• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

One Piece (Beware, spoilers)

I like that thought, about Devil Fruits channelling something from the past. And yeah, makes sense. I think you might have read a different translation than I, because looking at it, the mural is definitely translated differently now, than when I first read it.

I can't shake the feeling, that the bit from The Second World paints Joyboy in a not perfect light. He clearly started the war. But then, that might not be a bad thing, if the "Gods of the Forest" used devil fruits. Would be an interesting twist, if the conflict of the Lost Century was a bit more complicated, and Imu and not just a monster back then. Maybe a bit of a fake saviour, who used the legend of Nika to gain support by the people? Dunno, not that Joyboy is supposed to be EVIL now, I just would find it nice if the conflict was a bit more complex than what we (or at least I) expect it to be at the moment, with clear heroes and villains.

This is the lore drop of all lore drops, isn't it? That panel alone contains so, so much.
 
I can't even remember where we saw him up to now. I remember the design, but elsewise, no idea. Wouldn't have realized who it is, without Oda explicitely telling us.

Still, pretty cool. I assume Luffy now gets another mentor? I really wonder wht his role in this arc will be.
 
We’ve seen his old self wearing the Wano hat on the cover of Chapter 631, drinking with Crocus and Laboon, and then he talks to Marco before the latter came to Wano. His younger self appears in all the major Roger Crew flashback but hadn’t been connected to this older self until now
 
That last page, Loki standing, his face in shadow and blood - and then his grinning face. Amazing. Love it. And it's kinda crazy, that he is now (nearly) free. Kinda insane, that we are already there.

Sorry for repeating myself once more, but I just can't help it - I love the design of the giants, and seeing these specific ones in that boat together is such a nice panel. I'm still so happy, to be in Elbaf. It's such a cool place.

I want to see Loki now wreck something. Not necessarily the other giants, I want to see how strong he is, fighting against some actual enemies, like one of the holy knights. I generally trust Oda, but at the moment, I fear a bit that Loki might be a letdown (maybe that's why there is still some seastone on him, and he is deadly wounded, too). He is supposed to be this monster, nearly unbeatable giant of giants. But he can't just defeat that bandage woman whose name I forgot. Dunno, we'll see.

Oh, and I really enjoy Luffy/Zorro time. I really enjoy their chemistry and the way they work together.
 
Last edited:
I have little to add beyond what you already said, but I will say that I’m loving how Usopp is just as overjoyed to be there as we the audience are for him to be.
 
Wow, didn't understand how gigantic Loki is, until now. Great panel. Also, didn't expect him to go all in immediately, starting to wreck stuff. This seems really bad. But again, he is heavily hurt, so it should be possible to bring him down. But whatever happens, I expect the giants will, at least for now, have a different opinion of Luffy.

That, and the situation with the children - things going bad fast.

Also, a devil fruit that lets someone manifest nightmares of a person is a pretty cool idea. And the monsters don't seem to be that trivial to defeat.
 
Read through it a second time, and wanted to add a bit.

I love the design of the nightmare creatures. They look so goofy, but the way they are drawn in that panel, dwarfing the giants, is great, and makes them actively horrifying. Still, great, great designs. Don't even know which is my favourite, but I guess it's that wolf. Low-key favorite is the mum, which I missed the first time, hidden on the left between two speech bubbles.

Also, Oda is so good at drawing hits, where you can feel the impact. The panel, where the principal wrecks the snake with his giant hammer is awesome, as is Sauls punch. But also, Lokis hit against Yggdrasil is insane. And it's a beautiful panel, the way Loki is drawn, with his pelt, or whatever his cape is made out of.

Oh, and love the desing of the walrus giant, the principal. Not much to say, it's great, I love it. Especially after seeing him first in his role as principal, sitting peacefully at his chair, looking like a harmless, old dude. And then coming in, and hitting that snake with his giant hammer.

I'm hoping the Straw Hats that aren't with Luffy now will be shown fighting against the nightmares. Not sure, how effective some of them can be against these gigantic monsters, but then, they were able to fight against Orz, even before the time skip. I mean, Nami can throw thunderbolts, Usopp has his fun shooty seeds which should be able to do weird stuff, chopper can become pretty big himself, Robin too, when she isn't just in demon form, Jinbei is a powerhouse and Brook might be able to counter whatever sleep spell is on the kids, being a bard with weird, musical abilities. It would be a great opportunity to give them all a chance to shine.
 
