• Welcome to Talking Time's third iteration! If you would like to register for an account, or have already registered but have not yet been confirmed, please read the following:

    1. The CAPTCHA key's answer is "Percy"
    2. Once you've completed the registration process please email us from the email you used for registration at percyreghelper@gmail.com and include the username you used for registration

    Once you have completed these steps, Moderation Staff will be able to get your account approved.

America's Favorite Non-prehistoric Cartoon Family - The Simpsons Thread

The Commercials
Vol. 6: Butterfinger

Here's the big one. The one that was both very important to both the product and the spokespersons in terms of making a big splash. Butterfinger is a chocolate bar with a flakey peanut butter inside (almost like flakey peanut brittle) covered in chocolate. Now this isn't the first celebrity endorsement. The bar is over 100 years old and their first was actually in a Shirley Temple movie, Baby Take a Bow as prominent product placement. The Simpsons was different. It was different for both.

See, yes, Butterfinger sales rose with the Simpsons ad campaign. But this was also key in raising Simpsons awareness. See, the first ad came out while the Simpsons were still a short on the Tracy Ullman Show. In all honesty, I expected to find an oral history or something online because it is so significant to making people know the Simpsons as characters and I think probably an important role in helping make the show a phenomenon before the show is able to stand on it's own two feet. It started in 1988 and was the show's longest continuing campaign. Though it stopped some time ago, it comes back in different forms from time to time, including Bart and Homer packaging for the 100th anniversary. The Simpsons itself would take potshots at the bar after the campaign but really, even they feel like relative softballs. Personally, while not my favourite bar, I think they are pretty good (though the better version is Crispy Crunch, which you should get if you are in Canada).

The Butterfinger Group
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Well, this is... tricky to gauge. Because when asking "is this the Simpsons", keeping era into account we need to ask "is this Ullman era Simpsons". There are janky looking background characters and that was a thing early in the series (though these ones, even by Jank Simpsons, seem of a very wrong model). Bart saying "neato" and "au contraire mon fraire" is fairly early Simpsons (the narrator seems tickled by "neato". I actually think when comparing to the show at the time, the dialogue is well-written. It feels weird to say because let's face it, it's not funny but it seems of a certain child-wit that works for what this is.

And, of course, this is the first appearance of everyone's favourite sad sack Milhouse, a character design so strong and a pathetic presence so intense, it had stayed with the show, becoming not only a canonical character but one of the most iconic of the non-family members. Now part of the reason that design is so strong is Groening designed him for an abandoned NBC product (which I would love to learn more about) and was re-used for the ad (Groening called him Milhouse after Richard Milhouse Nixon because it was the most unfortunate name he could imagine giving a child).

Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Not only delicious but necessary for survival. It's a cute gag. Milhouse will die now.
Overall
Yeah, there's lots to dunk on in the era. But selling out (the worst sin the 90s can think of) was probably key for early survival with the show. And this is actually a pretty solid ad for the product.
Here's a Comment

The Raid Of Butterfinger BB's scare me this commercial. I don't watch too later days because it's scary.
Wow. Sorry to hear that, dude. Stay strong with whatever the fuck you are talking about.
 
Last edited:
Aw yeah here we go! Incidentally, I don't enjoy the experience of eating a butterfinger, I feel like I could make a mold of my teeth with how much it sticks to them.
 
No Teasing
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Yeah, very Ullman era humour, specifically. It also has the pink gradient from season one where the house is weirdly coloured. Not that the colour pink is weird but some ends of the room are darker than the others. It's also, in the mode of the Ullman era, a "Lisa gets the best of Bart" bit.

Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Hey, everyone want to eat it in the ad.
Overall
This feels like a slight step back from the last one, not in terms of quality but it feels much lower concept than the last one. If anything, this might have made more sense as the first one.
Here's a Comment

Thank you share give lisa butter bart
😀
😉
🍫
🖐
✔
I will NOT give Lisa butter Bart. This concept makes me uncomfortable.
 
The Bully
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Interestingly, this is tonally season 1 but this one actually came out in 91, so we were into season 2 here, at least. Nelson's Haw Haw catchphrase is here but in sort of an undeveloped form.

Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
I think these ads do a good job drawing the bar with detail to make it look good and long.
Overall
It's pretty much conventional Bugs Bunny marketing where someone uses their wits or cool to steal or protect their snack food. Pretty generic
Here's a Comment

THE SIMPSONS
™
&
©
1991 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation.All Rights Reserved.
Who is this on behalf of?
 
Ice Cream on a Stick
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
It's not like the Simpsons never go to the beach but the Simpsons at the beach in ads feels... wrong somehow. Not like a betrayal but a cynical attempt to make them fun in a way that feels calculated. But to make it extra Simpsons, it does the thing where his eyes go one way and the mouth goes the other.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
EVEN BABBY WILL EAT!
Overall
This is basically nothing.
Here's a Comment

You snooze, you loose
I LOOSE
 
Therapy
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Hey, remember Dr. Marvin Monroe? Yeah, he went away after a couple seasons. No one's favourite character designed to represent a certain kind of intellectual, spawned from the 80s obsession with psychiatry in media. He's a bit like Otto, representing an archetype that was already sort of heading into... not irrelevance but certainly diminished relevance. Anyway, he usually represents an authority representing itself as patient and empathetic but really arrogant and quick to losing it. Despite that description, Marvin isn't a big, broad character so apart from how hard the voice is on the throat, I get why he got semi-retired and semi-murdered. And that's the thing. This does feel like early Simpsons gag but even more than usual, Monroe is really quick to anger because a child didn't immediately clue in that he wanted to eat his candy bar.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
EVEN THERAPISTS WILL EAT!
Overall
It's a bit of an odd one. Like, I think there was too much road to pave in 30 seconds and it makes Monroe look extra nuts, even for a snack food commercial glutton.
Here's a Comment

Sonic The hedgehog Nestlé Butterfinger
These are, in fact, words
 
The Shock
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Early Simpsons, sort of but there are two... things here.
zBgtfsr.png

NO! NO NO NO!

I don't like wrong Homer.

The other is...

obA2nmB.png

This little moment of, after the prank is over, Homer seems irreperably damaged and Bart seems to feel REALLY bad about it. It's such a weird little move for the candy commercial.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
DAMAGE YOUR DAD TO PROTECT!
Overall
This is a weird one. Bart really feeling bad seems like a meta-gag in a later season (which they would draw out a bit more to put a point on the idea that slapstick might have sad, lasting effects.) That's not what they are going for here. I guess they want Bart to be slightly less edgy for the ad or something. But to put that button on basic cartoon violence is a weird move, brief as it is.
Here's a Comment

I tried google translate on this. It said "electric". This does not answer my deeper questions.
 
Butterfinger Ice Cream Bars
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Oof. So, Apu's voice sounds wrong. This could be because it is early on because I think this is still Hank Azaria but... the whole thing hasn't aged well to begin with but Apu's voice sounds extra "not cool" here.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
GO IN BOX TO EAT!
Overall
Look, growing up, I liked the Apu character a lot and the writers clearly did too. They gave him a back story and main stories where he is shown to be well-educated, witty and have a lot going on. But going forward, we also saw that having a South Asian man voiced by a white guy and written by non-Indian writers with a "funny" made up long name and "funny" voice is pretty uncool. And here, they lean into the "funny" voice in a way more uncomfortable than the main series. It's subtle but I can tell that it's different. And it's... yeesh.
Here's a Comment

The Simpsons Is Also Owned By The Walt Disney Company.
The energy is "follow me down the rabbit hole", then no actual rabbit hole.
 
I kinda like the animation in this one, it’s very subtly off-model but in a way that I think comes off as very charming and I love that seamless camera spin from the outside of the box to the inside.
 
The Pacifier
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Sure. It's kind of the old kind again and specifically the kind I feel the show used to do where it did take a schoolyard meme. I really don't know what else to call it. It isn't a joke but in the old days, things just spread from kid to kid, which little songs and games having their own variations based on region. I feel like the Simpsons would echo these as a joke until themselves early on before the show became more absurdist. Then they were more likely to parody them or make them up, like the "freak fry", which I feel confident isn't a thing but boy does it feel like it.
I remember kids doing this rhyme (as the giver rather than the recipient) and the question is... did you trust the giver.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
The really put as much detail on a simple bar of chocolate as they can.
Overall
This one isn't that memorable... except for me it is. It's the one of these I've seen the most, for sure. Not sure why that is but I don't recall seeing most of the ads on their original run. Part of it is also in my part of Canada, we didn't get Fox till the mid-90s, with the show playing on a Canadian network MITV (later renamed Global). So I'm wondering if it aired on a Canadian channel or if other non-Fox channels played the ad. Or if it had a long enough run that I caught it in the mid-90s. Anyway, I don't think it's amazing but I can't quite be objective on this one.
Here's a Comment

