• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

Podcast Recommendations

Wax Audio
It's a relatively new podcast with high production values and quality. Essential if you're into 80's hard rock. They've done two huge episodes on famous and reclusive record produce Mutt Lange (AC/DC, The Cars, Def Leppard) and a huge episode on Van Halen unreleased archive recordings.
 

Octopus Prime

Mysterious Contraption
(He/Him)
Sitcom D and D
It’s the other show from Hey Riddle Riddle co-host Erin Keif (and others, but I mainly know her and mainly from that) and it’s got a fun hook and a great cast; using DND mechanics to play through stock sitcom plots. The first couple of episodes lean on the central gimmick a bit too much (lots of canned laughter and fake audience gasps) but after the second or third episode that really falls to the wayside and the show finds it’s groove to be like a more surreal Always Sunny.
 

Octopus Prime

Mysterious Contraption
(He/Him)
Anyone have any recommendations for podcasts in the vein of The Twilight Zone

I feel like there must be hundreds but know of none.
 

Dark Medusa

Diamond Crusader
(He/they)
So I'm curious, since now I'm officially a Podcast Producer for Stereo Chemistry, Chemical & Engineering News (a part of the American Chemical Society). What would make you listen to a scientific podcast? Would you want to hear scientific trivia, history, or concepts? Conversations between scientists? What style tends to bring you in and get you interested?
 

Falselogic

Lapsed Threadcromancer
(they/them)
So I'm curious, since now I'm officially a Podcast Producer for Stereo Chemistry, Chemical & Engineering News (a part of the American Chemical Society). What would make you listen to a scientific podcast? Would you want to hear scientific trivia, history, or concepts? Conversations between scientists? What style tends to bring you in and get you interested?
Just do whatever it is Alie Ward is doing w/ Ologies.
 

FelixSH

(He/Him)
So I'm curious, since now I'm officially a Podcast Producer for Stereo Chemistry, Chemical & Engineering News (a part of the American Chemical Society). What would make you listen to a scientific podcast? Would you want to hear scientific trivia, history, or concepts? Conversations between scientists? What style tends to bring you in and get you interested?
I think I'd like a slow introduction, so that I actually understand the concepts. Ideally, told in the way of stories, so that the information sticks (like how the concept you present has been found). As someone interested in History, I prefer it to be chronological, so I will at some point have a really good understanding of the state of chemistry (in this case).

Personally, I'm not really interested in interviews. But that's partly, because the guests often speak pretty unclear, and with English as my second language, the barrier is still there. But aside from that, I simply prefer to hear an episode of a podcast as a story told.

That said, I am probably not the norm. Maybe you can just try out different formats, and stick with what works best for you, and where you get the best feedback from listeners.
 

ThornGhost

lofi posts to relax/study to
(he/him)
I'm also probably not going to be the best source of making a popular scientific podcast, but I've become very ...weary... of the edutainment style podcasts so popular in the "science" podcast world. You feel like you're learning something but often it seems to me that it trends toward ego stroking of the listeners, prioritizing the story/entertainment portion and even veering into editorializing by the non-scientist hosts.

Either give me a couple of scientists talking at the very highest levels in a casual way to give me interesting items to look up more fully later, or focus on actually teaching a concept, even if it is boring.

In Our Time is about all I can stomach these days.
 

FelixSH

(He/Him)
You know, these are actually good points. A reason why I don't listen to science podcasts is that nothing sticks. Which is partly me, I learn bad from listening. But the ones I listened to (which is years ago, so no idea how relevant this point even is) felt shallow. As ThornGhost said, more interested in entertaining, instead of teaching. And at this point, why even bother?

I do like stories as a medium of explaining things, but it should always be subservient to teaching things, at least within a scientific podcast.

As an example, I still like History podcasts a lot. Where the whole "tell a story" style really works, because History consists of stories. But I never was at all interested in something like a podcast that acted like you were in the middle of things, or something. Mike Duncan is still a favourite podcaster of mine.

