way that started to lose its punch pretty early. I think Beloved benefited a lot from intermingling moments of joy with the sadness and the loss, as you could keep the hope alive as much as the characters did (making it much more painful when that hope is torn away). Here, it was all hopeless, all the time.



Didn't really love Falling Free by Lois McMaster Bujold, my second Bujold book and a prequel to one of her main series. I found a lot of elements charming - the way all of our heroes are engineers and problem solve with engineering methods, the theory of the romance between the augmented four-armed human and the main guy, the nuances of working in space - but it's one of those sci-fi stories about everyone reasonably creating a big plan to address a existential problem and then doing that plan without any real hiccups or complications. It's nice and all, just, not much of a story. This ALSO included what I'm starting to see is a Bujold staple: Huge problematic age difference between the man (40) and the woman (16?), reminding me a lot of Chalion's 35/19 pairing. Why does she keep doing these? Something I've started keeping an eye out for with her stories.



I didn't end up super loving Some Desperate Glory by Emily Tesh, though I like what it tried to do in many ways and I think it spent its focus (character-wise) in the right places. One of those stories you need to quiet the part of your brain that asks questions to really get into. Another YA-type book that doesn't state it's YA? I suspect that's a publisher decision.

I think this is capably written and it goes down easy, so if you're in the mood for something like this, it's a fine book to put on in the background while you're doing something. I liked some things about the setting, I generally liked the main character's arc and I appreciated how everyone in this story feels shaped by this world (and by their empire). Appreciated the Babylon 5-esque "Earth lost the war" premise and my favorite parts were seeing how this affected human society. Big fan of the unusual setup where humanity are about twice as tall and strong as your average alien, making them all very wary and fearful of us. Good audiobook reading by Sena Bryer too! I love her choice for Yiso in particular.

I have some gripes but honestly, Tesh commits to an interesting perspective - the indoctrinated fascist kept blind by a steady feed of fear and anger - and treats the character seriously, showing us what a struggle it is to deprogram. Again and again, Kyr and her friends relapse into the party line, into the easy story they've lived their entire lives believing. We see it resurface again and again, even when they believe they are free of it. I really appreciated that element of the story, it kept me on-board all the way through. It's refreshing to see a story present a flawed protagonist and actually put in the time to show her struggle towards being something nobler.

It's also more than little YA, especially once you hit the last third of the book. Avi is very quippy and Kyr seems to want to entertain the reader, which grated on me, though it's usually her thoughts and not her spoken dialogue. The Wisdom - an unknowably powerful supercomputer created by the Majo - is the main source of conflict and twists of drama in the book, having the power to change reality and see into the future, leading to its choice to inscrutably call for the fascistic Earth's destruction. I liked the idea of The Wisdom being this thing that drove the Majota's actions without them understanding its reasoning (which is true), becoming a sort of faith-based system where any majo will do whatever it asks to ensure The Wisdom's will is done. As the book progresses, though, and we learned more about it, it became less and less interesting. The Wisdom is evidently able to do literally anything one can imagine(?), if you ask it(?), meaning that it is wielded like a gun by various bad actors to commit unthinkable atrocities . It will then undo these things if asked. This leads to a real disconnect where you can't really bring yourself to care too much about what's happening, because none of it reeeeeally matters, it's like a video game player save-scumming and trying to brute force their way out of a game over. A lot of little things started pulling me more and more out of the story: Why is it so easy to hack into this impossibly complex supercomputer? Why is Jole still an obsessed and angry zealot even in the universe where he has everything he ever wanted? Why did hemming and hawing about nonbinary pronouns take up so much airtime in this far future setting? How is a supercomputer about to shift our universe into other simulated ones? To the tune of obliterating thousands of planets at a thought, or traveling through time, or perceiving countless parallel universes (are these not rewritten when time is changed)? Shouldn't this thing be under the most insane security ever imagined, if not by the majo than by The Wisdom itself? So if everyone is sentient in simulations made by The Wisdom, isn't this a crazy Torment Nexus that no sane majo ("sentient") would allow? I don't think you're really supposed to think too much about the hows and whys, which leaves the whats, which I just didn't think were too interesting. You need to just ignore those questions to stick with the story.

There is some musing on utopia at the start of the last third, and the way fascism develops from this idea at times, and while that's perfectly nice, it's again quite YA in how uninterested it is in going deeper. The "end of the Twilight Zone" narration monologue is enough apparently, and man, this passage summarizing its moral argument by quoting the Beatles' "Imagine" did some psychic damage to me.

By the time I finished, I was happy to be done but I did like the book. I think its aims are laudable and it explores some interesting ideas, and if you're willing to quiet the part of your brain that is asking questions about the nature of their universe, there's a fun little story in here.
 
I was a bit underwhelmed by The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison, which made a lot of sense when I looked into it and saw that this was written 17 years before Beloved. It is an unrelentingly tragic trudge of racism and self-hatred whittling every character down to their bones in a way that started to lose its punch pretty early. I think Beloved benefited a lot from intermingling moments of joy with the sadness and the loss, as you could keep the hope alive as much as the characters did (making it much more painful when that hope is torn away). Here, it was all hopeless, all the time.
Hmm, this is on my Classics book club list for next year, will be good to keep in mind.
 
