• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

I had a good feeling! Celebrating 40 Years and 108 JRPGs of Destiny

Anyway
DQ2 HD-2D Remake has a second ending which is actually really cool. I also like how it sells that the four young heroes together are more than a match for any hero of legend through gameplay. After playing through DQ1 HD-2D Remake with the hero's super-jack-of-all-trades build, it's hard not to notice what each of the protagonists in 2R is missing compared to him. Midenhall has big issues with multiple targets, Cannock-M can't outdamage a sheet of paper, Moonbrooke could be brought low by a sheet of paper, and Cannock-F still hasn't figured out how the Follow Orders tactic works. But as you progress, you realize 'wait, Cannock-M doesn't need to hit hard, Midenhall can do that', 'wait, Midenhall doesn't need to AoE, Moonbrooke can do that', 'wait, Moonbrooke doesn't need to take hits, Cannock-M can do that', and 'wait, Cannock-F is here too'. And together, they can thrash foes that the second coming of Erdrick couldn't have dreamed of.
 
Tied for 90th place are two maximalist JRPGs, each taking a different approach to their embiggoning.

BgXuzBO.jpeg


90. Dragon Quest XI
Square Enix, 2017: PS4/PC. Points: 183 Votes: 4​

DQ XI might just be the consummate Dragon Quest. It takes every little part of the Draquestian character—the charming cast, the perfectly balanced gameplay mechanics, the fairy-tale inspired scenario writing, the picking up of a jar just to smash it at the owner’s feet, among many others—and explodes them into a huge, inhabitable adventure that stretches across three acts, each the size of a normal JRPG in themselves. Of course, XI wasn’t the first Dragon Quest to realize its world in a 1:1 scale 3D space, but DQVIII’s strict translation of a typical 2D overworld into a polygonal context leaves it with vast stretches of empty ground and a loneliness that no amount of piped-in horse clomping can alleviate. XI benefits from twenty years of computing power in order to create landscapes crammed packed with objects, vistas, and hordes of wandering monsters that makes its spaces feel lived-in and purposeful. It also wisely divides its world into concrete regions with their own cultural, environmental, and biological characteristics. This gives overworld traversal a novelty and freshness that VIII often lacked with its samey rolling plains and tiny habitations. This also primes for a moment of wonder. For when you take to the skies for the first time and see how all the separate regions are actually connected there’s a fantastic sense of the world unfolding, of having gained special knowledge, that matches the aspects of freedom and ascension that the airship moment typically entails.

5hraNpj.jpeg

The world map design is just one example of the many ways Dragon Quest XI actualizes the DQ experience. The game is almost a perfect example of how tradition and innovation can meld into a charming, enthralling experience that pushes forward while staying true to heart.

~


n9FEMCu.png


90. Trails in the Sky FC
Nihon Falcom, 2004: PC. Points: 183 Votes: 5​

Trails in the Sky: First Chapter is also a huge game. But where XI expanded and increased, Trails digs-in and specifies. It bucks JRPG tradition to avoid a world-hopping adventure in favor of focusing on one country on one continent and on the daily travels of street-level beat cops. By sharpening its focus it’s able to fill its setting with details, not just in its environmental design or the way that NPCs have thousands of lines of dialogue (updating after nearly every plot event), but also in the nuts and bolts of politics, social structures, economic systems, diegetic rationales for magical artifacts, the production chains for said artifacts, local history, international cultural relations, unique “it’s empty” messages for each and every looted treasure chest, among many other granularities that JRPGs usually gloss over in their rendering of a setting down to a manageable stand-in.

ljm8Pue.png

By focusing on a small, local conflict, Sky FC casually establishes its characters and stakes in a way that allows for the climax to shock and destabilize the player. With a reveal of mythic significance, the conflict is set not just for the expansive Trails in the Sky Second Chapter, but also for an additional thirteen games that explore other countries and conflicts which are all tied up in a grandmaster chess game of divine intervention and human potential. It’s a massively ambitious project, and by starting off with little Estelle and her cat-rescuing adventures it has something of the feel of a classic Fantasy. Like the hobbits leaving The Shire, which at the time seems like a big adventure but in actuality is only the first step into something even more fantastic and grand.
 