But then, I also prefered the teacher talking, instead of looking at historical artifacts, and never understood why people felt like History came to live that way, or whatever. Just give me interesting information, but do it in a way that doesn't put me to sleep.

Sorry, I'm surprisingly interested in this topic, despite probably not being very representative of the larger podcast listener population. So, again, don't give my takes too much credit, I might be the only one they apply to.
 

Dark Medusa

Diamond Crusader
(He/they)
I'm also probably not going to be the best source of making a popular scientific podcast, but I've become very ...weary... of the edutainment style podcasts so popular in the "science" podcast world. You feel like you're learning something but often it seems to me that it trends toward ego stroking of the listeners, prioritizing the story/entertainment portion and even veering into editorializing by the non-scientist hosts.

Either give me a couple of scientists talking at the very highest levels in a casual way to give me interesting items to look up more fully later, or focus on actually teaching a concept, even if it is boring.

In Our Time is about all I can stomach these days.
So I do want to get a little more in the weeds with y'alls suggestions because they're great, but for now just a quick response and a question:

I agree that edutainment doesn't stick, it's meant to make you enjoy it and feel like you're learning without really learning. I agree with having two scientists talk science is fairly interesting, but most scientists aren't good at communicating in a way that is "casual" enough for a listener to follow, so you'd need to either coach them up or have people good at speaking already. I agree, though, that this tends to be the way I swing, and Stereo Chemistry attempted to do something like this with their series Bonding Time.

My main question here: why can you stomach In Our Time? What about it makes it listenable?
 

muteKi

Geno Cidecity
I think that every audio podcast should take advantage of its form and reserve at least a small amount of time to narrative poetry, especially parodies of those already likely to be familiar to a general audience.

Ex.

In Zurich U. did Kubler-Ross
A model of our grief decree
First used for dying, then for loss
Its weakness should be put across:
Not shown empirically
 

ThornGhost

lofi posts to relax/study to
(he/him)
My main question here: why can you stomach In Our Time? What about it makes it listenable?

In Our Time has an almost lopsided amount of time dedicated to subject matter expert voices versus host voice than your average edutainment podcast. Melvyn Bragg prioritizes his guests' responses to his own questions.

He certainly asks questions, but he's more of a round table moderator than a podcast host trying to tell a story. He also ensures each guest has ample opportunity to speak on their own niche of the subject. He's been knighted for this kind of work. The show is practically unassailable.

Where it may not track exactly with what you are doing is that the show has either very deep pockets, very deep connections to academia or both.

Also, In Our Time spends next to no time trying to sell a listener on why any one topic is important to learn about. You either bring your own interest or you tap out. It can be, on the surface, quite dry. Despite that being refreshing to some, it can make casual listeners bounce off.

Best of luck! I podcast myself, but in the totally opposite direction of importance haha
 

Paul le Fou

24/7 lofi hip hop man to study/relax to
(He)
I've been considering adding Friends at the Table to my repertoire, mostly because I heard they were doing Lancer stuff on their Patreon at the moment. Is there a good place to jump in, or should I just go back to the beginning?
 
I've been considering adding Friends at the Table to my repertoire, mostly because I heard they were doing Lancer stuff on their Patreon at the moment. Is there a good place to jump in, or should I just go back to the beginning?

They have a chart answering this very question!

SjR4Lzd.jpg


But if you want to listen to them play a certain system, nothing wrong with just jumping to that.
 

Dark Medusa

Diamond Crusader
(He/they)
I also somewhat disagree with the chart- I don't think Marielda was a great place to come in. I listened to Marielda, was confused about what it all meant and was annoyed with how the short nature of that campaign didn't let the Blades system really flow, and going straight into "Winter in Hieron" didn't help very much. It took starting with Counter/Weight about two years later before I even really enjoyed it.