I'm almost done with Raekwon's autobiographical From Staircase to Stage: The Story of Raekwon and the Wu-Tang Clan. I've been a fan of Wu-Tang Clan since the 90s, so it's really interesting to read a first-person account of their history. Even from the outside, even for someone who isn't actively paying attention to hip-hop publications or rumors, it's been obvious that the Clan has had a fair share of infighting, and Raekwon's story pretty much just confirms what "everyone" knew already. RZA is a legendary producer and the Wu-Tang Clan wouldn't exist without him, but he's also occasionally very much a dictator and the band members have been financially screwed over many times. It's clear that Raekwon has done a lot of introspection about his (and his bandmates') actions and he is treating everyone with as much respect as possible - even in cases where he's been treated unfairly. His insightful attitude isn't limited to his work in the music business, but he's also very thoughtful when he's talking about his life and past relationships; he's always very respectful about his exes and he owns up when he has acted immaturely (like when he got a woman pregnant while he was in a relationship with a different person and then refused to interact with his child until she was six years old). He's not making excuses for his past behavior, but at the same time, I'm sure there are things he's intentionally not bringing up at all. Anyway, if you're into 90s hip-hop, this book is a treasure trove of stories from the time, but if not, I'm not sure there's much here beyond the vivid first part about living as a poor Black child in Staten Island from the mid-70s onwards.
 
I've also made good progress on The Three Musketeers for my classics book club. I've read a lot of passages from it and am pretty sure I've read an abridged version before too. It's nice to read the full thing. I had definitely forgotten how goofy all the characters were.
Finished it. This is indeed a goofy book, with so much over the top drama and adventure. I had a lot of fun with this.
 
Few more recent reads:

At Blackwater Pond by Mary Oliver was a lovely book of naturalist poetry. My favorite poems from this collection were Peonies and Her Grave.



Small Gods by Terry Pratchett was excellent, as you might expect. Has a lot of substantial and true things to say about belief, organized religion, worship, and faith, all delivered with a good measure of humor at the frequent absurdity of human effort. My favorite part was that whole stretch in the desert.

This was a real treat. One of the best Pratchett stories I've read, and certainly one of the best stories about organized religion and belief. As usual, there's a pretty goofy top-level story with a ton of depth to be found whenever it decides to dig a little deeper, which is often. Pratchett's writing is fun and clever and efficient, often revealing the most interesting thing in the room, finding the best angle to come at the next bit of plot progression so that you're touring about the people that live in this world. He tells the truth about the matter every step of the way, and the humor effortlessly flows from the frequent absurdity of humanity's struggle to construct meaning.

I liked Vorbis as the villain a lot. He is a true believer, something I wasn't sure would be true or not by the end. Most other stories would have him simply be a power-mad huckster, but it's much more interesting that he drinks his own kool-aid and legitimately doesn't realize how far things have strayed from anything Om once said. Further, I absolutely loved how the divine work in the Pratchett universe, where they are a form of life like any other, metabolizing faith to keep alive, changing with their believer's whims and misconceptions, being shaped by those who would worship. I have some gripes about how fully it leaned into the "gods are lazy buffoons" element for comedy, because that joke started wearing on me pretty quickly, but it was also true to how people in power behave so I didn't really mind. Generally speaking, Pratchett's idea of what gods are is frequently fascinating.

There are a ton of little scenes all throughout that I thought where fantastic. Freet going to assassinate Vorbis because he'd already been double-damned to hell for eternity, what else could they do to him? Or Didactylos' street sermoning where he talks about how you don't need to believe in things that exist (like the Great A'Tuin, only that which doesn't exist requires faith. The entire desert sequence was probably the highlight of the book, the forgotten gods, the messianic journey Brutha finds himself on without realizing it... this book really goes places.

The audiobook reading was good, I'd recommend it. His Om can be a little bit annoying, but I suppose that's the character. I can definitely see myself giving this a reread in a few years.



No Flight Without the Shatter by Brooke Bolander was similar to her other (great) book The Only Harmless Great Thing, where I found the prose wonderful and evocative and complex, and the story kinda eh. This one is about environmental devastation and while it sorta bangs on the same drum the whole way through, the way each character and place is realized and described makes it well worth the read.



All Systems Red by Martha Wells didn't really do it for me, but it's definitely a perfectly fine scifi story. I think the fact that it's a "diary", being told by Murderbot to another person, takes so, so much out of what this could have been. You are now simply told that Murderbot has social anxiety and depression, and struggles to find meaning, rather than seeing it. To me, this was an entire book where the most interesting thing by far happening was inside the mind of a character who was aware of their story (because they were telling it) and did not want people interested in it, they wanted them to go away.

I think this might actually be one where I'd enjoy the show more, since we're already on the outside anyways, a good amount of it is action (which I thought was well-described), and of course, I love me some Alexander Skarsgård (though this does unintentionally give Murderbot a gender in a way I don't love).
 
I mentioned this before, but I do find that the Murderbot books get better as you go. You don't really have enough time in the first novel(la) to see a lot of characterization, but it arrives in bits over the rest of the stories. It's still something of a popcorn sci-fi series, but it does gain a little depth as it goes.

The TV show is fun, although they make the scientists on the team incredible dumbasses for comedic reasons.
 
Back
Top