I only just recently finished Dragon Quest XI S, and I put it in the upper half of Dragon Quest games. That said... I think it really outstays its welcome. I get the narrative reasons why it plays out as it does, but the asset reuse feels pretty egregious at the end. It's still very much worthy of being on this list, though, so don't pay me and my curmudgeonly self any mind.

Speaking of curmudgeonly, though, I ruined my own playthrough of Trails FC by obsessively going for 100%, which meant following a guide to a T. While it made sure I didn't miss any of the copious character-building dialogue, it also made for a not-amazing playthrough for a reward that absolutely was not worth it. I think that's why I haven't moved on to SC by now. Or maybe even why I haven't played through any Trails since. Don't do what I did!
 
Hoo boy we're getting ties too? Poor Loki gonna have to write a thousand posts lmao

DQXI was my #17. Oddly, I didn't have FC on the list, but I did have SC... Both games are fantastic, though, and yeah, for nearly opposite reasons. DQXI is wild for its length - they packed a lot in there. And yeah don't do what Sarge did with FC, SC, or any of the games - just play them and enjoy them, see what you feel like seeing and enjoying yourself.
 
And yeah don't do what Sarge did with FC, SC, or any of the games - just play them and enjoy them, see what you feel like seeing and enjoying yourself.
If you have a time machine, go back and tell past me not to do it. And give me a few Super Bowl winners. And to buy that copy of Little Samson off of eBay for $50. :ROFLMAO:
 
Man, a couple of real bangers today. I'm gonna have to effort-post.

Before I head off to the writing mine, though: friends don't let friends get max bracer rank. It's guide-bait horseshit. I play Trails games by doing the world tour and talking to every single NPC after every single event, and I still missed bracer points. Let sleeping Zodiac Spears lie.
 
I suspect I was probably the top vote for DQ11, having it at #3 on my list. What a fucking banger of a fucking video game. Before I start, though, a spoiler warning: if you think you might want to play DQ11 for yourself, and you're the sort of person who cares about spoilers, maybe don't read this, and maybe don't read what anyone else says about it either! I'm going to try to talk around specific spoilers and much as I can and use spoiler code readily, but even still, discussion about DQ11 inevitably touches on some pretty major narrative spoilers that inform the game's structure, so reader beware!

Anyway, DQ11. Man. I was completely unprepared for how much I fell in love with this game. I think it is arguably the best RPG ever made. Just a giant sweeping epic with a colourful world and fun systems and loving homage to the history of the genre. I have a long, complicated history with Dragon Quest, and I'm sure this series will come up for discussion again later in the thread, so I'll just say that it's a beloved foundational work not just for the subject of this thread, but for me personally, and I didn't think any new DQ game could unseat my favourite prior ones, let alone do so as soundly as it did. I don't even know where to start.

Let's start with mechanics! At a very basic level, DQ11 has a fun combat engine, and this is important because you spend countless hours in it. It remains fun and varied the whole way through, as your characters grow and develop and come and go, and it makes it very hard to settle into a routine. Combat feels really strategic and complex as you manage pep levels and status ailments and HP/MP totals both in the front line and the back line as you rotate different characters in and out of your active party. Also, as you're shuffling your lines, different combo abilities become available or unavailable, with satisfyingly varied impacts and sometimes delightful animations (shout out to my favourite, where one of your party members throws another and then has Kaclang cast on him to turn him into a living metal projectile).

A big part of what informs that combat is the license board, and here too there's a lot of fun to be had, planning and speccing your characters to play sometimes very different combat roles depending upon how you'd like to build them. It's even tactilely satisfying and colourful to play with, and has some fun obscured panels that you need to reveal, and even some entirely hidden tiles that don't show up on the board at all until you reach them (I was shocked to make this discovery literally hundreds of hours into the game). My favourite thing about the board, though, might be how it sometimes updates with the narrative as certain characters experience important personal developments (special shout out here to how the Luminary part of the MC's tree is pruned away after the Act 1 climax).

The final mechanical delight I want to call is the Draconian Quest options menu that allows sickos like me tailor the experience to our terrible tastes. From simpler (and, IMO, essential) modifiers like harder enemies and reduced XP flags that make combat much more satisfying, to more esoteric things like what amounts to a "graveyard duck" mode that sees villagers giving you false tips, you can really tweak the game to give you the flavour of challenge that you're looking for.