Personally, I think you're forced to start with Marielda or Counter/Weight (and I'd argue the latter is A LOT better for it, even with its own hangups I could talk about if you wanted), but their most recently finished series Sangfielle is also meant to be standalone, and if you wanted to see what "modern" Friends at the Table sounds like, it could be a good place to start, although you have to be ok with a horror theme. Also, I haven't gotten to Sangfielle yet (I'm still in Partizan!) so I can't speak to its quality, although what little I've heard sounded great.
 

Paul le Fou

24/7 lofi hip hop man to study/relax to
(He)
Excellent, thank you both!
I also somewhat disagree with the chart- I don't think Marielda was a great place to come in. I listened to Marielda, was confused about what it all meant and was annoyed with how the short nature of that campaign didn't let the Blades system really flow
Was this Blades in the Dark or some other FitD game?
 

Dark Medusa

Diamond Crusader
(He/they)
For Marielda, they use Blades in the Dark. Later, in Twilight Mirage, they eventually go to Scum and Villainy, and all of Partizan is using Beam Sabre. (these are all FitD systems, is why I mention them)
 
Bandsplain on Spotify has given me dozens of hours of entertainment recently. Great conversations about rock bands. And because it's on Spotify, they can play full songs.


Guns n' Roses
Bad Brains
Metallica
Jawbreaker
PJ Harvey
Fugazi
Kate Bush
etc.
 
If anyone likes the idea of "gossipy true crime, but about the book world," please consider giving Missing Pages a listen. It received a positive review in New York magazine's print edition a few weeks back. This was extremely exciting, because I'm a producer on the show.

I'm also a guest on the latest episode. They needed a cynical ex-publishing person, and I just happened to be there...
 

Octopus Prime

Mysterious Contraption
(He/Him)
Monster Line is a new show from Adal Rifai (of Magic Tavern/Hey Riddle Riddle fame) and Katelyn Hempstead of Lizard People), and I think the best description is “Magic Tavern mixed with Neighborhood Listen, if it was based on horror monsters instead of fantasy creatures or weird neighbours”

It’s only a few episodes old and I’m sticking with it.
 

FelixSH

(He/Him)
The last episode of Mike Duncans Revolutions podcast is out. You know, the History of Rome guy. I'm still in the middle of the Russian revolution (Rasputin, WW I), but took a break to listen to that last one, to find out what he does next. After a break, it will be a podcast with a historian about History books. So, something very different. Just thought I would mention that here, it sounds interesting, but not enough for me, as I have too many other podcasts.

Anyway, I simply wanted to use that chance to tell people who liked History of Rome, but gave up on Revolutions early on, to give it another chance. Yes, the first series about the English Revolution (is that the name? The one with Oliver Cromwell) is really dense, and I didn't find it that great, even if it was interesting. And the second one, the American Revolution, is the weakest of the series. He talked about that, his plans were different at the beginning, to make each subseries 15 episodes long, or so. Which resulted in a very condensed narrative.

With the third series (I think that's already the French Revolution), the podcast gets really good. It's not only my opinion, but also the one from the host, that this is the place to start. If you had a hard time getting into Revolutions, give it a second chance, and start with the French Revolution. It's a really good series. And I think all the following ones are equally good. To me, the Haitian or the Mexican Revolution were completely new stuff, and very interesting, whereas I knew some stuff about the French Revolution, but it was still very interesting, and I learned a lot.

Anyway, if you gave up early, despite liking Duncan as a host, give it another shot. It's worth it, I think. You will learn a lot about 19th century Europe, plus a ton about Russia, especially in the 19th and early 20th century.
 

ThornGhost

lofi posts to relax/study to
(he/him)
Teg I went around asking that same question after I finished watching Only Murders in the Building. Just got me in the mood you know? I'm not an expert, but here are my picks:

(Trigger warning, all except for Wild Thing, these all feature dark themes like murder and suicide.)

Serial - season 1
Kind of launched the whole true crime podcast thing. Say what you will about the aftermath and the ethics of dredging up this kind of a cold case, but hot damn I was hooked. It remains the gold standard. The magic was gone after season 1, though. Not bad, just not great.

