Here are my reviews for show's first episodes this season. Note most of these I wrote only seeing episode one and since I've seen more and would readjust my takes... but I don't feel like going back to rewrite them.
Sanda
The Premise
CHRISTMAS IS CANCELLED! Some time ago, people stopped celebrating Christmas. It’s just another day now. At a middle school, one child has gone missing and her best friend is convinced there’s only one person who can find her. The last in a long lineage, a being of power and humanity. The last of his kind. The last… Santa Claus.
It Gud?
We really started on the right foot here. We have a wild premise to begin with and as it starts, made no short work of being fun, even before the action starts. The main character tries to rationalize his classmate attempting to knife-murder him as “she’s shy about asking for a date”. Then when the action kicks in, which doesn’t take long, it is gorgeously animated and wonderfully ridiculous, complete with Sanda doing a Santa Claus laugh as part of his transformation sequence (though it’s different than the English Ho Ho Ho but that could be a cultural thing).
The show knows how to have fun with its premise. Without transforming, the main character needs to stop a bomb from exploding a classroom of kids, which concludes in a funny moment from the teacher, then we learn that Santa is fireproof… because he’s gotta be with all the chimneys he descends. It really gets how to utilize the premise and give Sanda powers and qualities based on the Santa mythos without going obvious routes like many other Santa stories have had.
I also loved the wacked out character designs and the animation is really pretty, with the transformation sequence reminding me of some of the great One Piece sequences in recent years. And this is all the track-laying episode, so I’m excited to get into the main story, especially considering this is from the author of BeaSTARs, the show that mixes Zootopia with horny teen soap opera. I have high hopes for this one and boy did it get off on the right foot.
Chitose in the Ramune Bottle
The Premise
A popular high school kid is called in to try to convince a shut in to come to school.
It Gud?
The first episode ends with the main character breaking the main character’s window with a baseball bat, promising to free him of his anxiety and love school life. This might have made for a memorable opening shot, but unfortunately, I watched everything preceding it. That was my mistake. Instead, the episode starts with this weird poetic bit giving it a “mood”, then being the most generic anime ever. Except the main character is less likable than most.
But also, every girl wants to get with him. And he describes himself as a “love-him-or-hate-him-kind-of-guy”, which is really something a “hate-him-kind-of-guy” does. And he introduces every character like they are an entry in a Wikipedia page. And in the most writerly way possible (and a bad writer by the way) the narrator seems to just say “I can only write broad anime archetypes”. And he’s so fucking smug. Why are we following this guy? Shouldn’t we be following the sad kid who needs a wild character to shake up his life?
Chitose in the Ramune Bottle lays so much track with his characters, I was wondering “are we heading into a big genre twist?” The previews didn’t imply this. But weirder things have happened. It would make sense to draw out introducing these characters who seems ridiculously happy with life and are broad characters then reveal they are going to be a death game or maybe all the characters were created by the shut in as a piece of metafiction. Maybe it’s going to turn out to be a murder mystery. Anything. But instead it’s about helping a kid with a taste for awful sounding light novels. Maybe there IS a twist but instead, what it chooses to open with is incredibly irritating.
WanDance
The Premise
A high schooler who struggles with his stutter and wanting to follow the crowd finds a new calling when wanting to truly express himself through dance. But he knows very little so he’s going to join the dance club and learn for himself.
It Gud?
I think this series has a strong starting point; a character who struggles to express himself verbally finds the art of dance. It’s a great way to get ourselves into the art/sport (I assume the series is going to do competitions, but I could be wrong) by connecting it to the character’s need. It tells us the virtue of dance efficiently and it gives it an importance to the character. It also deals with the idea that he has friends who do thinks he doesn’t approve of and struggles to express himself until the climax.
But overall, while I think the roadmap is strong, I didn’t really connect to the characters. The main is a bit too muted, which makes sense and I feel like the female co-lead is kind of a cipher. And not in an engaging way. They weren’t doing a *bad* job but it’s just missing that element that gets me really hyped, like Medalist had.
Also, two other things; 1. The dancing is CG. It’s not awful except for the fact that the FACES are so stiff it looks like the dancers are wearing creepy doll masks. It’s unfortunate because I think the movements are captured well, which is key but the weakness is very clear when you look in their dead eyes. The other issue? The main character is just Mash from Mashle.