I feel like we may not see proper fights here in this arc, given we had extended ones in Wano and presumably have ones coming up against the Blackbeard Pirates and possibly some senior marines, the Elders, and Imu. So I’m expecting more showcasey big hits and quick resolutions rather than fights where each crewmate shows their stuff.

But yeah, more good chapters rolling in. Interested where Oda is going with these Gods’ Knights, as they seem a late addition on top of all the stuff that wants wrapping up in the next few years.
 
Oh, I didn't mean one on one fights. I meant more, that despite their size and power, these nightmares are essentially trashmobs, and I want to see the Strawhats crash them. With some work, but not as extended fights. I think that would be fun. Maybe over one or two chapters, were we jump between Loki, and then we see one or two pages of Nami throwing a thunderbolt at the wolf, then back to Loki, than show Chopper wreck another nightmare. Something like that. But I think that's kinda similar to what you mean anyway.

The Gods Knights are interesting in any case. They just aren't the regular Celestial Dragons, these people are powerful. And the one who is transformed into a Kirin, I think, confuses me. Seems like someone like that wouldn't be accepted around the Celestial Dragons, having eaten a devil fruit (think that's taboo for them, isn't it?).

But yeah, I get a bit of a Worst Generation feeling from them, where Oda felt the need to add some spice, so he needed some extra group. Which makes sense, this way the Strawhats can actually interact with these assholes. And I assume Shamrock, and generally Shanks family, was always planned to be Celestial Dragons, and he needed a way for them to actively participate in the story, instead of just sitting around. And instead of just this one family, he probably thought "why not make up some more weirdos?", as he seemingly likes to do.
 
I had to laugh, when Loki went down. Just like that. And we already get to some truth. I guess it's time for a flashback? Short, I guess, but still.

I still don't get how some of the Celestial Dragons become people like this. The Gods Knights are so different, from how regular CDs behave. And there's no way, that Kirin-dude can live near "regular" looking CDs, he would be an abomination to them. I wonder, with them expecting people to be perfect, or something, maybe if a kid doesn't fulfill some weird, arbitrary standard, it might get killed. Or taken in to become a Gods Knight, someone outside of the regular society.
 
I suppose that God's Knights end up a bit quirkier and more human by spending time in the outside world and not just settling for a pampered life. Though they still clearly have the same total disregard for the lives of regular people. As for the Kirin dude I'm assuming this is him in a mixed Zoan state rather than his default human form.
 
That is a good thought, makes sense that being around other people might make you a bit more normal. Honestly, with them it hits even harder for me, when they act like normal people are garbage. I want to like them, at least the thorn dude, but he's just another ass.

Also, I'm watching a video about Smoker at the moment, and he is probably the character I miss the most. I hope he will get some time in the spotlight, at some point again, at least on the side. I loved his and Tashigis role in Alabasta, and he was such a powerful presence, when he first appeared (plus the way how he then apologizes to the girl who runs into him with the icecream is adorable).

I really like Smoker and Tashigi, it's a shame that he mainly vanished. I forgot, is he part of that fraction of the marines where Coby and Helmeppo are? Sword, I think?

Also, I can't stop thinking that he, at least the way he started out and hunted Luffy, is inspired by Les Miserables Javert.
 
He is in Sword as far as I know, yeah.

I wonder if Punk Hazard was meant to be the big Smoker arc and he’s more or less done now. Certainly his main intimidation factor early on was being a Logia and using Seastone, neither of which are all that scary anymore.
 
I love Colons design. Him on the ship was a great panel.

Dorry and Broggy coming to the rescue was great. Looking forward to seeing them wreck stuff, especially with Skopa Caban (no idea how to write his name, too lazy to look it up) there too.
 
Ooohh, that last two panels made me pumped. Also scared. I can't even say how this will play out, but...considering we have three enemies, and not all will be fought by Luffy, plus one of the fighters will be Skopa Gaban, I assume Killingham will be defeated. Would love to see Robin and Chopper aid in taking down one of those knights.
 
She had one in Wano, so not too long ago, assuming in-world time. But yeah, I'd still like for her to win this on her own. Not much hope, though. But I'm happy when she gets a fight, at all.

I feel like, considering were we are in the arc, that this one will be actually a shorter one. Crazy. Well, if true.
 
