• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

Any Way You Slice It: Talking Time's Top 50 Pizza Toppings

#42
Potatoes
45 Points, 2 Lists, Highest Vote: #2 (Olli)
tmKf8oom.jpg


​
is another one I've never tried, though it is apparently a common topping in Italy (Pizza con patate). Usually thinly sliced and browned in olive oil, and seasoned with herbs. Obviously there are other ways you can use potato on pizza. There is a loaded baked potato pizza recipe online though that sounds like a lot (I would try it).

Love me a good poutine pizza.

I think I've had sliced on there before, but the memory is much less distinct.

#39
Philly Steak
54 Point, 2 Lists, Highest Vote: #6 (Daikaiju)
bNqHOx8m.jpg

​
Unsurprising that the Philly guy voted for the steak. But what is a cheesesteak anyways? Be very careful how you answer if someone from Philadelphia and surrounds is nearby because you could be cruisin' for a bruisin'. So what is an authentic cheeseteak? Even Philadelphians can't 100% agree but there is definitely a skillet cooked, thin shaved beef involved. The cheese is generally provolone or Cheez Whiz, though American cheese is also possible as an authentic cheese choice. Grilled onions of course. NO peppers. You argue bell peppers on a cheesesteak to a Philadelphian and you will face the wrath of God. Then a hoagie roll, but the true bread is a roll from Amoroso's, which slightly salts its rolls.

All this to say that philly steak as a pizza topping is going to be shaved steak and it's generally going to be served on a cheesesteak pizza. Which will almost always have peppers on it almost everywhere.

Philly cheese steak pizza is one of my favorite go-tos at Dominos, though I have to get it without the peppers or onions. And they go the Provolone route.
 
Closest I've had to potatoes on a pizza is Pizzaria Uno's Pizza Skins appetizer. A personal sized pan pizza shell filled with mashed potatoes and then topped with cheddar and bacon, with some sour cream on the side.
 
I counted poutine as a separate entry.
I had to stop and think if I've had potatoes on pizza any other way, but then realized I forgot the really obvious one: The spicy pierogi pizza at Boston Pizza!

Love to get those whenever I go. Problem is, that's so rarely...

But yeah, those use sliced potatoes, and they're great!
 
I don’t think I voted for any peppers but if I was going to put peppers on my pizza, roasted red would definitely be the pick.

I’m not a big fan of greens and didn’t vote for them either, but I have had arugula on pizza a few times and it was pretty decent.

Not sure I’ve ever had Philly steak on pizza, but if it’s shaved thin enough to not be chewy it seems like something I wouldn’t object to.
 
Were the two guys and a girl the children of Italian immigrants living in the North End? If not, then they probably lied, yeah.
The two guys and the girl were not the children of the owner(s) - they were college students who worked there.

But the pizza place was owned by a black man so I guess that still does apply.
 
Last edited:
The name of that chain will never stop being weird to me, because when I was living in Boston I really struggled to find good pizza.
For some reason Canadian restaurant chain names like to use American location names.

St. Louis Bar and Grill
New York Fries
Montana's Steakhouse
Boston Pizza

At least with East Side Mario's, every city probably has an East Side.
 
#36
(Hot) Honey
62 Points, 3 Lists, Highest Vote: #10 (JBear)
42oGsflm.jpg

​
Honey is made by bees. Everyone knows that, of course, and that it is made by the bee drinking nectar and then regurgitating it in the storage of a comb where it thickens into the delicious sweet treat we know and love. However, two of the three people who voted for it specified hot honey, and that is the variation I have encountered on pizza myself. As well as many other places. Honey with chilis and a bit of vinegar added is all the rage right now, and pizza is not safe from the fad. Thankfully, this fad is fairly tasty and goes especially well on chicken or any sort of barbecue pizza.
 
In the town where we used to live in New Jersey, our favorite pizza place had a great pie with spicy soppressata and hot honey.

ETA: Also, JBear is absolutely right in the post below this one.
 
I am a firm believer that most pizzas are improved by a bit of sweetness spiciness, as represented by somewhere between 1/3 and 1/2 1/5 of my list, and corn is a solid choice for that figs are an amazing choice for that hot honey is a great choice for that.
 
Somehow, I don't think I've had any hot honey stuff.

I should give it a spin.
 
Oh I’d forgotten, but it looks like I did put hot honey in the middle of my list. As is general consensus, I wrote “kinda faddish, but pretty good”. There’s some minor upscale fast food chain, I forget which, that has a prosciutto and hot honey individual pie that’s pretty tasty, if a bit sticky on the fingers.
 
#35
Oregano
63 Points, 3 Lists, Highest Vote: #5 (Torzelbaum)
rlzw1fbm.jpg

​
Oregano is a flowering plant in the mint family, of all things. Its flavor is very different, though, as it is perhaps one of the two quintessential herbs used in Italian cooking. It can be used fresh, but is more often dried and ground. You will find it in sauces, and in the previously mentioned Italian Seasoning mix. It is also often used as a finisher or at table, which is what I assume people were voting for. A little extra oregano on top can add a lot of flavor to your pizza.
 
Hah, oregano is the one I was saying earlier I *should've* voted for as sprinkling some on is a great way to kick up a frozen pizza.
 
I'm not sure why I placed oregano so high on my list. I rarely ever order it explicitly but I always like it when it's included and miss it somewhat when it's absent.
 
Never entered my mind. It's something either already in the sauce or you add on after the fact like red pepper flakes or grated parmesan. Not so much a topping but a seasoning.
 
#34
Banana Peppers
66 Points, 3 Lists, Highest Vote: #1 (RT-55J)
wCgT6MEm.jpg

​
Banana peppers are mildly spicy peppers that are generally pickled. They often get lumped in with pepperoncini, but banana peppers have a slight sweetness and thicker skin. I honestly can't say for sure if I've ever had a banana pepper. I've had pepperoncini on sandwiches and maybe a pizza once? So my experience with both on pizza is limited to non-existent, but I can see them being a good pairing with salami and olives.
 
Banana peppers aren't my preferred pizza pepper, but they're a solid choice that I'm always happy to see.
 
Like Flawgic, I've usually had these on the side rather than on the actual pizza, but in general my theory is that hot peppers = good.
 
Back
Top