Well he said surprise, he never said it had to be a butterfinger
I say this unironically and without disdain; I hope you are proud of yourself. You figured out the ad. *hug*
 
The Last Butterfinger
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
There's something about Homer's run here that is pure early Simpsons. I also always find it interesting that Bart is so often used in marketing as "cool guy" when he doesn't play the role that often in the series. He's certainly clever and tricky but in the ads he's like a Bugs Bunny/Tony Hawk hybrid of athleticism and always getting one up on everyone. We have seen a couple exceptions in the ad campaign but I feel like this version of Bart (which is the Bart in many of these ads) is more Bart the t-shirt than Bart the character. Yes, Bart can be like this on the show but that's usually more for a quick bit. Which, to be fair, can also describe these ads. But, understandably, the "ad" Bart is a greatly reduced version of the character. Meanwhile, Homer being portrayed as an oaf really doesn't.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Yeah, it's the classic "two characters want the same product" deal.
Overall
This one is basic stuff but the funny thing is I don't remember "seeing" this ad (though I may have), but I certainly remember the sounds for some reason.

Here's a Comment

I remember this commercial on YouTube in 2011.
Dear God, this is where we are in the nostalgia cycle.
 
Bart's Karate Lesson/Best Friend
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Again, this is "cool Bart". As generic as it is, I do think that this and "The Bully" are smart enough to start with Bart as the bullied party, then turning things around. This is more "commercially" as an arc but it's easy to forget even at this stage where Bart is the cool dude on t-shirts, he is presented as a kid who has to go through some hard stuff in most of his episodes. Having Akira spasming is very Simpsons. The mini-commercial tag at the end is very Simpsons because Milhouse is... just so pathetic.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
EVEN THE KARATE MAN WANTS IT! and milhouse...
Overall
The main commercial isn't that interesting to me though it is also one of the few I do have strong memories of. Akira is one of the more unusual characters to pull since he ended up getting far less play (and then Harry Shearer replaced George Takei as the voice). The little mini-commercial at the end is nothing but it does do a good job of making Milhouse a loser. Points for that. Also, "ice cream nuggets" is the most 90s ass treat ideas.

Here's a Comment

Pre-9/11 stuff.
💲
😎
....this is correct, I guess.
 
Last edited:
Good & Evil
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
This feels like any generic cartoon really. The Simpsons have done "angel/devil on your shoulder" gags from time to time in a meta way but it really feels pretty one note here. This could have been a Smurfs.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
The BBs don't look that appealing to me, really.
Overall
This one is pretty weak. It feels weird to have the moral conundrum when no one is asking for the candy.

Here's a Comment

This was the only post but it's pretty reasonable.
 
Bart's Homework
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Hey, Lisa is here. Yeah, I mean it's pretty basic stuff but I like this better than Bart is jumping into trees and beating up karate guys.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
I'm still not getting into these BBs. Part of it is the crunch sounds makes it sound more like what I feel a Crunchie Bar would sound like, which is a bar filled with sponge toffee.
Cadbury-crunchie-chocolate-candy-funhouse.jpg

Overall
I don't mind this one but I don't have a lot of thoughts on it. At least Lisa is getting some play.
 
The Beach
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
It's weird because it is but the Homer being beset by crabs feels like a lazier latterday joke without the extra button of irony on it. But then the image of Bart at the beach with zinc on his nose feels like the most 1991 unlicensed t-shirt you can find in Australia.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
I guess it doesn't melt in the hot sun, so that's good.
Overall
Not a strong one but the addition of crabs helps a little, I guess. I mean, not great but the image of them emerging from his sand body is unique at least.