Gnosia
The Premise
WEREWOLF! IN! SPACE! (the game, not the mythical beast)
It Gud?
Gnosia is apparently based on a video game I’ve never heard of, a sort of Danganronpa version of Among Us. As a show, the premise is a group of people must vote on which one they think is an evil alien in disguise and which they think isn’t Some of the characters are space aliens, like a non-binary plant lady and though they don’t show up in the first episode, this series has some wild character designs. There’s a dolphin in a suit, a classic grey alien, some kinda pirate man or something.
But as a show… maybe it corrects as it goes on, but mostly it’s the worst of werewolf, people just pointing fingers and going “it’s you!”. There’s some manipulation in the last act, one that isn’t a bad idea but the characters should be trying to use both logic, charisma and manipulation to try to get the results that they want and there isn’t enough of it. There is a lot of laying track but it isn’t hard to figure out.
Overall, it’s a show that’s decidedly unclever. There’s a conceit involving time looping that allows the show to keep doing different rounds. So in theory the main character will get better at the game. That’s not the problem. I feel like it would be more interesting to see characters really getting tricked and manipulated. Having a character that starts as naïve make sense but I wish there was more to the other characters, who are ridiculously cool with the whole process.
Let’s Play
The Premise
A young woman working for her family company dreams of returning to video games after noting increased interest in a game she made for a school project. However, she’s heartbroken when her favourite YouTuber’s negative review gives the game in a bad reputation. Adding to the strangeness, she also discovers said youtuber has also just moved into the apartment next to hers.
It Gud?
Let’s Play is an odd beast. There was a period where CrunchyRoll was bankrolling anime based on WebToons, the financially successful but lesser known format for comics. In particular, it was Korean WebToons. And then that seemed to mostly go away (though I think Solo Leveling is probably the most recent and successful version of this). But it’s one of the rare WebToons created by a North American creator to get an anime. And it really feels like it.
It does bring to mind a lot of the earlier WebComics and regular comics where the Western creator is heavily influenced by Japanese tropes. Many of the hokey gags feel like old anime gags and story turns. Also, the personification for the characters fear of confrontation looks like it repurposed some Venom slash-fiction. I know that seems like I’m dunking on it for playing into older cliches and formula. But there are times when it is genuinely quite funny. Also, the animation is really pretty. Is it pandering in style to gaming and anime nerds? Yes, very much so. It feels like it’s 20 years late to aping Bryan Lee O’Malley (and much of Scott Pilgrim has not aged well to the point they made a Scott Pilgrim anime dealing with that), it does look good.
So I’m kind of on the fence. I suspect I’ll be rolling my eyes quite a bit at some of the choices, but at the same time, I had a good time for large portions of this as well. And I think the set up for romcom makes it clear the romantic co-lead isn’t negging or bullying like some shoujo leads, he’s someone who seems ignorant of the strength of his words and actions and is probably on an arc to learn, which is potentially interesting.
Mechanical Marie
The Premise
A wealthy young man who has inherited the family fortune is the subject of frequent assassination attempts. No longer trusting people, he demands to get a robot maid to protect him. He’s impressed with the maid brought to him but little does he know she isn’t a robot but a super strong wrestler known for her emotionless face. Can she keep up the ruse and protect him from hired killers?
It Gud?
If Let’s Play feels very “of a web comic era”, Mechanical Marie feels very old-fashioned in conceit. Not so much the lie of the lead but the general wacky comedy vibe and “dude and maid” dynamic feels something from 20 years prior. Again, this isn’t a bad thing. The problem I have, and it’s a small one, is in the details. The animation is competent but it makes the weird decision to suddenly switch to a colourful painted piece for a moment. It was a move that was also done in The Fire Hunter, a show that suffered from confounding animation that it tried to present as Science Saru-esque. I’m not sure why Mechanical Marie is making this decision. It’s odd but it’s neither a positive nor negative.
I also feel like they make the mistake of when to reveal that Marie isn’t a robot. You could have slow rolled it so we see how Marie gets into this literal farce or we (my preference) got DEEP into the episode, having Marie do robot stuff and then towards the end after she did a bunch of wild stuff make that reveal. The actual doing of it feels too casual, unfortunately.
