Astrid is an insecure and judgemental writer in her mid-30's chasing the dragon of her vision of the Good Lesbian™ (by L.A. standards), and the story is basically about her learning to pull away from the endless performance of her world and enjoy a real thing. As the POV character, she's petty and mean-spirited and dismissive when she's trying to perform, but smart and romantic when she's not, with no idea how to operate as that side of herself. So, this checks the boxes of the main character having some interesting shit going on, with her main love interest also being a fairly complex person with her own wants and fears and quirks. Penelope, the hippie-ish older fem top Astrid becomes obsessed with, is the highlight of the book for me, I enjoyed all of her scenes the most.
I have a bunch of gripes but it's tied a lot to the fact that the story needs Astrid to be "problematic" so it can put her in conflict with modern queer culture, she's supposed to be judgemental and up her own ass, she dismisses therapy as fake, dislikes butch women because they're too masc, seems teetering on the TERF cliff because she's annoyed with young queers, and will do cartoon white woman stuff like judge others for having the wrong astronomy sign etc etc. Most of the humor of the book flows from this and it's pretty clear you're not really supposed to take these as the author's (current) opinions, but the story doesn't do a whole lot with this realm where modern queerness butts up against purely lesbian culture, and I was left wondering why it was even in there at all. Astrid eventually just steps away from it, which, I dunno, I felt like was backing away just when we were getting into the real messy shit.
(
From this quite good interview with the author)
Dorn: I turned 35 and realized a lot of my bad behavior wasn’t cute anymore. It probably wasn’t cute long before that, but it became glaring at 35. I guess one’s personality sort of crystalizes at 35. So if you’re in a bad place around there, changing becomes high stakes.
...
Maybe that’s why Astrid shares a lot of biographical details with me. I’m pretty boring, so my bad behavior was nowhere near as bad as Astrid’s. And she’s much hotter and more successful than me.
The friend that recommended it compared it to
Yellowface in that it similarly has a very unflattering and messy representation of a type of person that does exist, even if it's a sort we're uncomfortable with. I think I just liked that Astrid wasn't the same perfect, inoffensive, bland POV heroine I've been seeing in the romances I've been reading. The book gets out-of-jail-free a lot by nature of being "satirical" and "pulp" but I also feel like that often thwarts the story saying something interesting or getting its hands dirty. But this didn't really impact my enjoyment much.
About half of every chapter is a meditation on L.A. lesbian culture, which I liked, as it directly related to the main character's whole arc. The way she saw more in gay culture's interest in traditionally feminine things than lesbian culture's interest in traditionally masculine things, the way men would typically covet youth while lesbians coveted maturity, how she didn't know how to face aging out of her previous role in the community, all that was good.
I reeeeally loved how smell was consistently a part of the description. This almost never happens in a story, but here, the scent she picks up in a place or on a person adds so much to the character of the place, it really cashed that check the title wrote. Loved every time a scent of perfume was described like a flavor or when the smell of a person would intoxicate or repulse her. It really says a lot about how she feels, without being something she rationally considers. Really jumped out at me in a good way.
Probably going to check out
Exalted by Dorn next, I generally liked her writing style.
[/details]