Another thing that really strikes me about DQ11 is just how fun it all is. It really just feels like a fun-forward experience, from the silly costumes and jokes and almost distressingly authentic slot machines to the DQ1 stair sound effect for area transitions and just literal Skeletor. Did I mention that Skeletor is here? Skeletor is here.

And the final thing that I'd like to touch on is the narrative, and the game's overall structure. I'm not sure I've been this emotionally invested in a JRPG a narrative since [recacted, but it's a short list]. Some of this game's major plot beats left me bawling. I've always been a fan of games that have party members come and go, and this has lots of that as you navigate the game's 3 major acts, each of which I'd like to touch on: Act 1 (introduction), Act 2 (getting the band back together), and Act 3 (post-game). Act 1 feels like your traditional DQ adventure narrative, as you travel from kingdom to kingdom, slowly collecting your party members and engaging with traditional DQ vignettes in each location, terminating with the wild unexpected climax when a betrayal leads to the game pulling a FF6, which then leads to a much darker Act 2. I know that everyone was dubious when the new DQ was pitched as a darker story, but honestly, if it's anything like what they did here, then I'm here for it. It's remarkable how different everything feels at the start of Act 2, as you are fighting a desperate holding action at The Last Bastion, the last human holdout in the kingdom and my favourite location in the game, battling back from the edge of ruin with the aid of your former foe Hendrick as you begin the long slow process of putting the band back together and figuring out how the world can recover. Just fucking peak. And I love the development of Hendrick as a character from there, and your relationship with him. It's just all so good.

And then you get to the end of Act 2, and I have to disagree with a lot of folks when I say that Act 3 is not required reading. I love it, and I'm glad I played through it, but I often see people say that you need to play it, and I just can't agree. Dragon Quest 11 is a long fucking video game. The end of Act 2 has one big dangling downer note, but is otherwise a complete and narratively satisfying ending, with credits, and a great place to tap out if you feel like you've had enough. If you're a true sicko like me, though:

it's super fun to go on a time-travelling continuity reset adventure to save your friend. I am sympathetic to folks who feel like this throws away everyone's character development throughout Act 2, and to criticisms that it's too repetitive with what came before, but that bothers me less when I view Act 2 as the ending and Act 3 as the fun spin-off post-game. It just feels like such a powerful act to throw away half of what you've done over the past several hundred hours, both for you mechanically and your characters emotionally, and seeing the exact ways that the choice manifests mechanically and narratively is very cool and fun. It just raises so many questions, and invariably my reaction to "oh shit, how are they going to handle *this* thing?" is delight and surprise.

Anyway, TLDR, Dragon Quest 11: it's a GOAT. You should play it!
 
Dragon Quest XI is a very good Dragon Quest game. I think Act 3 is best understood as adding story context to a very substantial mechanically-driven post game, in view of which it's more extensive than Chapter 6 in Dragon Quest IV DS.

They say Dragon Quest is a series of games that contain their own sequels; XI contains not only its own sequel, but also its own fix-fic spinoff.

I feel like the writing in Dragon Quest games end up setting the tone for JRPGs that follow them for years after their release. If a character dynamic appears in the party in Dragon Quest, you're going to see other games riffing on it for years to come. What DQXI brings to the table is that every member of the party is both bound to and favorably disposed to the hero because of his magical destiny. Sure they like the kid, but they were loyal to him before they even knew him. As a writer, Yuji Horii knows how to use understatement, so in DQXI proper this ends up just setting you up with the gratifying and even heartwarming sense of having a close-knit posse who can be relied upon absolutely. Among less skillful imitators, however, I think this kicked off or at least prolonged a trend of games with a really obsequious treatment of the player, fawning over the avatar and having supporting cast members talk about how special they are.

Meanwhile, Trails in the Sky has been in my backlog for so long that a total remake has come out in the intervening period. Someday....
 
Someday, Square-Enix will update their PC or PS5 ver of DQ11 to contain the Switch upgrades. Until then I wait with patience.
Was this not already done years ago? The DQ 11 S version avaiable on PS5 - which I think is the PS4 edition - seems identical to the Switch version, which is to say, it's the "S" version of the game.

