26. Final Fantasy III
Square Enix, 1990: NES Points: 485 Votes: 13
Forget your VIIIs and XIIIs, my vote goes to III as the most inscrutable Final Fantasy. Not that it’s unclear or overly convoluted, but rather the circumstances of its release in the West means we got it out of context and out of joint. It’s the Billy Pilgrim of FFs, unstuck in time and totally discombobulated.
It also marks the start of a transitional moment for Square. Final Fantasy IV is a candidate for the title of the first truly integrated JRPG, where story, systems, and presentation all work together to manifest a new storytelling mode. It was also the team’s first game on the SNES, with all the expansive freedom 16 bits allowed. III is the last game in the old tradition, and you can really feel the developers chafing at the constraints.
Elements like its linear job system, map and encounter design, and graphical style all have one foot in the future, anticipating what’s to come, while the other is still planted in the past, beholden to the era’s customs. Likewise, there are a number of innovations that only want the freedom of the SNES to come to full fruition, like the way the world map gradually opens up or the game’s approach to secrets and exploration.
All this makes for an odd little goblin of a Final Fantasy. Though it is quite a charming one. The game is bursting with personality and memorable moments. It opens with candy-colored onion babies in a truly excellent and iconic first dungeon and ends in a brutal five-boss gauntlet with desperate stakes (the player’s last save is so, so far away). In between we have a succession of airships, a dapper skeleton, a mansion made of gold, mouse-sized dungeons, the four real Warriors of Light, a stunning moment of recontextualization when you first get off the continent, and the best overworld music of the whole series—never to be topped by remix or re-instrumentation.
This is all well and good, but it does cement Final Fantasy III in its moment. Then, experiencing it for the first time sixteen years later, in compromised form, gave it an uncanny quality that’s forever shaded its reputation. It’s one thing to understand the context III manifested in; it’s another to have played it in 1990 without foreknowledge of everything that would come after.
Still, III is a peach and herald of a whole genre to follow. And the Pixel Remaster does a lot to bring forward its charms while minimizing its barriers. The less said about the DS version, the better (though I do love how the characters’ fashion choices manifest in all the job costumes). I will now turn it over to Jbear to gush about the game and explain to us the fine nuances of Job Levels.