Gone South
Just a straight across the plate, well produced true crime podcast about a high profile, unsolved murder near New Orleans in the 1980s. Affairs! Drugs! Plots! McGruff the crime dog? Also they recently started season 2 which seems pretty good!

S-Town
S-Town isn't really a true crime podcast, but it's also not not a true crime podcast either. What seems like a simple audio bio of an antique clock repairman goes very, very dark and wrong. It's enthralling. Possibly a better listen than Serial, but also just enough off the mark of true crime that it might not quite scratch the itch.

Wild Thing - season 1
Wild Thing is a bit of an odd duck here. Kind of like S-Town, I wouldn't exactly call it a true crime podcast, but it's got enough of that DNA in it that you shouldn't overlook it. Wild Thing season 1 is about bigfoot (WAIT, STOP, DON'T GO), but more importantly the people that are looking for bigfoot and why they look. The host is a former NPR reporter and her style matches Serial's so closely that I legitimately laughed at times. There's that same thrill of tromping around looking for evidence, testing DNA, interviewing witnesses, all of that. And all without that moral pall of exploiting a crime for entertainment value.
 

Octopus Prime

Mysterious Contraption
(He/Him)
A new season of 20-Sided Stories is imminent, the intro episode is already live, and there will be 7 prologue eps before the show starts in earnest in February. I am already entirely and completely on board with this based on premise alone.

Unlike other seasons, which were adapting popular franchises using custom-made tabletop rules, this season is a wholly unique pirate adventure.
 

Kazin

did i do all of that?
(he/him)
S-Town
S-Town isn't really a true crime podcast, but it's also not not a true crime podcast either. What seems like a simple audio bio of an antique clock repairman goes very, very dark and wrong. It's enthralling. Possibly a better listen than Serial, but also just enough off the mark of true crime that it might not quite scratch the itch.

I highly recommend S-Town. It is dark, yes - in ways you sometimes don't see coming, and in ways you do. Serial was a fascinating puzzlebox of a podcast, but S-Town is just a great (and haunting) tale.

Wild Thing - season 1
Wild Thing is a bit of an odd duck here. Kind of like S-Town, I wouldn't exactly call it a true crime podcast, but it's got enough of that DNA in it that you shouldn't overlook it. Wild Thing season 1 is about bigfoot (WAIT, STOP, DON'T GO), but more importantly the people that are looking for bigfoot and why they look. The host is a former NPR reporter and her style matches Serial's so closely that I legitimately laughed at times. There's that same thrill of tromping around looking for evidence, testing DNA, interviewing witnesses, all of that. And all without that moral pall of exploiting a crime for entertainment value.

I know you already listened to this, @Tegan, so you know, this doesn't really apply to you (sorry lol), but while I enjoyed Wild Thing, it felt more to me like a deep dive on a subject than a sort of puzzlebox or story, really. It does feel like the odd one out of the things ThornGhost recommended.

The closest any podcast that I've heard that comes to feeling like Serial is Atlanta Monster. It can be quite a rough listen, though, as any description of the show will probably clue you in on real quick.
 

R.R. Bigman

Coolest Guy
I rarely ever listen to podcasts anymore. I’ve almost stopped listening to Retronauts entirely after certain events, and dropped the Bombcast after everybody left. It would be nice to find new ones, but I don’t know if I want hear a few people talk about any subject for two hours at this point in my life.
 
Can anyone recommend a good True Crime podcast? I've been listening to Crime Junkie because of the high ratings and sheer volume of content, but it's kind of lousy.

Bear Brook and Cold are some of the best series I've listened to outside of Serial - Season 1.
 

MCBanjoMike

Sudden chomper
(He/him)
Does anyone have any good videogame podcast recommendations? I used to listen to the Giant Bombcast religiously, but since the departures earlier this year my heart hasn't been in it. I currently listen to Nextlander and about every second episode of Waypoint Radio. I was a big fan of Idle Thumbs back in the day, if that helps to orient you. There's gotta be something good out there that I'm not aware of!
 
Top