• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

Eating Like An Earl - Talking Time's Top Sandwiches

When I saw the pic for the first #39 I thought it was one I’d voted for, but apparently it’s legally distinct as mine wasn’t from Canada. Seems… pretty dang close though. But I guess the other one could still show up.
I think I voted for your thing, too.
 
Our next entry features a return of two of the ingredients from entry #41. But now they have a different co-star.

#38
hYlBAJ6.jpg

bacon cheeseburger

59 points, 2 votes
Staunchest Sandwich Supporter: Johnny Unusual (#6)

Tour Locations:
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Lansing, Michigan​

This sandwich is another one which was difficult to categorize. What I think it boils down to is this - when does an extra ingredient (or ingredients) actually make one sandwich into an entirely different one? Or when does a topping become more than just a topping? I think that's hard to judge objectively but what I decided (in this case) was that if a combination of ingredients was given a different name or is given a combination name (as opposed to being some other sandwich with the other ingredients) then it is a different sandwich. The fact that more than one person voted for this specific sandwich (more or less) also factored into my decision.

All that aside I'm sure many of you have had this tasty trio of different types of rich flavors that work together so well that the sandwich is available at many different places.

Speaking of different places, @Daikaiju voted for a very specific version of this sandwich - the Roy Rogers Bacon Cheddar Burger:
9cSrL88.jpg

(Roy Rogers is a fast food restaurant chain that started in 1968. The parent company approached actor Roy Rogers about using his name in return for a licensing fee and also paid Roy to make personal appearances at the restaurants. But there is so much more to that story - you can read about it here.)

@Johnny Unusual
 
Hamburgers are actually among my least favourite sandwiches, as I think that beef is one of the least interesting things that you can put on a bun, but as far as beef burgers go, the classic bacon cheeseburger is certainly one of my favourites, and still something I look forward to having fresh off the grill at my parents'.
 
I had to check my list, apparently I once again almost voted for this one but not quite. My lone cheeseburger vote had an appendix of “(ideally with good local meat, and maybe bacon or something)” but I didn’t specify it *had* to have bacon so fair enough, but suffice to say I am down for a good bacon burger.
 
I love burgers but the fact is the meat, unless it is interestingly spiced, is the least interesting aspect and requires other ingredients to make it shine. Enter bacon and cheese.

ak4v1n.jpg

Sure, there are other options to make a burger great. An onion jam. A nice aioli. But the two different savoury flavours enhance the flavour of the beef tremendously.
​
Also, in terms of spices, I think in terms of fast food burgers, A & W has the best seasonings for their burgers. Curious if anyone else has different opinions.
 
#37
QRjYmxR.jpg

category tuna

60 points, 3 votes
Staunchest Sandwich Supporters: Lokii, RT-55J (#15)

Tour Locations:
Baltimore, Maryland
Fulton, Maryland
San Diego, California​

Tuna is a paradoxical food. Some varieties and cuts of it are rare, prized delicacies but it's also available as a common, mass-produced, pre-cooked, packaged consumer product. It's that second category that is at the heart of this entry. Packaged tuna is used as the main non-bread ingredient in many different varieties of tuna sandwich. This happens so often it's said that in the US over half of all canned tuna is used for sandwiches.

While the voters enjoy tuna sandwiches they couldn't agree on any one specific variety.

@Lokii likes tuna and toast:
bwP6csY.jpg


@RT-55J likes a tuna melt:
Q0KyqPK.jpg


While @JBear has a nostalgic fondness for a simple tuna sandwich:
JBear said:
My mother made me a sandwich consisting of only canned tuna and Miracle Whip for my school lunch for over a decade, and it's still a comfort food for me, although one I rarely have.

(Note: No one specifically mentioned that they were voting for tuna salad sandwiches and I neglected to ask for clarification so it is not explicitly included in this category or the previous salad sandwiches category.)
 
I love a good tuna sandwich, even if I forgot to vote for it. I've found that mixing in some dill and Old Bay really takes it to the next level.
 
I like a good tuna but I'm picky. No onion. No celery (I like celery but there's something about the texture in this context that's a no go for me). And some element at least needs to feel warm or hot (maybe toasted bread).

I got to eat tuna more often. Good fish.
 
It’s a great fish but I never thought I liked it at all until I discovered fresh sashimi-grade tuna. Which you don’t really put in sandwiches.
 
Well, it's a wrap folks. But I don't mean that the presentation thread is over - that's the next entry.

#36 (tie)
1mhEHdS.jpg

gcyyot7.jpg

category wrap

62 points, 3 votes
Staunchest Sandwich Supporter: WildcatJF (#6)

Tour Locations:
Terre Haute, Indiana
Quad Cities – Illinois / Iowa
Tijuana, Mexico​

Wraps are a broad category of sandwiches - they are all made by rolling a flatbread of some type around a filling of some kind. When using pre-made flatbreads they can be put together quite quickly so they're popular as a fast food item and as a quick meal (or snack).

@WildcatJF likes poultry in his wraps - either chicken or turkey. @Johnny Unusual prefers turkey.