I won’t be sticking with this series but it’s not bad. It just lacks sharper gags to make me want to enjoy it. But it’s a fun premise and the wackiness feels old school in a way that… it doesn’t make it better per se but somewhat comfortable, at least. If you are in the mood for an old fashioned maid show that feels less problematic than the one from 20 years prior, Marie isn’t a bad one. I just wish it was better.
Plus-Sized Misadventures in Love
The Premise
A large woman wakes up in a hospital bed with no memory of who she is. Full of joie de vivre and unbridled confidence in herself, she learns that prior to falling off a four story building, she was depressed and plagued by body image issues. But that won’t stop her from finding love, improving her life and also maybe finding out if her fall was a suicide attempt or… a murder attempt.
It Gud?
It’s not common for the world of romance focused on female leads has anything other than slim. There are some who are tall but usually it is a thin, petite woman. Watching the preview, I wanted to try it because… it actually seemed like it could either be making fun of the lead or be a show that features good body size representation. And finally having seen it… it kind of breaks both ways.
Mostly, it is a sweet, positive show. I think it shows that the beauty of the character shows through her confidence and kindness as she supports others and is unabashedly proud of who she is, as well as dealing with the knowledge that she didn’t always think that way (I like how she finds an old idea book where she is putting herself down and fills it with affirmations, which definitely it going to come back when the character regains her memory. But on the other side, yeah, it does make jokes of her being a bit of a glutton and also her size (one scene where she has to sidle sideways out of a bathroom stall). It’s frustrating because I think with the right touch, you COULD make humourous bits about these things but this show doesn’t succeed and it undercuts a lot of what I do like about it. Thankfully these scenes are outnumbered by the better stuff but it makes it a bit harder to recommend.
But, I’m gonna stick with it, at least for a little while. Why? Because they also put a MURDER MYSTERY SUBPLOT IN THIS! Well, attempted murder but still. Early on, a character is like “oh… you survived” and I was like “is this implying attempted murder”. And then it becomes “yep” when the police call and suggest as much. And I love this and the choice that the main character is not nearly as concerned about this as she should be and instead is more focused on finding love and supporting her friends. Plus-Sized could get worse, it could get better but I’m going to give it a shot purely because of this.
Shabake
The Premise
In feudal Japan, a frail young noble learns he is the son of divinity and can see and is protected by yokai. He uses this to solve mysteries in his community.
It Gud?
I had hopes for Shabake. The animation wasn’t impressive and there wasn’t some big amazing premise. A boy who sees ghosts solves mysteries. But there are two things I liked; how almost pleasantly simple the idea is and just having a mystery show. So my hope was it would be a simple, pleasant and clever crime solving show where he needs help from the supernatural to uncover natural clues. And maybe going forward the show about a weak boy helping people will be that.
Part of the problem, though, is I really can’t describe these characters. A lot of time is dedicated to laying out the premise (which really could have been pieced out as needed) of the character and spending time with them. But they are kind of dull. The main character is a good boy and his attendants are… both kinds the same. A bit protective. But nothing pops out as interesting. We barely even get to the mystery and that’s a shame. I think a number of shows have had the challenge of not getting to the whole mystery to prove how clever it is. But the one threat is at best mildly engaging. We hardly get to what the crime is and I feel like not enough clues are given.
It's a disappointingly inert show. We get to see a couple of ways the spirits are useful but I was hoping for, if not great characters, a well-constructed and compelling mystery. But nothing comes together to hook me in. I don’t need twist after twist, I like a chill or cozy mystery, too. But nothing here tells me I want to keep trying. The character begins as sickly but also he’s double privileged and we just spend a lot of time hanging around his mansion. It’s not like the character sucks but it feels frictionless, the personalities who are meeting have no chemistry. It’s a “just there” show, as it is. And I will leave it there.
Tojima Wants to Be Kamen Rider
The Premise
Tojima grew up watching the superhero TV series Kamen Rider and decided that’s what he wanted to be when he grew up. He never gave up on it, even when confronting the reality it made him uncool and that it can never be achieved. Now at 40, Tojima is possible he strongest fighter in the world but this means nothing because his dream is literally unattainable… until the day that criminal thieves started dressing like Kamen Rider’s arch-foes Shocker.
It Gud?