For my part, I thought DQ11 was too long. But I've come to understand there's a kind of padding (for lack of a better word) that seems to be instrinic to DQ games and, as much as I enjoy them, it will always be my bone to pick with the series. They are not always the best games for the inpatient person. I fell off somewhere in Act 2 when I just could not force myself to play it anymore but I quite enjoyed everything before that point, especially stuff with Veronica or Sylvando, athough the entire cast was great.

I played about three hours of original - is the Steam version the original? - Trails in the Sky and determined it was the kind of game I would likely loved when it was new but I came to it very late and just couldn't get into it. Although maybe I should try that remake.
 
I thought DQ XI was a great game. It goes on way too long, as all Dragon Quests must. Still a wonderful game with some of my favorite characters in the series.

I fervently hope for a new mainline game with Toriyama caliber silly characters and and a soundtrack by a person who is not an evil asshole.
 
I absolutely must give Trails in the Sky FC a full-bodied chance in my life, Estelle Bright is such a good character that deserves the time.

Dragon Quest 11 is an amazing game to experience. Like all good RPGs it eventually lets you bend the rules to make absolute confetti out of the enemies, and the story is full of twists and turns and plots that make the 100 hour run time fly by.
 
I really need to play DQ XI, huh?

Trails in the Sky FC was not on my list (I wonder, if I forgot it or if it got kicked of), but I liked it a whole lot. The characters and the dialogue make this game. The battle system is fun, too, but it's just living inside that world that made it special. Estelle is also such a fun character to have as your main. I really need to replay it, and then continue on to SC. First time I beat FC, I was just burned out, and only started SC. Now it's been so long, that I need to replay FC, or I will not get the experience I could. Especially here, being a direct sequel, have to do it that way. Some day.
 
I am an outlier that fell off of DQXI and don't have any plans to revisit it. It didn't hook me as it seemed to for many of you, but that's okay. I can see its qualities, but I guess it wasn't what I wanted.

I quite enjoyed the Trails in the Sky First Chapter remake, but that's not the game being featured so I will refrain from further commentary.
 
Alright, needed to take a breather. So, Trails in the Sky. I actually got into this series later than a lot of folks (although apparently not later than the average around here), I think around the time the 3rd was coming out. I had a friend who insisted that there was this good throwback RPG series that I should check out, and there was! I don't have quite as much text to barf out about TitS as I did about DQ11, but it's still a game that's near and dear to my heart and that placed high on my list. Loki already touch on a lot of points that I would, but to my mind the two things that make TitS feel special are the pacing and the world-building, so I'll touch on each of those in turn.

For much of its playtime, Trails in the Sky's pace is, in a word, languid. For me, it's like slipping into a warm JRPG bath. This might sound like a damning condemnation, but this is a game where I have, on multiple occasions, fallen asleep while playing it. And enjoyed that! I had some really pleasant afternoon naps! It's just cozy and sedate and a world that I enjoy spending a lazy summer day in...

...which is why it hits all that much harder when you hit an end-of-Act climax and it slams the throttle to 11 and doesn't stop. This shit gets wild. The music kicks in, bad shit is going down (sometimes of the world-shaping geopolitical variety, sometimes peril of a more personal nature), and everything just starts popping off and doesn't let up until you hit the Act break.

...and then you're back to chatting everybody up and finding missing cats again.

I dunno, I just find it utterly unique in this way, and I love it for it. Both speeds are very important to my enjoyment of the experience as a whole.

The other thing that sets TitS apart is its world-building, and here at least I wouldn't say its unique, but it is in good company, reminding me more than anything of the Suikoden series (I hate to bring up games in these lists before they're featured, but I think it's important to be explicit to make my point here). This is a world that feels lived-in. You always get the sense that you're just seeing a small slice of a larger world that other people inhabit, hearing stories of interesting peoples and places (sometimes in the newspaper!) and participating in international events that influence and in turn are influenced by the actions of other nations, and then later games zoom in on those nations and lets you experience some of those same events from another viewpoint and paint in the vague outlines you've had in your head to that point.