But @Issun is more exacting - he likes a chicken Caesar wrap. (Which I had cut from my long list.)

S2cDGNz.jpg
 
While wraps tend to be made with less expensive and more readily available ingredients our next entry tends to be made with a more premium ingredient. (But there are exceptions to that.)

#36 (tie)
KULDO4L.jpg

lobster roll

62 points, 3 votes
Staunchest Sandwich Supporter: Kirin (#3)

Tour Location: Milford, Connecticut​

The lobster roll is a sandwich consisting of lobster meat on a grilled bread that is like a hot dog bun. They are served either hot or cold and mixed with either drawn butter or mayonnaise, depending on the version. Sometimes diced celery or scallions are added.

@Lokii prefers the hot Connecticut lobster roll. @Kirin and @JBear didn't really specify their preference.

Well, JBear does have some requirements for the lobster rolls he eats:
JBear said:
Lobster rolls can vary widely in quality, and this is not a vote for any of "the bad ones". Anything on a basic-ass hot dog bun can fuck all the way off, for starters. But a good lobster roll is worth the price.
 
I vastly prefer hot over Maine style. New England is already frigid and soggy. Why would you want to eat a cold lobster??
 
The thing about caesar wraps (and most wraps in general) is that you want it fresh made. If you buy it out of your supermarket grab n go the lettuce is going to be very sad and wilted and that's going to ruin the whole experience. So you either have to risk tearing the wrap apart by pulling the lettuce out or just putting up with it, neither of which is ideal.
 
the thing i like about wraps is that you can include a sauce or dressing and have a better chance of it being mostly contained, where a sandwich would be a mess. I really like a honey baked ham wrap. I think it has a honey mustard inside that is really yummy, but sticky, so its nice to try to avoid getting it on you.
 
I vastly prefer hot over Maine style. New England is already frigid and soggy. Why would you want to eat a cold lobster??
I can't be there with you man. Hot lobster can be good but, like, in a bisque or a fancy Mac and cheese. If you are just eating a whole lobster, cold is the way to go. Rip it apart like a barbarian. Tail is so good.

Lobster rolls also need to be cold. Sorry no, the lobster medley needs to be cold. Get a nice thicc sturdy bun and toasted or otherwise made hot. Its a nice sensation flavor combo of warm, crusty bread and cool lobster. But who am I to talk because NO CELERY IN LObSTER FOR ME, PLEASE.

I will not dignify "Maine style" with a response.
 
I've been eating lobster rolls my whole life and have never heard of either. Ya'll don't own the idea of putting lobster on a bun, America.

ETA: Man, I've never made so many typos in my life. The first version of this post was so badly written that I'm worried I had a stroke. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
Lobster has been one of my favorite foods since I was a kid but if you don’t live in, like, Maine, it can be a bit hard to come by outside of exorbitantly priced restaurant options. So I will jump at pretty much any chance at a lobster roll, cold or hot. But my fave way is probably cool lobster with hot butter on a nice fluffy toasted roll. God, I want one right now.

Meanwhile I’m not a chicken fan but I do sometimes get other things wrapped. nat’s honey baked ham one sounds good to me.
 
I had one of those exorbitantly priced restaurant lobster rolls a couple years ago and boy howdy that was a disappointment.

For the record's sake, I blame the restaurant, not the food item itself. I love a good bit of lobster or crab, so in theory it should have been a slam dunk. Alas... 😔
 
Apparently when you add an egg to the sandwich it's called a buck rabbit or a golden buck.
So Sandwiches of History made one of these today:

(It seems rather tedious to make. Also, the video seems to provide a good method for poaching eggs.)
 
I'm sure this next entry will generate far less controversy than the previous one.

#35
4DIVw0R.jpg

Chicago dog

65 points, 2 votes
Staunchest Sandwich Supporter: Daikaiju (#2)

Tour Location: Hmm, now what city should I use for this one?​

A Chicago dog is a style of hot dog that originated in Chicago, Illinois. The sandwich includes a somewhat long and exacting list of ingredients.
  • steamed poppy seed hot dog bun (a high-gluten variety is used to handle the steam)
  • all-beef kosher-style* frankfurter (usually with a natural casing)
  • dill pickle spear
  • tomato wedges or slices
  • yellow mustard
  • chopped white onion
  • celery salt
  • sweet pickle relish (with blue food coloring to make it a nice, bright green color)
  • pickled sport peppers (a small chilli pepper which is similar to a serrano pepper)
  • and no ketchup! (or else!)
@Daikaiju @Lokii

*The term "kosher style" was invented by Nathan Handwerker, co-founder of Nathan's Famous Hot Dog. Their all-beef hot dogs could not be called kosher since they didn't use kosher meat and their facilities weren't inspected by any rabbis. Nathan used the term kosher style since the hot dogs did not contain pork or horse meat which are considered treif/not kosher.
 
I have never really been to Chicago, but I did switch flights there once, and I took that opportunity to have one of these at the airport and it did not disappoint. Highly recommended!
 
Back
Top