Here's a Comment

The Simpsons joining us in:The Emperor's New GrooveScooby DooThe Rugrats MovieThe Road to El DoradoShrekThe SpongeBob SquarePants MovieToy StoryToy Story 2Toy Story 3Jimmy Neutron: Boy GeniusTreasure PlanetJetsons: The MovieA Bug's LifeMadagascarThe Nightmare Before Christmas (30th Anniversary/Halloween Special)Elf (20th Anniversary Special)Home Alone (Christmas Special)Star Wars: The Phantom MenaceThe Hunchback of Notre DameShrek 2 (20th Anniversary Special)Over the HedgeThe Secret Life of PetsThe SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of WaterInside OutQuillo accidentally switches on the television nearly waking up Gladys Sharp with trailers for:Atlantis: The Lost EmpireThe Little MermaidSouth Park: Bigger, Longer & UncutThe Rugrats MovieChicken RunHappily N'Ever AfterJetsons: The MovieThe SpongeBob SquarePants MovieTreasure PlanetStar Wars: The Empire Strikes BackThe Cat in the Hat (2003)BarnyardRobotsCars (because Despicable Me added "The Polar Express", when joining The Lion King and Toy Story for a trailer for "Ice Age" during "A Christmas Story" on December 24, 2022)ShrekAll Dogs Go to HeavenSon of the MaskAntzShark TaleIndependence Day (Summer Special)Toy StoryThe WildStar Wars: The Phantom MenaceAnastasiaThe Great Mouse DetectiveThe Nightmare Before Christmas (30th Anniversary/Halloween Special)JumanjiThe Emperor's New GrooveMadagascarHome Alone (Christmas Special)Spider ManThe Hunchback of Notre DameJames and the Giant Peach (with the help of "Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron", "Ice Age", "The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie", "Ratatouille", "Monsters, Inc.", "Finding Nemo", "Madagascar", "The Rugrats Movie" and "How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000)" on May 9, 2024)Shrek 2 (with the help of "Ice Age", "The Simpsons Movie", "The Polar Express", "The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie", "Ratatouille", "Monsters, Inc.", "Finding Nemo", "Madagascar", "Lilo & Stitch", "The Rugrats Movie" and "How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000)" on May 12 and 23, 2024)The Lost World: Jurassic ParkToy Story 2Hoodwinked (with the help of "Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron", "The Simpsons Movie", "The Polar Express", "Ratatouille", "Monsters, Inc.", "Madagascar", "Lilo & Stitch", "The Rugrats Movie" and "How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000)" on May 17 and 30, 2024, because Pumbaa unexpectedly sits on the remote and changes the channel to a trailer for "Over the Hedge" in "Timon and Pumbaa Interrupt 3 Ice Age II: The Meltdown")The Secret Life of PetsThe SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of WaterThe Lego MovieToy Story 3Inside OutRichard and George watching as Suede is the look for this fall part:The Simpsons MovieShrekThe Prince of EgyptSinbad: Legend of the Seven SeasIndependence Day (Summer Special)Monsters, Inc.RobotsIce AgeAnastasiaAn American TailAntzLilo & StitchThe Nightmare Before Christmas (30th Anniversary/Halloween Special)The Emperor's New GrooveHow the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000) (Christmas Special)Home Alone (Christmas Special)Inside OutThe Hunchback of Notre DameThe SpongeBob SquarePants MovieShrek 2 (20th Anniversary Special)Over the HedgeThe Secret Life of PetsTangledBarnyardLittlefoot's Adventures of Aladdin - The Tigger Movie and The Lion King II: Simba's PrideLittlefoot's Adventures of The Lion King - Toy Story, The Tigger Movie and The Lion King II: Simba's PrideLittlefoot Meets Tarzan - The Tigger Movie, Dinosaur and The Lion King II: Simba's PrideLittlefoot's Search for The Black Cauldron - DinosaurLittlefoot's Adventures of The Nightmare Before Christmas - DinosaurLittlefoot's Adventures of The Jungle Book - The Tigger Movie, Dinosaur, The Lion King II: Simba's Pride and George of the JungleLittlefoot's Adventures of The Little Mermaid - Toy Story, The Tigger Movie, The Lion King II: Simba's Pride and George of the JungleLittlefoot's Adventures of Sleeping Beauty - The Tigger Movie, The Lion King II: Simba's Pride and George of the JungleLittlefoot's Adventures of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - DinosaurLittlefoot's Adventures of The Great Mouse Detective - DinosaurLittlefoot's Adventures of DuckTales the Movie: Treasure of the Lost Lamp - DinosaurLittlefoot and Pooh's Grand Adventure: The Search for Christopher Robin - The Tigger Movie and DinosaurLittlefoot Meets The Fox and the Hound - The Tigger Movie, The Lion King II: Simba's Pride and George of the JungleLittlefoot's Adventures of A Bug's Life - Dinosaur and The Lion King II: Simba's PrideCrocodile Beat (7 versions on disc with the help from Reader Rabbit, Sam the Lion, Mat the Mouse and Charlie the Chipmunk)Polar Bear, Polar Bear, What Do You Hear? (3 versions including an audio CD)Going to the Zoo (with the photo of Reader Rabbit, Sam the Lion, Mat the Mouse and Charlie the Chipmunk)Animal Action ABC (with the photo of Reader Rabbit, Sam the Lion, Mat the Mouse and Charlie the Chipmunk)Saturday Night at the Dinosaur Stomp (with the photo of Reader Rabbit, Sam the Lion, Mat the Mouse and Charlie the Chipmunk)We're Going on a Bear Hunt (another audio CD and 3 other versions with the help from Reader Rabbit, Sam the Lion, Mat the Mouse and Charlie the Chipmunk)Chicka Chicka Boom Boom (PC for Mac OS X, Windows XP, Windows 95/98 including a bonus song - "Where's Z?" - which involves letter Z playing hide-and-seek in the tree, while the rest of the alphabet goes to find it)Snap! (with Brock Zuyderwyk reviewing the book with page footages)
Even for Bot-slop, a lot of this is particularly confusing)
 