She did have a fight in Wano, and it was rad, but it's also true she rarely gets to shine as one of the fighters and now is the perfect time for another. To defend Saul? To defend the books from Ohana? It'd be disappointing if she didn't. I mean, how many straight fights has Robin even been in, not counting movies and filler? Skypiea? There was that one unimportant priest whose name I don't even remember. Water 7/Enies Lobby? Unless you count slapping the shit out of Spandam, zilch. Thriller Bark? She fought Hogback for a bit but that was mostly assisting Chopper. Sabaody and through the timeskip? Nope. Fishman Island? She briefly scuffled with Hammon when he popped back up but that hardly classifies as a fight. Punk Hazard? It almost looks like she was being set up to fight Monet but then Zoro took care of her. Dressrosa? She was about to help Usopp with Plum but she got doll'd. She wasn't on Whole Cake Island. And then we get to Wano, where she finally got a one-on-one again.

I really wish that in Egghead we had Robin be the one to take care of Lucci in the second half instead of Zoro. Maybe fans would have considered it too big a 'downgrade' for a fan favorite villain but it would have been more appropriate, just to show that she's come so far and never needs to even worry about the former CP9 agents again. Ah well.
 
SpoonyBard said:
I really wish that in Egghead we had Robin be the one to take care of Lucci in the second half instead of Zoro. Maybe fans would have considered it too big a 'downgrade' for a fan favorite villain but it would have been more appropriate, just to show that she's come so far and never needs to even worry about the former CP9 agents again. Ah well.
Click to expand...
I never even thought of that, but you are totally right. That would have been great.

And to be clear, I totally agree that Robin should have had more fights, and always found it frustrating that she didn't . So this is very welcome, and I hope she kicks ass here. And yeah, it's super appropriate.
 
I enjoyed this chapter a lot. Robins clever play was really fun to see. I do hope, that wasn't all, though. The last bit, the panicked face, that made me laugh. I guess we should have been expecting some way, to deal with the regeneration powers of the Holy Knights. There is certainly something, that Scopper Gaban can teach the Strawhats. Before he dies - he is of the old generation, and with him around for the whole arc, especially after seeing this, he needs to die for there to be anything to worry about (or somehow be stopped from doing something, I guess, it's One Piece, after all). Dunno, I hope he and Robin will take that jerk down together.

That first hit, though, that was great. Oda really knows, how to draw hits that look like they have an impact. They are always so satisfying.
 
Last edited:
Of all the characters to focus on in this arc, I didn't expect it to be Brook. I start to feel, that Usopp will not get his focus, which would be a real shame. Like, real, real shame.

Also, I guess Scopper Gaban (I will never write his name wrong) is done, huh? Had to happen some way, I guess. I mean, works well enough, and does it's job.

Hmm, I sound so negative, I think. I did enjoy the chapter! And I liked the bit at the end, where Imu started to call. Very curious for the next chapter.

Also, I guess we just got a powerful ally, and the kids are not in danger anymore? I wonder, if Gunko will be stuck, or switching back to being controlled, or what?
 
Yeah I'm not clear on what's going on in those last couple pages. So she's Brook's abandoned daughter, maybe angry at Brook for reasons fed to her by the Nobles, or is she angry at the Nobles for telling her Brook was dead (even though she presumably knew from the music career and wanted poster, surely), or I dunno what else.

Was a bit disappointing to see Gaban go down quite so soon, coulda just left him far from the action without removing him entirely.
 
Huh. Now it kinda feels even more like they shouldn’t have sidelined Gaban. …unless the plan is for this arc to be a big loss for the giants and strawhats, to set up the finale.
 
I didn't even consider that! And I actually like that idea.

Hmm, I think we need to remember, that Dorry and Broggy are from another generation. So there is a decent chance that they will not make it, in some form.

Also, the night is always darkest before dawn. So having the giants, the one island the world government was always afraid of, finally fall would be quite fitting. And, honestly,

Also also, there are still Loki, Luffy, Zorro and Sanji. Especially the former HAS to give a bit of a show, considering how he is supposed to be that giant who even the giants fear. And Gaban was also one of the old generation, it simply isn't his fight. The new generation has to win. He can help, and I assume he will, by teaching the Strawhats how to fight against those in contract with Imu. But he can't be a real thing here, or it would be too easy. Using his kid as a weakness is probably the best way, from a storytelling perspective.
 
It was definitely the right way to sideline Gaban, just I felt it happened a bit early! We still have all the God’s Knights around and now we have the inverted evil giants too.

Seems like a lot to get rid of for a smaller arc, unless it’s building to a loss.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top