So, that's what makes it feel special to me and sets it apart from the other games in this list, but as far as what I just like about it, well, Estelle always looms large. It's rare that the main character of a game with a large cast is also the fan favourite, but everyone loves Estelle, and with good cause. She's a larger-than-life sassy hothead with a big stick and an attitude to match, naive in the ways of the world around her but eager to learn and help people and make a name for herself. She's the heart of this game (and arguably the mascot for the larger series), and I think the biggest reason for the series' enduring popularity.

In summary:
Estelle_Simpsons.png
 
If I were voting for best JRPG characters rather than straight up games, Estelle would be in the discussion for top five at least. She's the best
 
I am an outlier that fell off of DQXI and don't have any plans to revisit it. It didn't hook me as it seemed to for many of you, but that's okay. I can see its qualities, but I guess it wasn't what I wanted.
I am also another one who didn't love it very much. I have 5 other DQs on my list ahead of 11. I got to Act 3 in the game too, so I enjoyed it enough to get that far I guess.
 
I kept my list to top 25. I think DQXI would have made my list if I went beyond top 25.

DQXI is about as classic a JRPG as it gets with modern balance tweaks. DQXI is real good.

Like a lot of my favorite JRPGs the cast of DQXI is great. I like everyone that can be in the party.

I think the only gripe I have against it, is that its long. But if you enjoy something does it matter if its long?
 
Last edited:
I am also another one who didn't love it very much. I have 5 other DQs on my list ahead of 11. I got to Act 3 in the game too, so I enjoyed it enough to get that far I guess.
I did finish it, so I definitely thought it was good even if I was ready to be done by the end. It didn't end up making my top 50, but was definitely in my top 100. I've got four Dragon Quest games on my list, though. :)
 
Trails in the Sky FC was on my list at #36. While I eventually fell off the Trails series, I did think the first game was fantastic, to the point that I bought and played four more games hoping they would recapture the magic.

Also, I'll jump on the "praising Estelle" train and highlight how well her gameplay role meshes with her character. She's a jack of all trades by design, with middling stats in all areas and the unique perk of having none of her quartz slots restricted to one color. So, no matter what kind of tactics a fight calls for, she'll be able to contribute, but will always be overshadowed by more specialized party members. However, her Morale craft is one of the best abilities in the game, giving an attack buff in a large AOE centered on her. So, if she's able to take a turn to psych herself up, she can punch above her weight class, and when her friends rally around her, they also get a lot stronger. She's the emotional center of the party, in and out of battle.
 
I think there's an important distinction to be made between the original XI and the re-release, which apparently adds a bunch of mandatory interstitial substories between Act 1 and Act 2, right? Which can make a long game feel even longer.
 
I quite enjoyed those bits (especially Sylvando's), but I've never played the game without them.
 
one day i should sit down and actually play DQXI

last time i tried i finished the Haiku Zone and got two girl party members and started going into a swamp area, i think? and then i adhd'd and suddenly it's been

*checks steam*

five years
 
The intermissions are fun in a vacuum, but they really undermine the shock of going right from the end of act 1 to the very dark Cobblestone scenario in act 2.
 
I had Trails in the Sky pretty high on my list. Aside from the game itself, I think the name and imagery are one of the best encapsulations of the sense of wonder and adventure that jrpgs can do so well.

bofgaTG.jpeg


I mean, look at that. Ironically the game plays from a perspective that means you never see the sky (outside of cutscenes maybe? It’s a long time since I played this one).

I’ve played a lot of Trails games now, but I think the first remains the best. It’s relatively grounded, telling a story about a coup d’état within a single country, at least until the very end when the absurd secret society that’s really responsible for things comes into view. Lokii describes it as maximalist, which it is, but not like how the series would get later. I played the ninth game recently, Trails of Cold Steel IV, and it’s just absurdly big, full of stuff, drowning in lore (it’s also remarkably streamlined, allowing you to engage with its overflowing content with minimal barriers, which was nice, and I dunno if I’ve just gotten used to it or if something has changed but I finally feel like Ouroborous is adding something to the series rather than being its second worst part (after the gross sex stuff)). That has its appeal, but I like how FC is detailed but within limits.
 
DQ XI is very impressive but count me amongst the Act III unfinishers. I puttered around for a bit, ran into a boss who steamrolled me, got distracted by something else and haven’t successfully gotten sucked back in.

Maybe I’ll pick it up on switch some day…
 
Back
Top