Bart's Locker
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Oh, this one is weird and prophetic. Basically, it feels like a microcosm version of the big act 2 break of Grade School Confidential, which is pretty wild (and a great episode). Also Marcia Wallace are in the episode. Apart from that, I do want to talk about what I find a bit weird about it in the Overall section but more than that Krabappel and Skinner taking delight on taking Bart down is somewhat in character, but I always feel like it's contextual and it... feels slightly off here, despite the acting actually being pretty strong (mostly, because Marcia feels truly gleeful).
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Hey, you can buy them by the box.
Overall
OK, my issue here is... I'm not sure where they are coming from. Are they simply wanting to steal Bart's candy? I feel like that would definitely be a Krabappel move. Krabappel is a character who both can have integrity but also sometimes puts it to the side because she is also somewhat cynical and burnt out. But I feel like it would be more casual than some kind of heist (Skinner's morality is also malleable but he is consistently a square).

Or is... this breaking a rule? What rule? Having too many chocolate bars? I guess I don't get the motivation of these characters. I think maybe the people working on it needed to get to the action and not the reason. 30 seconds is both very little time and a lot of time in the world of ads. You got to lay a lot of groundwork. But I will say, despite the motivation being unclear (it's easy not to think about because "someone stealing my food" is most ads of the era, so the hand wavy nature makes sense since only weirdos like me are going to care), it does feel well paced and not too sweaty-feeling. So, decent ad.
 
I've Been Robbed
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
There's Simpsons in there. The cadence and rhythm of the Chief Wiggum section is very on brand. But then the huge cartoon goon who steals those Butterfingers feels very much like some Tom and Jerry stuff.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
The focus seems more on the contest here.
Overall
Man, remember these contests? They don't do that anymore. I feel like every other week we were being asked to find out who stole Cap'n Crunch's hat or who stole Lucky the Leprechaun's gold or who stole Dig 'Em's... hat. I ran out of things to steal. In the post-"mascots on TV shilling junk food" age, these are relics of the past. Seems like the contest has the advantage of characters we are familiar with at any rate.
Here's a Comment

Butterfinger
Accurate
 
I've Been Robbed
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
There's Simpsons in there. The cadence and rhythm of the Chief Wiggum section is very on brand. But then the huge cartoon goon who steals those Butterfingers feels very much like some Tom and Jerry stuff.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
The focus seems more on the contest here.
Overall
Man, remember these contests? They don't do that anymore. I feel like every other week we were being asked to find out who stole Cap'n Crunch's hat or who stole Lucky the Leprechaun's gold or who stole Dig 'Em's... hat. I ran out of things to steal. In the post-"mascots on TV shilling junk food" age, these are relics of the past. Seems like the contest has the advantage of characters we are familiar with at any rate.
Here's a Comment


Accurate
So who was the culprit?
 