I go into this with only a mild knowledge of Kamen Rider. I know it’s a very long-running franchise with a monster of the week and probably have a multitude of timelines or something. The first one was a cyborg on a motorcycle with a cool scarf. Let me assure you from that perspective, that’s all you really need. Just know that this is a series about someone in love with a franchise and a character and while the show doesn’t spell stuff out, it mostly just focuses on the characters at hand.
In that respect, it works. It’s someone who never grows out of that feeling as a child of wanting to be a fictional character. I work in preschool and when we ask what kids when they want to be when they grow up, they say Spider-Man or Minecraft Steve or, most worrying, a ghost. It’s understandable and the character KNOWS how deeply cringey his dreams and desires are that he can’t let go. And it’s not enough for him to be strong. He’s not delusional. But to him, this only matters if he was able to do something that can’t happen because it is fiction. And then we let the dream come true.
It’s interesting because it’s a power fantasy show but for the lead, he isn’t after the power. He has that. He wants the fantasy. The idea of getting to be someone who protects in a very specific way. I think it helps that Tojima is a likable guy with self-awareness. He knows the problems with his desires. He even gives up all his merch because he’s afraid how pathetic he’d look if someone found his lonely corpse surrounded by remnants of a 54-year-old kids show. He’s sweet and he helps others and he’s funny. The character is what makes it work and I hope it can keep up the charm and humour of the first episode.
Touring After the Apocalypse
The Premise
In post-apocalypse-Japan, two girls tour the country, stopping off at tourist spots as they dodge danger.
It Gud?
Touring is a bit of an odd series because it is both just a chill hang out show in a mostly empty landscape but also balances it with actual action. Though it doesn’t appear in the first episode, the second reveals “THIS SERIES HAS MONSTERS!” in the intro and I did not know we were going there (the first episode’s threat is an out-of-control AI tank) so it’s not exactly Train to the End of the World-level weirdness but it is clearly trying to do a balancing act that mostly works.
I would have been fine with the series if it was just puttering around the end of the world. I really didn’t need the action stuff. But I also don’t dislike it and think it was well done. I think while I am more into the quiet element, which is pleasant and slightly melancholy, I think it balances its sense of fun pretty well. Overall, I don’t actually have a lot to say beyond that. There’s a mystery element but it neither felt weak nor engaging. It’s not quite the “vibe” I was hoping but it’s a post-apocalypse that it is I think I will enjoy visiting on a weekly basis.
A Star Brighter Than The Sun
The Premise
A tall girl grapples with her love for her childhood friend… just as her new friend finds attraction to the same guy.
It Gud?
There’s nothing wrong with A Star Brighter Than the Sun. It reminds me of shows I quite liked, such as Skip and Loafer. Though THAT show does hint at sadness in the romantic male lead, what makes it is no big high concept but simply characters who are charming who you want to spend time with. Skip and Loafer, even if it doesn’t head anywhere, is a series that lives on the charm of the characters. Similarly Blue Box has both sports and romance but mostly it succeeds on wit and mostly well-written stuff (though it kinda got too wheel-spinny by the latter half).
A Star Brighter Than the Sun has characters who are likable but… they just don’t “pop”. It’s not for a lack of trying. I don’t think it’s a boring show but it doesn’t stand out and I really don’t feel a lot of investment in their friendship with some romance on the fringes. It throws in a complication on the last minute. And it isn’t a bad one, a decent one to allow for teen drama. But even by the end of laying down emotional track, I feel like I just want to say “OK, cute”, then move on.
Everything I like about it I like much more in other series I’ve mentioned. The big-hearted heartthrob just feels like a less interesting version of Skip and Loafer’s male lead. The tall girl who is insecure about her height? I’ve read it way back in Lovely Complex and similar shoujo (if anything, still making the male lead even taller doesn’t quite land). A Star Brighter Than the Sun is not a bad choice if you want good old fashioned teen romance but if you are trying to limit what you are watching, you are probably good to skip this one.
Ganglion
The Premise
What happens when a tokusatsu henchman knocks off for the day.
It Gud?
This is a cute short feature. It’s mostly a slice of life about an upper ranking henchman and what he does when he goes home for the day. It’s interesting this came out the same time as Kojima-san but this is much more slice of life with really perfect little ending points on our family man dressed as a bug man.