Crime of the Century
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Wow, these are some expressive Simpsons. In that respect, it's Simpsony
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
It's more about the prize here.
Overall
There's a lot I want to unpack. Are the people outside the courthouse... simply advocating Butterfinger, the candy? What is happening here?

Bart feels betrayed to an unwarranted degree here. The animators make it look like "he created a fake record label to end your singing career" level of sad. And moreso when it is Krusty.

URcDQLJ.png
KP6PtRH.png

It is odd to go this hard but I LOVE this choice. This is not a phoned in ad. The animators are like "I think I can hurt Bart's heart more to have him learn someone took his 99 cent (in 1993 dollars) chocolate bar." Yes, they thought the words 1993 dollars!

The reveal actually, in the words of Hermes Conrad, raise further questions. Krusty was already caught. He's literally tied up and being wheeled around. What was plan b? Go to jail as Homer while Homer is just walking the streets? Where was this going, Krusty?

Anyway, this is all well animated, particularly Krusty's facial expressions as he falls down the court steps. Bart pretty much forgets this betrayal to wear a trenchcoat and talk to camera. So he's gotten over it.
Here's a Comment

Ned beat up Krusty and tied and ducttaped him to the cart. I'm sure Ned bullied Krusty.
Are... you still trying to win this contest?
 
The Dog Biscuit
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Yeah, but again, this is one of their cornier bits.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Butterfinger: Better than a dog biscuit!
Overall
I like that this feels slightly more high concept, though it's not particularly strong. And this time, it's Santa's Little Helper feels betrayed.
Here's a Comment

Do you have any Unsolved Mysteries episodes/segments?
Good question. Good, very unrelated question.
 
I'm reminded of something I heard from one of the director commentaries that the animators liked scenes with them in the dark like that because it was really easy to animate.
 
The Raid
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
This feels a less like it in certain broader terms but it fits with the way nightmares are often staged on the show and the creepy way Smithers is feeding Burns.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Sorry Butterfinger, I still can't get behind BBs for some reason. I don't even think it's the taste. They don't look unappealing in the ads but they also aren't appealing either. There's something about the texture of how the chocolate bar is drawn that works for me more than smooth balls.
Overall
I think this one is decent on a visual level (though weirdly not as good as the Krusty reveal from a few commercials back) but that's about it.
Here's a Comment

I thought chocolate kill dogs
Grammar aside, this is a point that I missed out on. But also it's a dream. I don't think we are expected to watch a commercial of a boy dreaming of a dog who slowly dies to sell candy balls.
 
Maggie's Party
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
This one feels like it is not trying too hard to be the Simpsons. Who are these other babies? Clearly they didn't have that Milhouse rizz that skyrocketed him to popularity.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
They look OK, I guess.
Overall
This is a pretty forgettable one.
 
Hit a Homer
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Slightly but it's more commercially. Hit a Homer as a pun is used a number of times, one being Homer giving a chef's kiss to the Pin Pals for rhyming Homer and Homer and my personal favourite from, I believe, The Boys of Bummer (a really solid episode from one of the lesser seasons) where the little league announcer talks about Bart hitting homers and states "coincidentally, Bart's father's name is, you guessed it, not in our files."
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Back to bar. In animation, the bar looks more delectable than the balls.
Overall
Pretty lazy one, especially for one of the later commercials where you would think with the show's heavy irony levels established, they might start to play with the formula.
Here's a Comment

Sure, buddy.
 
Philosophy
The Commercial:

Is it... The Simpsons?
Hey, the writers get to show off their college education. Or they made up a quote, which would be funny.
Did it Make the Product/Brand Look Good?
Again, BBs are just there. Gimme a bar.
Overall
Getting brainy does get to have a slightly different tone but not enough to make it rise above fine. This is also the era where the look of the Simpson is really streamlined so the animation isn't as interesting as it was before.
Here's a Comment

I won't deny this but what specifically?
 
Back
Top